Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part V: Screen/The Fifteen-Minute Quick Screen

Lesson 5.1.1

Six Checkpoints, Three Kill Switches

Buy-box fit, trajectory and customer concentration are the kill switches; owner role, add-back smell and asking-price sanity follow. Each screen ends in a verdict: pursue, investigate, or pass.

Lesson 1 of 6 in this part · 10 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How do I quickly screen a CIM to decide whether a business is worth pursuing?

Run six checkpoints in a fixed order and stop when a kill switch fails. Buy-box fit, trajectory and customer concentration are kill switches: fail one and you pass. Then judge the owner's role, the add-backs and the asking multiple. Any visible deal-killer ends the screen at once. Finish with one sentence: pursue, investigate or pass, the business name, and the single reason.

A confidential information memorandum (CIM) is the marketing document a broker prepares to sell a business: a history, a set of financial summaries, a list of reasons to buy. It tends to arrive late on a Saturday night, and it is written to be read slowly and admired. Do neither. This lesson gives you a fifteen-minute screen with six checkpoints, run in a fixed order, that ends in one of three verdicts: pursue, investigate, or pass.

The point is not speed for its own sake. Over a search you will open dozens of these documents, and most of them describe businesses you should never buy. The three hours you would spend admiring the wrong one come out of the time you need for the right one.

Principle

Fifteen minutes with a CIM is a decision, not a reading assignment. You are not trying to understand the business yet. You are trying to find out whether it deserves the work that understanding would take.

A few terms first, in plain words:

  • Your buy box is your written description of what you will buy: industry, geography and size. You built it in Part III. If it is not written down, the screen cannot work, because every deal will look like it might fit.
  • EBITDA is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization: the profit from running the business before financing costs and the paper cost of aging equipment.
  • A multiple is the price divided by earnings. A $4,000,000 asking price on $1,000,000 of earnings is a 4x multiple.

The screen has six checkpoints, and the order matters. The first three are kill switches. Fail any one and you stop. They come first because they are cheap to check and because no price fixes them:

  1. Buy-box fit. The wrong industry, geography or size is not a negotiating point. It is a different search.
  2. Trajectory. Shrinking revenue, a loss, or a margin falling off a cliff means you would be buying a decline with borrowed money.
  3. Customer concentration. One customer over 40 percent of revenue means you would be buying a single relationship you do not own.

The next three are judgment checks. They rarely kill a deal alone, but they decide whether the deal is a pursue or an investigate:

  1. The owner's role. Does the business run without the owner in the building?
  2. Add-back smell. Does the earnings figure the price is built on look like history, or like hope?
  3. Asking-price sanity. Is the multiple in the range businesses like this one actually trade at?

One standing override rides along the whole fifteen minutes: any single visible deal-killer ends the screen at the moment you see it. An unresolved lawsuit, a lapsed license, a lease about to expire on a location that is the business, a family dispute over who owns what. You do not finish the checklist to be polite to a dead deal. This is Gate 1 of the Walk-Away Doctrine (/walk-away).

Why trust the screen over the story? Because the story was written for you to believe it. The asking price is an opening position, not a measurement: a 2026 study of small business acquisitions found that businesses sold for significantly less than the seller's asking price during periods of high economic uncertainty (C11, 2026). And the earnings under that price were reported by someone with a reason to shape them. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer the business outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55, 2023). You are outside the family.

Every screen ends in one sentence: PURSUE / INVESTIGATE / PASS, business name, the single reason. If you cannot write the sentence, you have not finished the screen.

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Every number here is invented, but every pattern comes from the failure record.

Your buy box, set months earlier, reads: services businesses on Florida's Space and Treasure Coasts, $2,000,000 to $8,000,000 of revenue, owner-operated, ten or more years in business. On a Saturday night the seller's broker sends a summary for Coastal Comfort: $6,675,000 of revenue in fiscal 2025, "record" growth of 25 percent, and an asking price of $6,450,000, which the broker describes as 3.8 times $1,710,000 of "Seller's Discretionary / Adjusted EBITDA." Attached are three years of profit and loss statements (the P&L, which shows revenue, costs and profit for each year) and a balance sheet.

