Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part III: Prepare/Thesis and Buy Box

Lesson 3.3.3

The Scoring Rubric

A weighted score with hard gates and action bands that decide whether a target is pursued, investigated, held conditionally or passed. You may overrule the rubric, but only in writing, with the override memo on file.

Lesson 7 of 12 in this part · 11 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How do I score and compare businesses I am considering buying?

Use hard gates first, then points. A business that fails any pass-or-fail gate, such as SBA eligibility, customer concentration or 1.25 to 1 historical debt service coverage, is out. Survivors get a 0 to 100 weighted score across six categories. Score once on public data and again on the seller's documents; the second score is the score of record.

Your buy box (lesson 3.3.2) builds a list of businesses worth looking at. A scoring rubric decides what you do about each one: pursue it, dig deeper, hold it until one question is answered, or pass. Without a rubric, those decisions get made by mood: the deal you saw on a good day gets a call, the one you saw while tired gets a pass, and the one a broker is pushing hard gets your weekend. A rubric makes you judge every business the same way, writes down why, and gives you a record to check yourself against. This lesson builds one: a 0 to 100 weighted score, seven hard gates, action bands, and the rule that lets you overrule all of it, but only in writing.

Principle

Gates first, then points. A hard gate is a pass-or-fail test. A business that fails any gate is out, no matter how well it scores elsewhere. Points come second: they rank the businesses that survive the gates. Never let a high score buy back a failed gate. That is how buyers talk themselves into the deals that ruin them.

Weight what kills self-funded buyers. The categories and weights below are this curriculum's example, built for a self-funded buyer using an SBA 7(a) loan and a personal guarantee. They lean hardest on the things that break those deals: earnings that are not real or not recurring, revenue that depends on one customer, and a business that cannot run without its owner. Fit with you carries real weight too. A 2026 study of 903 entrepreneurs who entered business through takeovers found that lacking prior industry and functional knowledge was associated with a higher risk of exit afterward (A16). Adjust the weights to your thesis, but decide them before you score your first business, and do not change them to rescue a favorite.

Score twice. The first pass uses public data only and takes about half an hour. Mark every unknown with a question mark and score it conservatively. The second pass uses the seller's documents (the CIM, which is the confidential information memorandum a broker prepares, plus tax returns and financial statements). The second-pass score is the score of record. It decides whether you write a letter of intent.

Bands decide the action. The score maps to one of four bands, and each band carries a required next step. That turns the rubric from an opinion into a workflow.

You may overrule the rubric, but only in writing. Judgment matters, and some good deals fail a rule for a reason that can be managed. The protection is the override memo: which rule you are overriding, why, what specifically mitigates the risk, and the condition under which the override expires. It is signed, dated and filed with the scoring sheet. If you cannot write the memo, you do not have a reason. You have a feeling.

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. It surfaced from public data in lesson 3.3.2: an HVAC contractor in Palm Bay, Florida, founded in 2009, owner in his late 50s, no second licensed qualifier, an estimated $5 million to $8 million in revenue, and one large townhome project with a local homebuilder in the county permit records.

First pass, public data only. It clears all seven gates, with two marked unknown pending documents (historical coverage and verifiability). It scores 70: financial quality 16 of 25 (mostly question marks scored conservatively), revenue and customers 13 of 20 (prepaid maintenance agreements visible in public filings), seller and succession 14 of 20, operations and people 8 of 15 (no visible second-in-command), fit with you 10 of 10, location and network 9 of 10. That is the bottom of the strong-fit band: reach out and request documents.

Second pass, with the documents. The broker's memo claims $1,710,000 of adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, after the seller's adjustments). Rebuilt from the tax returns and the profit and loss statement, recurring earnings are about $1,017,000. Revenue jumped 25 percent in 2025 on one commercial new-construction job and on homeowners pulling replacements forward ahead of an announced equipment price increase tied to the refrigerant transition. One homebuilder accounts for about 38 percent of receivables. The owner is the general manager, the lead salesperson and the only license qualifier.

Score the second pass twice: once at the asking price, and once at your price, the one you rebuild from recurring earnings. Only the lines that depend on price move.

Category Max First pass, public data Second pass, at the ask Second pass, at your price What changed
Financial quality 25 16 11 15 Margin spike and hockey-stick year. Coverage fails at the asking price (about 1.10x) and clears at your price
Revenue and customers 20 13 9 9 One builder at 38% of receivables; a one-time job inside 2025 revenue
Seller and succession 20 14 16 16 Clear motivation (moving near grandkids), open to a seller note
Operations and people 15 8 5 5 Confirmed: no second-in-command; owner is the only qualifier
Fit with you 10 10 10 10 Unchanged
Location and network 10 9 9 9 Unchanged
Total 100 70 60 64 Strong fit to conditional, at either price

At the ask, the deal scores 60 and fails the coverage test: about 1.10x against the 1.25x floor. At your price, coverage clears and financial quality rises from 11 to 15. Nothing else moves, because a lower price does not change who the customers are or who holds the license. The total is 64, still under 70. In both columns the rubric says: stop, name the one or two questions that could disqualify this business, and resolve them before any more work. Here they are: what are the real recurring earnings, and who runs the company and holds the license after the owner leaves? The rubric also says a letter of intent requires 70 or more on the second pass.

