A deal that survives the fifteen-minute screen in lesson 5.1.1 has earned a closer look, not your trust. This lesson is the closer look: twelve red flags, each with what it looks like in the financials, the exact question to put to the seller, and the decision rule. The same twelve run through this whole curriculum, numbered RF-01 to RF-12, so that a flag you raise at the screen is the same flag your diligence team confirms and the same flag your purchase agreement prices.
The library is online at /red-flags, one page per flag, and the Red Flag Screener walks you through it deal by deal. This lesson teaches you to use it with judgment.
Principle
A red flag is a hypothesis, not a verdict. You raise it from what you see in the documents. You confirm or clear it with evidence. Only then does its severity decide what you do.
Every flag carries one of three severities, and each severity has exactly one rule:
| Severity | Rule | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Critical | Walk if verified | The risk is the business. No price makes it safe to borrow against. |
| Moderate | Negotiate hard or walk | The risk is real and can be priced or structured, if the seller will move. |
| Low | Price it in and proceed carefully | The risk changes the number, not the decision. |
The severity tells you what to do once the flag is verified. It does not tell you to walk the moment you suspect something. An unexplained jump in legal fees is a reason to ask about litigation, not proof of a lawsuit. And the reverse: a flag the seller cannot or will not explain is treated as verified. Silence and evasion are evidence.
Three more rules sit under the library.
Ask in writing. Every seller question below goes in an email or a written request list, and every answer goes in your file. A verbal "no, nothing like that" is worth nothing at closing. A written answer becomes the basis for a representation in the purchase agreement, which is the seller's contractual promise that a statement is true.
Expect the flags to be dressed. The incentive to present the business well peaks in the year before a sale. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer ownership outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55, 2023). Several flags below (working capital, deferred capex, add-backs) are exactly where that management shows up.
Concentration kills, in every model. Even in traditional search funds, which buy with investor capital and a board, a 2026 IESE note on search fund failures names customer concentration among the causes and recommends assessing it as a risk in diligence (L15, 2026). That is fund context, not a self-funded statistic. The self-funded version is harsher: when one relationship walks, you have no investor to call, and the loan you personally guarantee keeps its payment schedule.
Case
Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. It passed the screen in lesson 5.1.1 with an INVESTIGATE verdict. Run against the twelve, its documents raise six flags:
| Flag | Evidence in the documents | Status after questions |
|---|---|---|
| RF-04 Owner dependency | The owner runs sales, dispatch and large-job supervision. No general manager, no second licensed qualifier on record | Verified. Not a walk, because 24 field technicians and an office team do the work; priced as the job it is, a market general manager at about $225,000 a year. The license question stays open for diligence: the owner's license does not transfer, and the company needs a licensed qualifier after he leaves |
| RF-01 / RF-12 Concentration and channel | One homebuilder is about 38% of year-end receivables and the source of the year's big commercial job | By revenue the builder is about 16% of fiscal 2025 and about 3% in each of the two years before, below RF-01's 30% line. Verified as a channel dependency (RF-12). The job does not repeat and no contract appears in the package |
| RF-09 Revenue and margin erosion (in reverse) | Margin jumped to 19.6% after two years near 15 to 16% | Explained by a one-time job and pulled-forward replacements. The base year is a peak |
| RF-11 Aggressive add-backs | Seven add-backs totalling $402,000: the owner's salary with no replacement cost, $60,000 of "projected rent savings", the spouse's full bookkeeping pay and the owner's truck | Verified. Lesson 6.2.1 grades each item |
| RF-06 Lease and cost cliff | $33,000 of legal fees for a lease dispute with the landlord | Open. The lease term and renewal rent must be in hand before an LOI |
No critical flag is verified as a walk on its own. But look at the pattern: owner dependency, a channel that drove the peak year, and add-backs that inflate a peak-year number. Together they explain why the recurring earnings a new owner can expect sit near $1,017,000 against the broker's $1,710,000. The flags are not a checklist to tally. They are the map of where the seller's number is wrong.
Steps
How to run the library
- Start from the documents, not the list. Read the P&L, balance sheet, tax return and CIM first, and note anything odd. Then walk the twelve and attach each oddity to a flag.
- For each flag you raise, send the seller question exactly as written below, in writing.
- Mark each flag raised, verified, cleared, or unexplained (which counts as verified).
- Apply the severity rule to every verified flag, and write the action next to it: walk, the price or structure change you will ask for, or the adjustment to your earnings figure.
Critical: walk if verified
RF-01 Customer concentration. Looks like: a revenue breakdown with "Customer A" far ahead of the rest, or one name dominating receivables. Ask: "If your biggest customer left the day after I close, what happens? Is there a contract, or a handshake?" Rule: one customer over 50 percent of revenue with no long-term contract is critical: walk. You would own a single relationship, not a business. At 30 to 50 percent it is moderate: price the risk and build diversification into year one. More.
RF-02 Active litigation. Looks like: legal fees that recur or spike, a contingent-liability note. Ask: "Any lawsuits, claims or disputes, active or threatened? Show me the filings and your attorney's assessment." Rule: material unresolved litigation is a walk unless the seller fully indemnifies you in writing and the exposure is held back in escrow, money set aside at closing that the seller cannot touch until the matter ends. Search the court records yourself; do not rely on the answer. More.
