The most common trick in a sell-side CIM is not a lie. It is a label. The owner's pay, and often the pay of the owner's family, is added back to profit in full, and the result is called "adjusted EBITDA." The number is real in one sense: it is what the business would earn if nobody had to be paid to run it. But somebody does. This lesson shows you how to spot the relabelling, how to rebuild the number a buyer can actually rely on, and why the gap can be close to half the headline.
Principle
Two earnings measures, and they answer different questions.
- SDE, seller's discretionary earnings, is profit before the pay and perks of one working owner, plus genuine one-time items. It answers: what does this business produce for a single owner who does the job personally and takes no separate salary? It is the natural measure for small owner-operated businesses.
- EBITDA, earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, assumes the business is already paying market wages for everyone who runs it, including whoever does the owner's job. It answers: what does this business produce after it is properly managed?
The gap between them is the cost of management. And here is the rule: SDE minus the market cost of replacing the owner is roughly EBITDA. Adding the owner's pay back without subtracting a replacement turns SDE into a number wearing EBITDA's name.
Why it matters is the multiple. Prices are quoted as multiples of earnings, and buyers, lenders and brokers carry different rough multiples in their heads for SDE and for EBITDA, because the two measures are different sizes for the same business. Put an EBITDA-sized multiple on an SDE-sized number and you pay for the owner's job twice: once in the price, and again every year in the salary you or a hired manager draws.
"But I'm going to run it myself" does not rescue the number. It just means the replacement manager is you. You still need a salary to live on, and the loan is repaid from what is left after you are paid. The SBA writes this into underwriting: under SOP 50 10 8.1 (effective October 1, 2026, Y25), the lender must justify every add-back in its credit memo, must support any adjustment to ownership compensation with a global cash flow analysis, and must confirm that the owner's compensation is sufficient to cover the owner's obligations and living expenses. Your lender will put your salary back in. So should you, before you make an offer.
Do not assume someone downstream will catch the relabelling for you. Research on expert valuations of private firms found heavy reliance on the firms' reported earnings, despite the possibility those earnings had been manipulated (C23, 2010). And the incentive to shape the figure peaks at a sale to an outsider: a 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found owners planning to transfer outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55, 2023).
Case
Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. The broker's one-page summary is titled "Seller's Discretionary / Adjusted EBITDA." That heading is the tell. It uses both names for one number, and the number is $1,710,000.
The memo's owner-and-family lines:
| Broker add-back | Claimed | What is true |
|---|---|---|
| Owner's W-2 salary, "new owner can run it" | +$90,000 | The owner is general manager, lead salesperson, dispatcher and large-job supervisor. A hired manager to do that costs about $225,000 in salary, bonus and payroll taxes |
| Owner's spouse payroll, "role eliminable" | +$78,000 | She does real bookkeeping. Only the excess over a part-time market bookkeeper, about $55,000, is an add-back |
| Owner health insurance and personal items | +$24,000 | Not an add-back. The company will keep paying for a health plan for whoever does the owner's job, so the cost does not go away with him |
| Owner's personal vehicle | +$27,000 | Only the personal portion of one truck, about $18,000. The fleet is an operating cost |
The tax return adds the fact that explains the low salary: the owner drew $90,000 of W-2 wages and took $810,000 in S-corporation distributions in fiscal 2025. His real pay was most of the profit. The salary line was never a market wage, so adding it back and calling the business "run by a new owner" is backwards.
Now rebuild fiscal 2025 honestly, step by step:
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA, tied to the P&L and tax return | $1,308,000 |
| + documented one-time items (lease-dispute legal $33,000, the truly one-time part of the rebrand $30,000), the personal truck $18,000, and the spouse's pay above a market bookkeeper $55,000 | $1,444,000 |
| + the owner's salary $90,000 | $1,534,000: honest SDE |
| − a market general manager, about $225,000 in salary, bonus and payroll taxes | $1,309,000: normalized EBITDA |
| − the profit from one non-repeating commercial job and pulled-forward replacements, about $292,000 | $1,017,000: recurring EBITDA |
Two notes on the table. The health plan appears nowhere in it. It was a cost before the sale and it is a cost after, because the company pays for a plan for whoever fills the role; the $225,000 is salary, bonus and payroll taxes only. And the $292,000 has a source: the job-cost report shows the townhome project contributed about $205,000, and about $300,000 of replacement revenue pulled forward into the year, at a contribution of about 29 percent, is another $87,000.
