Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part V: Screen/CIM Literacy

Lesson 5.5.2

The Three Moves of a Sell-Side CIM

Narrow your objection to a strawman and knock it down, sell the engine rather than the contracts, and re-label the earnings. Read a CIM as an engineered document with a target, and the target is you.

Lesson 6 of 6 in this part · 7 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How should a buyer read a broker's confidential information memorandum?

Read it as a persuasive document aimed at you, prepared by the seller's representative to draw an offer near the asking price. Watch for three moves: answering an easier version of your objection, selling a sales engine instead of contracts, and re-labeling earnings. For every claim, ask whether a contract, a verified history or a story stands behind it. Price contracts, test history, and do not pay for stories.

A confidential information memorandum (CIM) reads like a description. It is not one. It is a persuasive document, prepared by the seller's representative, built to move a specific reader to a specific action: an offer near the asking price. Once you can see how it is built, you can read it for what it leaves out, which is usually where the deal is. This lesson names the three moves that do most of the work in a sell-side CIM, shows each one in a real-looking broker memo, and gives you a way to read any CIM against its own design.

Principle

Read a CIM as an engineered document with a target. The target is you.

That is not an accusation. The seller's broker works for the seller, is usually paid when the business sells, and is doing exactly the job the seller hired them for: presenting the business in its best light. The problem is not the broker. It is the reader who forgets who wrote the page. Research on acquisitions of entrepreneurial firms found that buyers and sellers hold asymmetric views of each other's trustworthiness, that those beliefs are often wrong, and that the asymmetries shape behavior, including tendencies to deceive and to guard against deception (C6, 2009). You are on one side of that asymmetry. Read accordingly.

Even the softest parts of a CIM are doing work. A 2023 study combining business-for-sale listings with an experiment found that the stated reason for a sale acts as a signal and affects the price at exit (C9, 2023). "Retiring after 30 great years" is not a neutral sentence. It is chosen.

Most persuasive CIMs lean on three moves.

Move 1: Narrow your objection to a strawman, then knock it down. The CIM anticipates the obvious worry and answers an easier version of it. You leave the page feeling the worry was addressed. It was not; a smaller cousin of it was.

Move 2: Sell the engine, not the contracts. Instead of showing you what customers are committed to buy, the CIM shows you the machine that has produced sales in the past: a relationship, a reputation, a referral source, a market trend. Engines are real. But you cannot assign an engine in a purchase agreement, and a lender cannot underwrite one.

Move 3: Re-label the earnings. The profit figure carries a name it has not earned. The most common version is SDE, seller's discretionary earnings, presented as "adjusted EBITDA," which lesson 5.5.1 covers in full.

The defense against all three is the same: for every claim, ask what kind of evidence stands behind it, a contract, a verified history, or a story. Price contracts. Test history. Do not pay for stories.

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Its seller's broker sends a one-page earnings summary with a short section headed "Why we love this business." Here are the three moves in it.

Move 1: the strawman

The memo states plainly that fiscal 2025 "was the Company's strongest year ever and is presented as the go-forward earnings base." Then it reassures you on recurring revenue: "800+ recurring maintenance agreements provide predictable repeat revenue." And on the owner: "Owner willing to stay on for a short transition."

Look at what was answered and what was not. The real objections are will 2025 repeat? and who does the owner's three jobs after he leaves? The memo answers different, easier questions: does this business have any recurring revenue? (yes) and will the owner help hand over? (yes, briefly). Neither answer touches the real worry. The P&L notes do: the 2025 jump came from a single commercial new-construction contract and from homeowners replacing systems early, ahead of an announced equipment price increase tied to the refrigerant transition. Neither repeats.

The transition answer is weaker than it sounds for a second reason. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026 (Y25), in an Initial Acquisition, where a buyer purchases 100 percent of the business with an SBA 7(a) loan, the seller may not stay on as an officer, director, stockholder or employee; the business may contract with him as a consultant for no more than 24 months in total. "A short transition" is not a plan for replacing a general manager, a lead salesperson and a dispatcher.

Move 2: the engine

"A strong relationship with a major local homebuilder that continues to refer new work." That sentence sells an engine. Check what stands behind it: no contract appears in the package; the big job the relationship produced is finished; and the balance sheet notes the same homebuilder is about 38 percent of year-end receivables, the money customers still owe. Revenue by customer, once you ask for it, shows the builder at about 16 percent of fiscal 2025 revenue and about 3 percent in each of the two years before. What looks like a growth engine is a single referral channel (red flag RF-12) that produced a one-time peak.

The maintenance agreements are the opposite case: those are contracts. So test them like contracts. The balance sheet notes about 810 active plans and shows $57,000 of deferred revenue for them, which is the next twelve months of prepaid service not yet delivered at year end, not their annual revenue. Ask for annual plan revenue, the renewal rate, and the price per plan. Contracts earn a premium only after you have counted them.