RF-03 Regulatory, environmental and licensing exposure. Looks like: fines on the books, a lapsed license, a failed inspection, a permit expiring soon, a site with environmental history. Ask: "Is the business fully compliant and licensed today? Any open violations, citations, pending inspections or environmental exposure? Whose license does the company operate under?" A license belongs to a person and does not transfer with the business; many states require a licensed individual to qualify the company, so check your state board's rules for what happens when that person leaves. Rule: unresolved non-compliance is a walk. You inherit the penalty, the shutdown risk and the cleanup. More.
RF-04 Owner dependency. Looks like: no management salaries on payroll, a thin org chart, the owner holding the only license, the key relationships and the know-how. Ask: "Walk me through a normal week. What do you personally do that no one else can? How long would a new owner need you?" Rule: if the business is the owner and there is no second-in-command to promote or hire, walk, or price it as the job it is. More.
Moderate: negotiate hard or walk
RF-05 Working-capital manipulation. Working capital is the cash tied up in running the business day to day: receivables and inventory, less what the business owes its suppliers. Looks like: receivables or inventory growing faster than sales, profit that never shows up as cash, distributions to the owner speeding up before the sale. Ask: "How much cash does the business need day to day, and is that working capital staying in the business at closing?" Rule: re-price on the real cash number, or walk if the seller will not move. More.
RF-06 Lease and cost cliff. Looks like: below-market rent, a lease ending within a year or two, no locked renewal, or any single large cost about to reset. Ask: "What is the lease end date, the renewal options and the renewal rent? Is the landlord related to you?" Rule: secure a long renewal at a known rent before closing or model the higher cost. Walk if the location is the business and the lease is not secure. More.
RF-07 Key-employee risk. Looks like: one or two people carrying the technical work, the top sales or the customer relationships, with no succession. Ask: "Who are the two or three people this business cannot lose, and are they staying after the sale?" Rule: get retention agreements in place before closing. If a key person is irreplaceable and leaving, cut the price or walk. Re-check the roster the week before closing; the company you priced at the letter of intent is not always the one you receive. More.
RF-08 Deferred capex. Capex, capital expenditure, is spending on long-lived assets such as trucks, equipment and buildings. Looks like: old equipment, low recent capital spending, fully depreciated assets still in service. Profit looks high because nothing was reinvested. Ask: "When were the major assets last replaced, and what needs replacing in the next two to three years, at what cost?" Rule: subtract the coming bill from your effective price. Large and near-term means negotiate down or walk. More.
RF-09 Revenue and margin erosion. Looks like: revenue declining, or revenue flat while the margin shrinks each year. Watch the mirror image too: a margin far above the industry norm is often a normal margin with one bill temporarily missing. Ask: "What is squeezing the numbers: volume, input costs, pricing or mix? When did you last raise prices?" Rule: diagnose the cause. If it is fixable, price a recovery cautiously. If it is structural, lower your offer to the trend, or walk if the decline is the story. More.
Low: price it in and proceed carefully
RF-10 Related-party transactions. Looks like: rent paid to the owner's building, a vendor the owner also owns, family on payroll. Ask: "Are any vendors, customers, landlords or employees related to you or owned by you? Are those terms at market?" Rule: re-price every related-party item at market and rebuild the earnings figure. Below-market terms end the day you take over. More.
RF-11 Aggressive add-backs. An add-back is an expense the seller says will not continue, added back to profit. Looks like: a long adjustment list, recurring costs labeled "one-time," savings that have not happened. Ask: "Walk me through each add-back. Is it truly one-time, and can you document it?" Rule: grade every add-back A, B or C (lesson 6.2.1) and accept only what you can defend. At a 4x multiple, every $1 of add-back you accept adds $4 to the price. More.
RF-12 Channel dependency. Looks like: one distribution channel, platform, referral source or contract vehicle carrying the revenue: one marketplace account, one general contractor, one property manager who sends all the work. Ask: "Where do customers actually come from, and what happens if that channel repriced or vanished tomorrow?" Rule: price the fragility. If a stranger's decision can revoke or reprice the channel, treat it as concentration and escalate the severity. More.
When flags stack
Severity is assigned flag by flag, but you decide on the deal. Two rules for combinations:
- Two or more moderate flags that touch the same earnings (for example, a margin spike, deferred capex and add-backs all inflating the final year) should be treated as one critical finding about the earnings figure. Rebuild the number before you discuss price.
- Any flag that also fails the Walk-Away Doctrine (/walk-away), such as customer concentration above 30 percent with no contracts, or an owner who is the business, is a conviction-gate kill whatever its individual severity.
Deliverable
A red flag register for each deal that passed the screen, one row per flag raised:
- RF number and name.
- The evidence that raised it, with the document and page.
- The written question you sent and the seller's written answer.
- Status: raised, verified, cleared or unexplained.
- Severity and the action: walk, the price or structure change you will ask for, or the earnings adjustment.
Keep the register alive. Your diligence team will confirm or clear each row in Part VII, and every verified flag that survives should map to a price change, a representation, an escrow, or a reason you walked.
This lesson is education, not legal or investment advice. An attorney should advise on litigation, regulatory and lease exposure, and a licensed CPA on the financial flags, before you sign anything.