Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part VI: Underwrite/Find the Real Earnings

Lesson 6.2.1

Add-Back Tiers A, B and C

The canonical normalization frame with the owner-replacement adjustment, and the multiplier warning: at a four-times multiple, every dollar of add-back you accept adds four dollars to the price.

Lesson 2 of 12 in this part · 11 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

What are add-backs when buying a business, and which ones should a buyer accept?

An add-back is an expense the seller says will not continue under a new owner, added back to profit. Grade each one. Accept documented personal and finished one-time costs in full. Verify part-real items such as family payroll and credit only the documented portion. Reject anything that has not happened yet. You pay a multiple of every add-back you accept: at four times earnings, $1 adds $4 to the price.

Once the statements reconcile, the seller hands you a second number: adjusted EBITDA, the profit "after add-backs." It is almost always the largest earnings figure in the package, and it is the one the asking price is built on. This lesson gives you one frame for judging every add-back the seller claims, the owner-replacement adjustment that most buyers get backwards, and the arithmetic that explains why this is the most expensive page in the deal.

Principle

Start with the terms.

  • EBITDA is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization: the profit from running the business, before financing and the paper cost of aging equipment.
  • An add-back is an expense the seller argues you should add back to profit because it will not continue under a new owner. The owner's personal car run through the company is the classic example.
  • Adjusted EBITDA is reported EBITDA plus the add-backs. The seller's version is a claim. Your version is the number you will pay a multiple of.
  • SDE, seller's discretionary earnings, adds back the whole of one owner's pay and perks. It describes what the business is worth to an owner who will do the job personally and take no separate salary. It is not EBITDA, and lesson 5.5.1 covers what happens when one is dressed as the other.

Now the warning that sits over everything here: you pay a multiple of earnings, so you pay a multiple for every add-back you accept. At four times earnings, every $1 of add-back adds $4 to the price. A $40,000 add-back that is really a hope is not a $40,000 mistake. It is $160,000 of purchase price, most of it borrowed on an SBA loan you personally guarantee, and repaid out of earnings that were never there.

Sellers know this, and the incentive is strongest exactly when you arrive. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners intending to transfer the business outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55, 2023). Add-back schedules are where that management becomes a number. And do not expect a valuer to catch it for you by default: research on expert valuations found heavy reliance on private firms' reported earnings, despite the possibility those earnings were manipulated (C23, 2010).

So you grade every add-back yourself, into one of three tiers.

Tier A: almost always legitimate. Accept in full, with proof. Personal costs and finished one-time costs you will not inherit: the owner's personal car or phone run through the business; a documented legal bill for a dispute that is over; a documented one-time consulting fee. Owner pay belongs here too, but only the excess over what it costs to replace the owner (below). The rule: accept, but "trust me" is not documentation.

Tier B: sometimes legitimate. Verify, accept the documented portion, cut the rest. Items that are part real and part fluff: vague owner-discretion expense buckets, family members on payroll, travel and entertainment, deal-preparation costs. A common working rule is to credit about half until the seller documents more. The question for each: is this a real role or a real one-time cost, and how much of it?

Tier C: usually not legitimate. Reject. Anything that has not happened yet: future software savings, pricing power not yet used, cost cuts about to be made, savings expected from combining with the buyer, run-rate adjustments, working-capital effects swept into profit. The question: has this actually happened, or is it a forecast? If it is a forecast, it is your upside to earn after closing. You do not pay the seller for it today.

The owner-replacement adjustment

This is the add-back most buyers get backwards. If the owner works in the business, someone has to do that job after the owner leaves. That person costs money. Add back the owner's total pay, then subtract the market cost of replacing them. Credit only the difference.

Illustrative arithmetic: an owner takes a $200,000 salary and runs a $50,000 personal car through the company, $250,000 in all. A hired general manager to do the job costs $130,000 in salary, bonus and payroll taxes. The add-back is $250,000 minus $130,000, which is $120,000, not $250,000. Credit the full $250,000 and you have overstated earnings by $130,000, and at four times you have overpaid by $520,000.

Three corollaries matter for a self-funded buyer:

  1. A cost that continues for whoever does the job is not an add-back. Health insurance is the usual example. The owner's plan leaves with the owner, but the company will pay for a health plan for the person who replaces them, so the cost does not go away. Either leave it in the expenses or add it back and put it inside the replacement cost. Never add it back and leave it out of the replacement.
  2. The adjustment can be negative. When the owner underpays themselves and takes the rest as distributions, the market replacement cost is higher than the pay you add back. The net adjustment reduces earnings.
  3. Planning to run the business yourself does not cancel it. You still need a salary to live on, and the loan is repaid from what is left after you are paid. Underwrite as if you are an employee at a market wage, because for debt-service purposes you are.