Move 3: the re-label

The earnings summary is headed "Seller's Discretionary / Adjusted EBITDA," and the number under it, $1,710,000, adds back the owner's full salary and the spouse's full pay, plus $60,000 of "projected rent savings" from a move that has not happened. Two names for one number, and a forecast inside it. Lesson 5.5.1 rebuilds it to about $1,017,000 of recurring earnings.

Put the three moves together and the design is clear. Move 1 keeps you from asking whether the peak repeats. Move 2 gives you a reason to believe it will. Move 3 multiplies the peak by a price. Each move is mild. Together they are worth more than two and a half million dollars of asking price.

Steps

1. Write your objections before you open the CIM

From your public-data screen (lesson 5.4.1) and your quick screen (lesson 5.1.1), write the three to five things most likely to be wrong with this business. Do this first. Once you have read the CIM, its framing becomes your framing.

2. Find where the CIM addresses each objection, and compare

For each objection on your list, find the passage that addresses it. Then ask: does this answer my question, or a smaller one? Mark each as answered, narrowed (Move 1) or ignored. A narrowed or ignored objection goes straight onto your question list, worded exactly as you first wrote it.

3. Build a claim ledger

List every factual claim in the CIM about revenue, customers, growth, people and earnings. Next to each, write the kind of evidence behind it:

Evidence type What it looks like What you do
Contract A signed agreement, a backlog schedule, a recurring billing roster Count it and verify it. It can carry value
History Three years of P&Ls and tax returns, revenue by customer, a tied bank statement Test it against source documents (lesson 6.2.2)
Story "Strong relationship," "loyal customers," "untapped potential," "continues to refer" Ask for the contract or the history behind it. Until you have one, it is worth nothing in your model

Engine language (Move 2) almost always lands in the story column. Your task is to move each claim to contract or history, or strike it.

4. Read every earnings label literally

Find the heading of every earnings figure. If it blends SDE and EBITDA, or adds back pay for anyone who works in the business, rebuild it with the bridge from lesson 5.5.1 before you compute a multiple.

5. Read the reason for sale as a claim too

Note the stated reason and test it the way you test everything else. Does the timeline fit? Do the documents show the owner winding down, or a final-year peak? A clean reason is pleasant. A verified one is useful.

6. Send the questions in writing

Send the narrowed and ignored objections, plus every story-column claim you need converted, as one written list. Keep it short and specific. The answers, or the gaps in them, become the first rows of your red flag register (lesson 5.2.1).

Deliverable

A CIM counter-read for each deal, two pages at most:

  • Your pre-read objection list, each marked answered, narrowed or ignored, with the CIM page.
  • The claim ledger: each claim, its evidence type, and what you will request to verify it.
  • Every earnings label in the CIM, read literally, with your rebuilt figure beside it.
  • The stated reason for sale and what the documents say about it.
  • The written question list as sent.

Keep the counter-read next to the CIM in your file. When diligence starts, it tells your CPA and attorney where the document was built to steer you away from.

This lesson is education, not legal or investment advice. Your attorney and a licensed CPA should review the seller's materials and the representations you will rely on before you sign a letter of intent.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

Who does a business broker work for, the buyer or the seller?

The seller. The seller's broker is usually paid when the business sells and is doing the job the seller hired them for: presenting the business in its best light. That is not an accusation. The problem is the reader who forgets who wrote the page.

Can the seller stay on after an SBA-financed business sale?

Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, in an Initial Acquisition, where a buyer purchases 100 percent of the business with an SBA 7(a) loan, the seller may not stay on as an officer, director, stockholder or employee. The business may contract with him as a consultant for no more than 24 months in total. A short transition is not a plan for replacing the owner's roles.

What should I do before I read a CIM?

Write the three to five things most likely to be wrong with the business, drawn from your own screens, before you open it. Once you have read the CIM, its framing becomes your framing. Then mark each objection as answered, narrowed or ignored, and send the narrowed and ignored ones as written questions.

Does the seller's reason for selling a business matter?

Yes. A 2023 study combining business-for-sale listings with an experiment found that the stated reason for a sale acts as a signal and affects the price at exit. Treat the reason as a claim and test it: does the timeline fit, and do the documents show the owner winding down or a final-year peak?

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C6

    Graebner, M. E. (2009). Caveat venditor: Trust asymmetries in acquisitions of entrepreneurial firms. Academy of Management Journal, 52(3), 435-472.

  2. C9

    Krukowski, K. A., Flink, N. A., & Edwards, B. D. (2023). Why are you selling your business?. Understanding signaling effects of seller rationale at time of entrepreneurial exit. Journal of Business Venturing Insights, 20, e00427.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.

You have read Part V

Now put it to work.

Step 2

Play chapter 5: Screen: fifteen minutes and a rubric

The broker's package for Coastal Comfort lands on a Saturday night. Screen it, read the memo for what it was built to do, raise the flags and score the deal. Then decide whether it has earned the work of underwriting.

Step 3

Practise: the assignment

One assignment for this part, posted in the community where other buyers check your work.