Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part V: Screen/Screening With Zero Financials

Lesson 5.4.1

The Public-Data Screen

A full go or no-go decision on a business that has shared no financials: a bottoms-up revenue and earnings estimate, benchmark multiples, a SWOT, and red flags pulled from public records. Also the discipline of saying no to an off-thesis deal you could win.

Lesson 4 of 6 in this part · 8 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How can I evaluate a business that has not shared any financials?

Build an estimate from public data and label every number as an estimate. Work out revenue from visible capacity, such as seats, trucks, hours and prices, in low, base and high cases. Apply an industry margin band for seller's discretionary earnings and a benchmark multiple for a value range. Sweep the public record, write a SWOT, then decide whether a first conversation is worth having.

Most of the businesses you will look at in an off-market search have shared nothing. No CIM, no P&L, no tax return, often no idea that you exist. You still have to decide whether a first conversation is worth having, and whether to spend weeks earning an owner's trust. This lesson is the screen you run on a business before it has shown you a single number: a bottoms-up estimate of revenue and earnings, a value range from benchmarks, a public-records sweep, a SWOT, and a go or no-go. It ends with the hardest part, which has nothing to do with data: saying no to a deal you could win.

Principle

You can make a real decision on zero financials, as long as you label every number as an estimate. The public-data screen is not an appraisal and never pretends to be one. Its only job is to decide whether the first conversation is worth having, and to make sure that if you have it, you walk in already knowing what the owner hopes you will not ask.

Three ideas carry the method.

Build from the sidewalk up. A business's capacity is visible: hours on the door, seats or service bays, trucks in the lot, prices on the menu or the website, staff on the floor. Capacity times a realistic level of use gives you a revenue range. Run it as three scenarios, low, base and high, and never collapse them into one number.

Value from benchmarks, held loosely. Once you have revenue, an industry's typical margin gives you a range for SDE, seller's discretionary earnings: the profit available to one owner who works in the business, before that owner's own pay. A benchmark multiple of SDE then gives a value range. Each step widens the error, and you should expect the range to be wide. Even professionals disagree: a study of actual appraisals of 258 closely held companies found that value estimates were sensitive to both the method used and the appraiser's background (C33, 1993). Your benchmark range is a rough fence, not a price.

Public records say what sellers will not. Ownership filings, health and safety inspections, licensing histories and court dockets are public, at no cost, and indifferent to how the owner wants to be seen. They are rich enough that researchers use them: a 2016 study of restaurant chains used comprehensive health inspection records to measure changes in store-level operating practice after a buyout (D2, 2016). If inspection histories can measure operations for academics, they can flag operations for you.

And one rule above the method: a screen that comes back workable is not a reason to proceed. It is permission to ask whether the deal belongs in your search at all.

Case

Project Slice is an anonymized case. The buyers ran this screen on a single-unit neighborhood pizzeria in a dense, walkable urban food corridor: an East Coast slice concept with a beer and wine license and a late-night window most competitors had abandoned. It was not listed for sale. There was no broker, no CIM and no contact with the owner.

The revenue build. From menu prices, seat count, operating hours and the pace of new reviews, the buyers built an average-daily-sales range, then multiplied: average daily sales times operating days per week times 52. The result was roughly $600,000 to $1,100,000 of annual revenue, base case around $850,000.

Earnings and value. Owner-operated single-unit pizzerias run roughly 10 to 18 percent of revenue as SDE, and beer and wine plus a high slice mix push toward the top of that band. The buyers called it $75,000 to $185,000 of SDE. Independent pizzerias trade around 1.5 to 2.5 times SDE in the buyers' benchmark set, and owner-recipe shops skew low because the product may not transfer. On the $850,000 base case, 10 to 18 percent is about $85,000 to $153,000 of SDE, and 1.5 to 2.5 times that is roughly $128,000 to $383,000: a low six-figure value, under $400,000 even at the top of both bands. Those benchmarks are the case's working assumptions, not market statistics.

The records sweep took four sources: the secretary of state (the legal entity, its registered agent and filing history), county fictitious-business-name filings (who is really behind the trade name), the county health department (the permit holder and the full inspection history, not just today's grade), and state alcohol licensing (who holds the beer and wine license, and what a transfer takes). The first finding came before any of the interesting ones: the legal owner was not visible in the shop's branding at all. "Family-owned" was marketing, not a cap table.

What the records surfaced. Two findings no seller conversation would have volunteered:

  1. A county-ordered health closure in the prior eighteen months, for exactly the violations you would fear, since fixed and reopened.
  2. A failed second location, opened in a neighboring market and closed.

Neither is automatically a deal-killer. The closure defines the first diligence question and a request for a written representation and an escrow, money held back at closing against a specific risk. The failed expansion says the "just open a second one" upside is priced wrong, because this team already tried and missed.

What does not transfer. The recipes, the vendor relationships, the founder's public persona, and years of actively answered reviews: a near-perfect rating across hundreds of reviews that was the business's single biggest asset, protected by nothing but execution and affection. Research on external successors finds that intangible assets like these weigh notably on a successor's decision to take over a company (C41, 2010). Here they argued for an asset purchase, a lease assignment as the gating item, an alcohol license transfer (a 45-to-60-day state process that belongs on the closing timeline, not in a footnote), and a multiple that prices the transfer risk.

The verdict. The screen came back workable. A low-cost first conversation was defensible. And the deal was still a pass, because it was off-thesis. The buyers' buy box was built around government-services companies, and a sub-$1,000,000 consumer business had no place in it, no matter how good the slice.