Here is the screen, run in order:

# Checkpoint What the documents show Result
1 Buy-box fit Palm Bay, Florida; HVAC services; $6.68M revenue; founded 2009 Pass
2 Trajectory Fiscal 2023 to 2025: revenue $4.80M, $5.33M, $6.68M. Reported EBITDA $714K, $857K, $1,308K. Margin 14.9%, 16.1%, 19.6% Pass, with a note: the last year breaks the trend
3 Concentration No customer list in the package. The balance sheet notes one homebuilder is about 38% of year-end receivables, the money customers still owe Yellow: unknown, ask
4 Owner's role P&L Note 1: the owner is "full-time working manager (sales, dispatch, and largest-job supervision)." No general manager on payroll Yellow, leaning fail
5 Add-back smell $402,000 of add-backs, including the owner's whole salary with nothing subtracted to replace him, and $60,000 of "projected rent savings" Strong smell
6 Asking price 3.8x the broker's adjusted figure; 4.9x the reported $1,308,000 Yellow

Nothing kills the deal at minute fifteen. Nothing clears it either. The verdict:

INVESTIGATE, Coastal Comfort HVAC: a 25 percent jump in the final year, priced on add-backs that include a forecast.

The two questions that go to the broker on Monday: What drove the 2025 increase, and will it repeat? Please send revenue by customer for 2024 and 2025. And: Who performs the owner's sales, dispatch and supervision work after closing, and at what cost?

The answer to the first question settles checkpoint 3. Revenue by customer shows the homebuilder, Beachline, billed about $1,080,000 in fiscal 2025, about 16 percent of revenue: the $930,000 Harbor Pointe townhome project plus about $150,000 of other work. In each of the two years before, it was about $150,000, about 3 percent. On the number the kill switch tests, share of revenue, Coastal Comfort passes: 16 percent is well under 30. The finding is somewhere else. One project made the year, the same customer is 38 percent of what is still owed, and no contract appears in the package. That goes into the red flag register in lesson 5.2.1.

Those two questions turn out to be the whole deal. The 2025 jump came from one commercial job and from homeowners replacing systems early, ahead of an announced equipment price increase tied to the refrigerant transition, and the recurring earnings a new owner can expect sit near $1,017,000, not $1,710,000. Part VI does that work in full, and then tests even that figure against fiscal 2024's margin, because checkpoint 2's broken trend does not disappear just because the spike came out. The screen's job was only to point at it, and in fifteen minutes it did.

Steps

Before any CIM arrives

  1. Write your buy box on one page. Industry, geography, revenue or earnings range. Keep it beside you when you screen.
  2. Write down the normal multiple range for your target industry and size before you see a single asking price. Build it from sources that are not selling you anything: conversations with the SBA lenders you met in Part III, the pricing references in the Library, and comparable sales your advisors have seen. Once a broker's number is in your head, it anchors you.
  3. Build a one-page screen template with the six checkpoints, a result column (pass, yellow, fail) and a verdict line. Duplicate it for every deal.
  4. Start a screening log: date, business, source, revenue, earnings, asking price, verdict, reason, next action. Every deal you screen goes in it, including the ones you pass on in four minutes.

The fifteen minutes

Set a timer. Work in this order.

Checkpoint 1: Buy-box fit (about one minute). Industry, geography, size. Any one wrong is a pass. Do not talk yourself into "close enough." A business outside your box is outside the experience your lender is underwriting and outside the thesis you have spent months building.

Checkpoint 2: Trajectory (about ninety seconds). Put three years of revenue and EBITDA side by side. Calculate the margin, EBITDA divided by revenue, for each year.

  • Revenue shrinking, a loss in any recent year, or a margin collapsing: fail.
  • Flat revenue with a holding margin: yellow.
  • Stable or growing: pass, but write a note if the final year breaks the trend in either direction. A sudden jump right before a sale is the most common reason a pass here turns into trouble later.

Checkpoint 3: Customer concentration (about ninety seconds). Find the single largest customer's share of revenue.

  • Over 40 percent: fail.
  • 30 to 40 percent: yellow.
  • Under 30 percent: pass.
  • Not disclosed: yellow, and the request for revenue by customer goes into your questions.

The screen is stricter than the full red flag library in lesson 5.2.1, which treats concentration over 50 percent as critical. That is deliberate. At minute fifteen you do not know whether there is a contract behind the relationship, and you should not spend three hours finding out on a deal where one customer is nearly half the business.

Checkpoint 4: The owner's role (about ninety seconds). Read the org chart, the key-employee list, any note on what the owner does, and the owner's stated role after closing.

  • The owner holds the license, the key relationships and the daily decisions, with no second-in-command: yellow to fail.
  • A real manager or team below the owner, and a transition plan that fits: pass.

