Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part V: Screen/Scoring and Hard Gates

Lesson 5.3.1

Rubric the Pipeline

Apply the scoring rubric in two passes, first on public data and again once the CIM arrives, so only targets above the threshold advance toward a letter of intent.

Lesson 3 of 6 in this part · 10 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How do I score and rank the businesses I am considering buying?

Score every target twice on a 100-point rubric. Run pass-or-fail hard gates first, then weighted categories. The first pass uses public data, with unknowns capped at half points. The second pass uses the seller's documents and your own tested earnings, and it is the score of record. Only a target scoring 70 or more on the second pass advances toward a letter of intent.

The quick screen in lesson 5.1.1 answers one question about one deal: is this worth three more hours? A pipeline needs a different tool. When you have forty names in sourcing, six owners talking to you and two CIMs on your desk, you need a way to rank them against each other, and a rule that decides which ones earn the expensive work of a letter of intent. That tool is the scoring rubric you built in lesson 3.3.3. This lesson is how to apply it: twice, on two different kinds of evidence, with hard gates in front and one threshold at the end.

Principle

Score every target twice, and let only the second score move money. The first pass uses public data, before the owner knows your name. The second pass uses the seller's documents, once a CIM or a financial package arrives. The second-pass score is the score of record. Only a target that scores 70 or more on the second pass advances toward a letter of intent (LOI), the document that sets your offered price and terms and usually gives you a period of exclusive negotiation.

Why two passes? Because information on private companies is thin, and thin information is where buyers fool themselves. Research on corporate acquirers found that the lack of information on private targets limits how widely an acquirer searches and raises the risk of evaluating the target poorly (C7, 2007). That study is about corporate buyers, but the mechanism applies to you with more force: you have no corporate development team, and your judgment is the only filter between a CIM and your personal guarantee.

The rubric has three parts, and the order is fixed.

1. Hard gates. Pass or fail, checked before any points are counted. A target that fails a gate is out, whatever else it scores. Gates are for the risks no score can offset.

2. Weighted categories, summing to 100. Each category has sub-criteria with point bands, so two people scoring the same target land within a few points of each other.

3. Action bands. The total maps to one action:

Score Band Action
85 to 100 Pursue Move fast: owner call or broker call this week, lender conversation in parallel
70 to 84 Strong fit Request the CIM or financials; on the second pass, proceed toward an LOI
55 to 69 Conditional Name the one or two questions that are holding the score down. The next action is only to answer them, then re-score
Under 55 Pass Log the reason and stop

Two rules govern the scoring itself.

Score unknowns conservatively, and mark them. On the first pass most cells are unknown. An unknown gets no more than half the available points and carries a question mark. A target that scores well on unknowns is a target you have not looked at yet.

You may overrule the rubric, but only in writing. A failed gate is final. A score is not. If you want to advance a target the bands say to hold, such as one under 70 on the second pass, write an override memo before you spend another hour: which rule, why, the specific mitigant, and the condition under which the override expires. An override you cannot write down is a feeling, not a judgment.

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. The rubric here is the one lesson 3.3.3 builds, unchanged: seven hard gates and six weighted categories. It is this curriculum's example for a self-funded buyer; you set your own weights there, not here.

The seven hard gates. A target fails when:

  1. Eligibility: the business is a type the SBA does not lend to, or you are not an eligible borrower under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026 (Y25). Since March 1, 2026, for example, every direct and indirect owner must be a U.S. citizen or U.S. national, and lawful permanent residents may not hold any stake (Y28).
  2. Earnings band: earnings fall outside the band your financing supports.
  3. Concentration: one customer exceeds the cap you set in advance.
  4. Historical coverage: no price you would pay reaches 1.25 to 1 coverage on historical earnings.
  5. Clean record: active bankruptcy, debarment, or litigation that threatens the core of the business.
  6. Transferability: a license, contract, lease or franchise the business cannot operate without will not transfer to you and cannot be replaced by closing. A license belongs to a person, not the business, so for a licensed trade the test is whether someone licensed will qualify the company after the owner leaves; rules vary by state.
  7. Verifiability: the seller will not produce tax returns and bank statements.