Three lessons in one table.
First, the broker's figure is larger than an honest SDE. It is $176,000 larger: a $60,000 "projected rent savings" that has not happened, the $24,000 health plan, $60,000 of rebrand spending that is really ongoing marketing, $9,000 of vehicle cost and $23,000 of bookkeeping pay a new owner still has to cover. A forecast is never an add-back.
Second, the SDE-to-EBITDA gap is $225,000, exactly the cost of the manager. Take the spike out of both measures and recurring SDE is about $1,242,000 against recurring EBITDA of about $1,017,000: the same $225,000. At 3.75 times earnings, close to the multiple the broker quotes, that gap is about $844,000 of price for a job someone still has to do.
Third, the earnings a buyer can rely on are about $1,017,000, about 60 percent of the headline. Every dollar of the difference was findable in the broker's own memo, the P&L notes, the job-cost report and the tax return. One check before you trust even that: the $1,017,000 sits on about $5,445,000 of revenue once the one-time job ($930,000) and the pull-forward ($300,000) come out, an EBITDA margin of about 18.7 percent, against about 14.8 percent for fiscal 2024 normalized the same way. Nothing in the package explains four points. It is a question for the quality of earnings report, not a reason to change your number tonight.
Steps
1. Find the label
Read the heading of the earnings summary and every footnote to it. Flag any of these:
- "SDE" and "EBITDA" used interchangeably, or together in one heading.
- "Owner's benefit," "owner's discretionary" or "owner perks" added back under an EBITDA heading.
- Notes such as "new owner can run it," "role eliminable" or "absentee potential" next to compensation add-backs.
2. List everyone the add-backs remove
For each compensation add-back, write the person, their actual role, and the hours they work. Use the org chart, the payroll register, and the owner's own account of a normal week (lesson 5.2.1, RF-04). Family members count.
3. Price every role at market
For each person removed, ask: if they left tomorrow, would I have to hire someone? If yes, price the replacement at a market wage for that role in that region, plus payroll taxes and benefits. Sources: local job postings for similar roles, your industry contacts, and wage data from public sources. Write the source next to each number.
4. Rebuild the bridge
Reported EBITDA, then documented one-time items, then the owner's own pay and any family pay above what the work is worth (this is SDE), then minus the market cost of every role you must fill (this is EBITDA), then minus anything that will not repeat (this is recurring EBITDA). The add-back grading itself is lesson 6.2.1.
5. Test the margin of what is left
Divide recurring EBITDA by the revenue left after the one-time items, and compare it with the prior year normalized the same way. If the recurring margin is well above the prior year's and the documents do not say why, write it down as an open question for the quality of earnings scope and keep a QoE condition in any letter of intent. Lesson 6.2.1 covers what to do with it.
6. Check the multiple against the measure
Ask which measure the asking multiple was applied to. If the broker applied it to an SDE-sized number, recompute it on your recurring EBITDA, and compare that to the range you wrote down before the CIM arrived (lesson 5.1.1).
7. Put your salary in, even if you are the manager
Run the debt test on recurring EBITDA after a market salary for the role you will fill. SOP 50 10 8.1 requires a debt service coverage ratio of at least 1.25 for an initial acquisition, measured on historical earnings, and the lender will make the same salary adjustment you just did.
8. Ask the seller in writing
Your summary adds back the full owner and family compensation. Who performs those roles after closing, and what do you estimate they would cost to replace at market?
The answer, or the lack of one, goes in your file.
Deliverable
An SDE-to-EBITDA bridge for the deal, one page:
- Reported EBITDA, tied to the tax return.
- Each add-back, accepted or rejected, with its evidence.
- Honest SDE.
- Each role the add-backs remove, its market replacement cost and the source.
- Normalized EBITDA, then recurring EBITDA, and the recurring margin against the prior year's.
- The asking price restated as a multiple of your recurring EBITDA.
- The written question sent to the seller.
This lesson is education, not accounting or lending advice. A licensed CPA should review owner compensation and normalization on any business you intend to buy, and your lender will make its own adjustments under the current SOP.