Checkpoint 5: Add-back smell (about ninety seconds). An add-back is an expense the seller says will not continue under a new owner, added back to profit. Subtract reported EBITDA from the seller's adjusted figure and look at what the gap is made of. You are not grading each item yet (lesson 6.2.1 does that). You are sniffing for:

  • Anything that has not happened: projected savings, planned cost cuts, expected price increases. A forecast is never an add-back.
  • The owner's whole salary added back with nothing subtracted for the person who will do the owner's job.
  • "One-time" items that look like normal operating costs.
  • A label that blends terms, such as "discretionary" and "EBITDA" in the same heading. Lesson 5.5.1 explains why that matters.

One forecast in the list, or an owner salary added back in full: yellow. Several: treat the adjusted figure as unusable and screen on reported EBITDA instead.

Checkpoint 6: Asking-price sanity (about ninety seconds). Divide the asking price by the seller's adjusted figure, then by reported EBITDA. Compare both to the range you wrote down before the CIM arrived.

  • Inside the range on reported earnings: pass.
  • Inside the range only on the seller's adjusted figure: yellow. The price depends on add-backs you have not tested.
  • Far above the range, roughly one and a half times the normal multiple or more: yellow, leaning pass. The asking price is aspirational, and the gap is a negotiation you may not want to have.

The verdict

  • PURSUE. All three kill switches pass and no more than one judgment check is yellow. Book the broker call and move to the red flag library in lesson 5.2.1.
  • INVESTIGATE. No kill switch failed, but something material is unknown or yellow. Send two specific written questions, no more. A list of twenty questions at this stage tells the broker you are a tourist.
  • PASS. A kill switch failed or a deal-killer is visible. Send a short, respectful decline within a day. Brokers remember buyers who answer quickly and clearly, and the next listing from that broker may be the one you want.

Write the one-sentence verdict in your log before you close the file.

Two habits that keep the screen honest

Do not reopen a pass without a written reason. If a deal comes back to you weeks later, write down what changed about the deal. If the honest answer is that nothing changed except your bank balance or your patience, the pass stands.

Time yourself. If screens are regularly taking an hour, you are underwriting, not screening. Underwriting is Part VI, and it is reserved for deals that earned it.

Deliverable

For every CIM or broker summary you receive:

  • A completed one-page Quick Screen with the six checkpoints, the evidence for each, and pass, yellow or fail.
  • The one-sentence verdict: PURSUE / INVESTIGATE / PASS, business name, the single reason.
  • If INVESTIGATE, the two written questions you sent.
  • A row in your screening log.

After your first twenty screens, read the log back. Count your verdicts and the reasons behind them. If most passes fail checkpoint 1, your sourcing is pulling deals outside your buy box, and Part IV is where to fix it.

This lesson is education, not investment advice. A purchase decision should rest on full diligence with a licensed CPA and an attorney, not on a screen.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What is a CIM when buying a business?

A confidential information memorandum, or CIM, is the marketing document a broker prepares to sell a business: a history, a set of financial summaries and a list of reasons to buy. It is written to persuade. Treat fifteen minutes with it as a decision about whether the business deserves more work, not as a reading assignment.

How much customer concentration is too much when buying a small business?

At the screening stage, one customer over 40 percent of revenue is a fail, 30 to 40 percent is a yellow, and under 30 percent passes. If the share is not disclosed, mark it yellow and ask for revenue by customer. The screen is deliberately strict, because you do not yet know whether a contract stands behind the relationship.

How do I know if a business's asking price is reasonable?

Write down the normal multiple range for your industry and size before you see any asking price. Then divide the ask by the seller's adjusted figure and by reported EBITDA. Inside the range on reported earnings passes. Inside only on the adjusted figure is a yellow, because the price depends on add-backs you have not tested.

How many questions should I send a broker after reading a CIM?

Two specific written questions, no more, when your verdict is investigate. A list of twenty at this stage tells the broker you are a tourist. If the verdict is pass, send a short, respectful decline within a day. Brokers remember buyers who answer quickly and clearly.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C11

    Kasten, C. L., Lambert, C. A., & Osborne, B. N. (2026). Small business valuations during uncertain times. Journal of Small Business Management, 64(5), 1999-2031.

  2. C55

    Umans, I., & Corten, M (2023). Ownership succession intentions affecting earnings management in private family firms. Small Business Economics, 61(2), 827-842.