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Its reported FY2025 EBITDA, tied to the tax return in lesson 6.1.1, is $1,308,000. The broker's memo adds seven items and arrives at $1,710,000 of adjusted EBITDA, then asks $6,450,000, about 3.8 times that figure.

Here is the broker's schedule, graded:

Broker add-back Claimed Tier Accepted Why
Owner's W-2 salary +$90,000 A, with replacement -$135,000 Add back $90,000, subtract $225,000 for a market general manager (salary, bonus and payroll taxes). The owner is GM, lead salesperson and job supervisor.
Spouse payroll +$78,000 B +$55,000 Real bookkeeping work exists. Only the excess over about $23,000 for a part-time bookkeeper is an add-back.
Owner's vehicle +$27,000 B +$18,000 Only the personal portion of one truck. The fleet is an operating cost.
"One-time" rebrand and marketing +$90,000 B +$30,000 Most of it is ongoing lead generation that recurs. Only the true relaunch cost is one-time.
Legal, lease dispute +$33,000 A +$33,000 Documented, finished.
Owner health insurance and personal items +$24,000 Reject $0 The company will keep paying for a health plan for whoever does Ray's job, so the cost does not go away with him. The $225,000 manager figure does not include health coverage.
"Projected rent savings" +$60,000 C $0 A future move to a smaller shop. Not a historical expense.

Reported EBITDA of $1,308,000, plus the accepted adjustments (-$135,000, +$55,000, +$18,000, +$33,000, +$30,000), gives normalized adjusted EBITDA of about $1,309,000. That is roughly where the seller started. Every dollar the broker added was offset by the one adjustment the broker left out.

The gap to the broker's figure is about $401,000. At the broker's own 3.8 times, that is roughly $1,500,000 of asking price resting on add-backs that do not survive grading.

And this is still not the number to price. FY2025 was a spike year, and the seller's own notes to the P&L let you size it. The job-cost report shows the one-time Harbor Pointe townhome project contributed about $205,000 after materials, subcontractors and field labor. Management estimates that about $300,000 of replacement revenue was pulled forward ahead of a price increase, and replacement work contributes about 29 percent, so that is another $87,000. Removing both takes $292,000 off, leaving recurring adjusted EBITDA near $1,017,000. Lesson 6.3.1 covers how to spot a spike year, and lesson 6.6.1 works this bridge in full. Grading add-backs is the step that tells you the broker's headline is wrong. Normalizing the base year tells you by how much.

Then test the result. Take Harbor Pointe's $930,000 of billings and the $300,000 of pulled-forward replacements out of FY2025 revenue and about $5,445,000 is left, earning the recurring $1,017,000: an EBITDA margin of about 18.7 percent. FY2024, normalized the same way, earned about $789,000 on $5,325,000, about 14.8 percent. Taking out low-margin project work should not lift the margin of what is left by almost four points on almost the same revenue. Your arithmetic is right; the documents under it do not explain the margin. You cannot re-price on a question, so the $1,017,000 stays your working number for now. The gap goes into your override memo as the first open question, into the written scope of the quality of earnings report (QoE, an outside accountant's test of whether the profit is real), and the QoE condition stays in your letter of intent. Lesson 7.3.1 shows what the QoE found.

Steps

1. Get the schedule in writing, line by line

Ask for the seller's or broker's add-back schedule with a written explanation for each line and the year each item occurred. An adjusted EBITDA figure without a line-item schedule is not an add-back claim. It is a number.

2. Demand the document behind each line

For every add-back, request the invoice, the payroll record, the settlement agreement or the card statement that proves it. Then check the prior two years' P&Ls for the same item. A "one-time" expense that appears every year is a recurring expense.

3. Grade every line A, B or C

Write the tier, the amount claimed, the amount accepted and the one-sentence reason next to each line. Default to the stricter tier when unsure. Ask one question of everything in Tier C: has this happened? If not, the accepted amount is zero.

4. Price the owner's job, every part of it

List each role the owner performs: general manager, salesperson, estimator, dispatcher, lead technician, bookkeeper. Price the market cost of hiring for those roles in that region, using job postings and local wage data you can show a lender. One person may cover two roles; few people cover five. Then compute: owner's total pay and perks added back, minus replacement cost. Enter the result as one line, positive or negative.

5. Check for double counts and costs that continue

A perk you already added back as part of the owner's total pay (a phone, a car allowance) cannot be added back again on its own line. A cost that continues for whoever does the job, such as health insurance, is not an add-back at all unless the same cost is inside your replacement figure. State in one line what your replacement figure includes: salary, bonus, payroll taxes, benefits. Family payroll added back in full while the family member's work still needs doing is a double count too: credit only the excess over the market cost of that role.