Steps

1. Build revenue from capacity (low, base, high)

Pick the capacity driver that fits the business:

Business type Capacity driver Use rate to estimate
Restaurant or retail Seats or registers, hours, average ticket Turns or transactions per hour, by daypart
Trades and field services Trucks or technicians Billable jobs per technician per day, average job value
Shop or bay services Bays or chairs Utilization per day, average ticket
Distribution or manufacturing Square footage, shifts, headcount Revenue per employee from your sector's norms

Multiply out for a year and write three numbers. Where you have a second, independent proxy (headcount, fleet size, review volume over time), use it to check the first. If the two proxies disagree badly, widen the range rather than picking the one you like.

2. Estimate SDE and a value range

  1. Apply an SDE margin band for the industry and size. Source it from your lender conversations, the pricing references in the Library, or comparable sales your advisors have seen, and write down where it came from.
  2. Apply a benchmark multiple band to the SDE range.
  3. Then do the self-funded check. Subtract a salary you could live on and an illustrative annual debt payment at a plausible price. If the base case cannot cover both with room to spare, a lender will not finance it either. SOP 50 10 8.1 (Y25) requires coverage of at least 1.25 times on historical earnings for an initial acquisition, and a business that fails that test on your own generous estimate will fail it on real numbers.

3. Sweep the public record

Run every source before any contact:

  • Secretary of state: legal entity, officers, registered agent, formation date, filing history.
  • County fictitious-business-name or assumed-name filings: who stands behind the trade name.
  • Licensing boards: contractor, professional or trade licenses; who holds them; any discipline.
  • Health, safety or environmental inspection records where the industry has them: the full history, not the current grade.
  • Alcohol, transport or other regulated permits: holder, status, and what a transfer requires.
  • Court records: civil suits, judgments and liens against both the entity and the owner, searched under the legal name, not just the trade name.
  • UCC search at the secretary of state: who has filed a lien against the business's assets.
  • Property records: whether the owner holds the real estate, which shapes the lease conversation.

Map each finding to a red flag from lesson 5.2.1. Slice's health closure is RF-03; a founder who is the brand is RF-04.

4. Write the SWOT

One page. Strengths and weaknesses are what the business has today. Opportunities and threats come from outside it. Put every public-record finding in the weaknesses or threats column, and every upside you are tempted to pay for (a second location, new hours, catering) in opportunities, where it belongs, because it has not happened.

5. Make the call, then ask the thesis question

Write the verdict: GO to a first conversation, or NO-GO, with the single reason. Then, before you send anything, answer one more question in writing:

If this deal goes perfectly, does it move me toward the business my search is for?

If the honest answer is no, pass, even though you could win it. The interview corpus of 60+ failed and struggling buyers includes a buyer who promoted a deal he had already doubted, not because the deal improved but because his patience and savings ran down. An off-thesis deal you can win is the most dangerous kind, because nothing stops you except your own discipline.

Deliverable

A public-data screen of no more than three pages:

  • The revenue build: capacity driver, use rate, and low, base and high revenue, with every number labelled as an estimate.
  • The SDE band, the multiple band and the value range, with the source of each benchmark.
  • The self-funded check: base-case SDE less your salary and an illustrative debt payment.
  • The public-records log: each source, what it showed, and the red flag it maps to.
  • A one-page SWOT.
  • The verdict, GO or NO-GO, the single reason, and your written answer to the thesis question.
  • If GO, the first two diligence questions you will raise, drawn from what the records showed.

This lesson is education, not appraisal or investment advice. A public-data estimate is not a valuation; any offer should rest on the seller's documents, verified by a licensed CPA.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

How do I estimate a private company's revenue?

Pick the capacity driver that fits the business: seats and average ticket for a restaurant, trucks or technicians for a trade, bays or chairs for a shop. Multiply capacity by a realistic use rate for a year and write three numbers, low, base and high. Check against a second proxy such as headcount or fleet size, and widen the range if the two disagree badly.

What public records should I check before buying a business?

Secretary of state filings, county fictitious-business-name filings, licensing boards, health, safety or environmental inspection histories, regulated permits such as alcohol, court records for suits, judgments and liens, a UCC search, and property records. Search under the legal name, not just the trade name, and run every source before any contact with the owner.

What is SDE in a small business sale?

SDE, seller's discretionary earnings, is the profit available to one owner who works in the business, before that owner's own pay. Applying an industry margin band to estimated revenue gives an SDE range, and a benchmark multiple of SDE gives a value range. Each step widens the error, so treat the result as a rough fence, not a price.

Should I buy a business outside my search criteria if the deal looks good?

A workable screen is not a reason to proceed. Before you send anything, answer in writing: if this deal goes perfectly, does it move me toward the business my search is for? If the honest answer is no, pass, even though you could win it. Nothing stops an off-thesis deal except your own discipline.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. D2

    Bernstein, S., & Sheen, A. (2016). The operational consequences of private equity buyouts: Evidence from the restaurant industry. Review of Financial Studies, 29(9), 2387-2418.

  2. C33

    Harper, C. P., & Rose, L. C (1993). Accuracy of appraisers and appraisal methods of closely held companies. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 17(3), 21-33.

  3. C41

    Durst, S., & Güldenberg, S (2010). The influence of intangible assets on external succession decisions in small and medium-sized enterprises. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Venturing, 1(4), 367.

  4. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.