Pass 1, public data. Months before any broker is involved, Coastal Comfort appears in your sourcing. State filings show a founder-owned company formed in 2009. A fleet and headcount proxy puts revenue at $5,000,000 to $8,000,000. The founder's first contractor license dates to 1994, which suggests he is in his late fifties, and no second licensed qualifier is on record. Public permits show a 41-unit townhome project with a local homebuilder in 2025. It clears all seven gates, with two marked unknown until documents arrive (historical coverage and verifiability), and scores:

Category Max Pass 1, public data Pass 2, documents, at the ask Pass 2, at your price
Financial quality 25 16 11 15
Revenue and customers 20 13 9 9
Seller and succession 20 14 16 16
Operations and people 15 8 5 5
Fit with you 10 10 10 10
Location and network 10 9 9 9
Total 100 70: Strong fit 60: Conditional 64: Conditional

Pass 1 lands at 70, the bottom of the strong-fit band: reach out and request documents. The first note on the file is the question the permit record raised: was 2025 a trend or an event?

Pass 2, seller documents. The broker package arrives claiming $1,710,000 of adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, after the seller's adjustments) and asking $6,450,000. Your own work puts recurring earnings near $1,017,000, about 60 percent of the headline. Every question mark resolves, and most resolve downward. Financial quality falls from 16 to 11 on the margin spike and the one-time year. Revenue and customers falls from 13 to 9: one homebuilder is 38 percent of receivables, and a one-time job sits inside fiscal 2025 revenue. Operations and people falls from 8 to 5: there is no second-in-command, and the owner is the only license qualifier. Seller and succession rises from 14 to 16, because the motivation is clear (he wants to move near his grandchildren) and the broker says he is open to a seller note.

Then one line of the score splits, and this is the lesson. The same business is a different credit at a different price. Financial quality includes a line for historical coverage, and coverage depends on what you pay.

At the asking price, illustrative arithmetic: a 10 percent equity injection leaves about $5,805,000 to borrow on the price alone, which is already above the $5,000,000 maximum for a standard 7(a) loan. Set that aside and run the payments anyway. Over ten years at an illustrative 10 percent rate (most 7(a) loans are variable, and your lender quotes the real one), that is roughly $921,000 a year, and $1,017,000 divided by $921,000 is about 1.10 times coverage. SOP 50 10 8.1 requires a debt service coverage ratio (DSCR, EBITDA divided by annual debt payments after the purchase) of at least 1.25 for an initial acquisition, measured on historical earnings, not projections. At the ask, the deal does not finance. Financial quality stays at 11 and the total is 60.

At a price built on $1,017,000, inside the curriculum's illustrative 3.0x to 4.5x range, the same arithmetic gives coverage of about 1.56x to 2.34x. Coverage clears the floor, the coverage line earns its points, and financial quality rises to 15. The total is 64.

Sixty-four is still under 70. A lower price repaired the financing. It did not repair the two things price cannot touch: earnings that are still your rebuilt number and not yet a proven one (and a number whose recurring margin, about 18.7 percent against 14.8 percent the year before, the documents do not explain; lesson 6.2.1), and a company with nobody but the owner to run it and hold its license. The rule stands: a letter of intent requires 70 or more on the second pass. In this case you write one anyway, at your price, and you do it the only way the rubric allows: with the override memo from lesson 3.3.3. The memo names the two open questions (what are the real recurring earnings, and who runs the company and holds the license after the owner leaves) and turns both into conditions of closing. That is the branch the Coastal Comfort case takes in Part VII.

Steps

Set up once

  1. Write your hard gates. Keep them few and absolute. Start from the seven in lesson 3.3.3 (eligibility, earnings band, concentration, historical coverage, clean record, transferability, verifiability) and add your household's red lines. Every gate should be something you would walk from even at a low price.
  2. Fix your weights and bands as built in lesson 3.3.3, and do not change them mid-search. A rubric re-weighted to fit the deal you like is no longer a rubric.
  3. Score coverage the way the lender will. The historical coverage line inside financial quality asks whether the business, at the price you would actually pay, clears the SBA's 1.25 coverage floor on historical earnings and still supports a salary you can live on. SOP 50 10 8.1 requires the lender to justify every add-back in its credit memo and to confirm that the owner's compensation covers the owner's obligations and living expenses.
  4. Keep the tie-breakers from lesson 3.3.3, in order: stronger historical coverage, lower top-customer share, more depth below the owner, clearer seller motivation, shorter drive from home. Use them when two targets land within three points of each other.