6. Build the bridge

  Reported EBITDA (ties to the tax return)
+ Tier A add-backs (accepted in full)
+ Tier B add-backs (documented portion only)
+ Owner pay added back
- Market cost to replace the owner
= Your adjusted EBITDA
- One-time revenue and margin effects (lessons 6.3.1 and 6.6.1)
= Your recurring adjusted EBITDA

Below the bridge, write the variance: the seller's figure minus yours, and that variance times the asking multiple. That second number is how much of the price rests on add-backs you rejected.

7. Test the margin of the result against the prior year

Divide your recurring adjusted EBITDA by the revenue left after you removed the one-time items. Do the same for the prior year, normalized the same way. If the recurring margin is well above the prior year's and nothing in the documents explains it (a price increase, a change in service mix, a cost that genuinely went away), the bridge is not finished: something in cost of goods or the year-end books is probably flattering the base year. Do not invent an adjustment to close the gap. Write it as an open question in your override memo, put it in the QoE scope by name ("explain the FY2025 recurring margin against FY2024"), and keep the QoE condition in your letter of intent so the price can move if the answer does.

8. Run the multiplier on every disputed line

For each line where you and the seller disagree, multiply the disputed amount by the asking multiple and write it beside the line. Negotiating "$60,000 of rent savings" sounds small. Negotiating "$228,000 of price for a move that has not happened" does not.

9. Remember who else will read it

Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026 (Y25), debt-service coverage for an initial acquisition must be at least 1.25 times, and it must be met "using either the last fiscal year-end or an average of the last two fiscal year-end statements on either a historical or adjusted basis", not projections. Tier C add-backs are projections by definition. Build a bridge you would be comfortable defending to the lender line by line, because the loan, and your personal guarantee, will sit on it.

Deliverable

A one-page Add-Back Grading Sheet and Profit Bridge, with:

  • Every seller add-back: amount claimed, tier, amount accepted, the document that supports it, and a one-sentence reason.
  • The owner-replacement calculation: each role the owner performs, its market cost and source, and the net adjustment.
  • The bridge from reported EBITDA to your adjusted EBITDA and your recurring adjusted EBITDA.
  • The margin check: recurring margin against the prior year's normalized margin, and any gap the documents do not explain, written as an open question for the QoE scope.
  • The variance to the seller's figure, and that variance times the asking multiple.
  • A written list of add-backs you need documented before you will credit them, sent to the seller.

This sheet is the input to the quality of earnings work in lesson 6.3.2 and to valuation in lesson 6.4.1.

This lesson is education, not accounting, tax or legal advice. A licensed CPA should review the financials of any business you intend to buy.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

Can the owner's salary be added back to EBITDA?

Only the excess over the cost of replacing the owner. Add back the owner's total pay, then subtract the market cost of hiring someone to do the job, and credit the difference. The adjustment can be negative when the owner underpays themselves and takes the rest as distributions. Planning to run the business yourself does not cancel it.

What is the difference between EBITDA and adjusted EBITDA?

EBITDA is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization: the profit from running the business. Adjusted EBITDA is reported EBITDA plus the add-backs. The seller's version is a claim. Your version, built by grading each add-back yourself, is the number you will pay a multiple of.

Are projected cost savings a legitimate add-back?

No. Future software savings, cost cuts about to be made, pricing power not yet used and run-rate adjustments have not happened. A forecast is your upside to earn after closing, not something you pay the seller for today. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, debt-service coverage is measured on the last fiscal year or the average of the last two, not on projections.

How do I verify a seller's add-backs?

Ask for the add-back schedule in writing, line by line, with the year each item occurred. Request the invoice, payroll record, settlement agreement or card statement behind every line. Then check the prior two years of P&Ls for the same item. A one-time expense that appears every year is a recurring expense.

How do I test whether my recurring earnings figure is too high?

Divide it by the revenue left after removing the one-time items, and compare that margin with the prior year normalized the same way. In the textbook's fictional case the recurring figure implies about 18.7 percent against 14.8 percent the year before, on almost the same revenue. If the documents do not explain a gap like that, name it as an open question, write it into the quality of earnings scope and keep the QoE condition in your letter of intent.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C55

    Umans, I., & Corten, M (2023). Ownership succession intentions affecting earnings management in private family firms. Small Business Economics, 61(2), 827-842.

  2. C23

    Elnathan, D., Gavious, I., & Hauser, S (2010). An analysis of private versus public firm valuations and the contribution of financial experts. International Journal of Accounting, 45(4), 387-412.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.