Pass 1: public data

  1. Run the gates from public records: state business filings, licensing boards, permit records, court records, the business's own website and reviews.
  2. Score every category. Half points at most for anything unknown, and a "?" in the cell.
  3. Act on the band. 70 or more: open a conversation or request the package. 55 to 69: write down the one or two questions holding the score down; the next step is only to answer them. Below 55: log and stop.
  4. Expect crowding in popular sectors. A 2026 practitioner paper cataloguing the stated criteria of 76 active acquirers found that 36 percent targeted HVAC, alongside manufacturing, electrical contracting, distribution and home services (U12, 2026). Most of those acquirers target larger earnings than a self-funded buyer, but a popular sector still means competition, and competition shows up in price. Let your match-to-thesis score, inside fit with you, reflect it.

Pass 2: the seller's documents

  1. Re-run the gates on the real numbers. Concentration and trajectory are the gates most likely to flip once a customer list arrives.
  2. Re-score every cell from the documents, using your own tested earnings figure, never the seller's adjusted number. Lesson 6.2.1 covers the tests.
  3. Score the coverage line twice: at the asking price and at the price you would pay. The gap between the two totals is what the asking price costs the deal. If the target clears 70 only at your price, that is your price. If it clears 70 at neither, it does not advance without a written override memo (lesson 3.3.3).
  4. Record the second-pass score as the score of record, with the date and the documents it relied on.

Keep the rubric honest

  • Never re-score without new data. A target does not go from 64 to 71 because you thought about it overnight.
  • Review your passes quarterly. Read the log of targets you scored below 55 and check whether any later sold to someone else on terms you would have taken. If several did, your gates are too tight. If none did, they are working.
  • File every override memo, and check its expiry condition when it comes due.

Deliverable

For every target in your pipeline, a scoring sheet with:

  • The hard gates, each marked pass or fail, with the evidence.
  • Pass 1 scores by category, with "?" on every unknown, the total, the band and the action taken.
  • Pass 2 scores from the seller's documents, with the coverage line scored at the asking price and at your price.
  • The score of record, the date and the decision: advance toward an LOI, resolve named questions, or pass.
  • Any override memo.

Then a one-page pipeline ranking: every live target by score of record, so you can see at a glance where your next week of work belongs.

This lesson is education, not lending or investment advice. SBA eligibility and coverage are determined by the lender under the current SOP; confirm both with your lender before relying on them.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What DSCR does the SBA require for a business acquisition?

Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, an initial acquisition needs a debt service coverage ratio of at least 1.25, measured on historical earnings, not projections. DSCR is EBITDA divided by annual debt payments after the purchase. The lender determines coverage under the current SOP, so confirm it with your lender.

What are hard gates in a deal scoring rubric?

Hard gates are pass-or-fail tests checked before any points are counted. A target that fails one is out, whatever else it scores. The textbook's example uses seven: SBA eligibility, an earnings band, a concentration cap, 1.25 historical coverage, a clean legal record, transferable licenses and contracts, and verifiable earnings. Each should be something you would walk from even at a low price.

Should I score a deal at the asking price or at my own price?

Both. Score historical coverage at the asking price and at the price you would pay. If the target clears 70 only at your price, that is your price. In the textbook's fictional example, the deal scores 60 at the ask and 64 at the buyer's price. Both are under 70, so a letter of intent needs a written override memo.

Can I pursue a deal that fails my own acquisition criteria?

A failed hard gate ends the deal. A score under the bar can be overruled, but only in writing. Before you spend another hour, write an override memo naming the rule, why you are overruling it, the specific mitigant, and the condition under which the override expires. An override you cannot write down is a feeling, not a judgment.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C7

    Capron, L., & Shen, J.-C. (2007). Acquisitions of private vs. public firms: Private information, target selection, and acquirer returns. Strategic Management Journal, 28(9), 891-911.

  2. U12

    Totter, C (2026). Buyer-side demand in the U.S. lower middle market: A cross-sectional analysis of 76 active acquirers (Q4 2025 to Q2 2026). SSRN working paper (CT Strategic Partners LLC), 19 pages, posted 6 June 2026.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.

  4. Y28

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). Policy Notice 5000-876441: Update to SOP 50 10 8, Citizenship and Residency Requirements, and Rescission of Procedural Notice 5000-872050. Effective March 1, 2026.