The buyer in this curriculum's case goes on to write a letter of intent anyway, at a price rebuilt from the $1,017,000, not the $1,710,000. That is a legitimate decision, and it is exactly what the override memo is for. The memo names the two open questions and turns both into closing conditions: the deal does not close unless each is answered. The Steps section below shows that memo. Without it, the same decision would be a buyer falling in love with a deal.

Steps

1. Write your seven hard gates

Each gate is pass, fail or unknown. A fail disqualifies. An unknown must be resolved before the second-pass score is final. This curriculum's example set:

# Gate Fails when
1 Eligibility The business is a type the SBA does not lend to (13 CFR 120.110, Y31), or you are not an eligible borrower under SOP 50 10 8.1 (Y25)
2 Earnings band Earnings fall outside the band your financing supports (lesson 3.3.2)
3 Concentration One customer exceeds the cap you set in advance (RF-01)
4 Historical coverage No price you would pay, at a stack you can afford, reaches 1.25 to 1 debt service coverage on trailing or two-year-average historical earnings, the SOP 50 10 8.1 floor for initial acquisitions
5 Clean record Active bankruptcy, debarment, or litigation that threatens the core of the business (RF-02)
6 Transferability A license, contract, lease or franchise the business cannot operate without will not transfer to you and cannot be replaced by closing. A license belongs to a person, not the business, so for a licensed trade the test is whether someone licensed will qualify the company after the owner leaves; rules vary by state (RF-03, RF-06)
7 Verifiability The seller will not produce tax returns and bank statements, so the earnings cannot be proven

Add your household's red lines from lesson 3.1.2 as gates too.

2. Set categories and weights

Category Weight Sub-criteria (max points)
Financial quality 25 Earnings size in band (5), margin stability (5), three-year trend quality (5), historical coverage at your stack (5), cash conversion and working capital (5)
Revenue and customers 20 Top customer or referral source share (6), recurring revenue share (6), channel dependency (4), one-time items in revenue (4)
Seller and succession 20 Owner tenure (4), owner age (3), no successor in place (3), motivation clarity (3), willingness to carry a seller note (4), willingness to consult through the transition (3)
Operations and people 15 Depth below the owner (5), key-employee risk (4), licenses and contracts transferable (3), condition of equipment and deferred capital spending (3)
Fit with you 10 Your edge in the industry (6), match to your thesis (4)
Location and network 10 Inside a priority cluster (5), your network's reach into the business's market (5)

For the transition sub-criterion, remember the rule: under SOP 50 10 8.1, when you buy 100 percent of the business in an initial acquisition, the seller cannot remain an officer, director, stockholder or employee, but can consult for no more than 24 months in total.

3. Write the point bands

For every sub-criterion, write what earns full points, partial points and zero, before you score anything. Examples:

  • Top customer share (6): under 10% = 6; 10 to 20% = 4; 20 to 30% = 2; over 30% = 0, and check the concentration gate.
  • Depth below the owner (5): a general manager who runs daily operations = 5; a capable lead in one area = 2; nobody = 0.
  • Owner tenure (4): over 20 years = 4; 10 to 20 = 3; 5 to 10 = 1; under 5 = 0.

These bands are this curriculum's illustrations, not market standards. Set yours from your thesis.

4. Set the action bands

Score Band Required action
85 to 100 Pursue Contact within five business days; brief your lender; prepare for a letter of intent
70 to 84 Strong fit Request the CIM and documents; run the second pass before any letter of intent
55 to 69 Conditional Name the one or two disqualifying questions; resolve them before any more work; re-score only with new data
Under 55 Pass Log the reason; do not pursue this cycle

A letter of intent requires 70 or more on the second pass.

5. Set tie-breakers

When two businesses score within three points, break the tie in this order: stronger historical coverage, lower top-customer share, more depth below the owner, clearer seller motivation, shorter drive from home.

6. Score the first pass

Use public data only. Give yourself about 30 minutes: five for the gates, the rest for the categories. Mark every unknown with a question mark and score it at or below the middle of its range. Write the top three risks and top three strengths every time, even when the score is low.

7. Score the second pass

When documents arrive, re-score every line from the documents, not from memory of the first pass. Replace every question mark. The second-pass score is the score of record. Lesson 5.3.1 covers running the rubric across a whole pipeline.

8. Write the override memo when you overrule it

An override memo has four parts and fits on half a page. Here is the one for Coastal Comfort:

Rule overridden: letter of intent requires 70+ on the second pass. Second-pass score: 60 at the ask, 64 at my price.

Why: The low score comes from two open questions: what the real recurring earnings are, and who runs the company and holds the license after the owner leaves. The first is sharper than the score shows: my $1,017,000 implies an 18.7 percent margin on the recurring business against 14.8 percent the year before, and the documents do not explain the gap. Both questions can be answered before closing. The business has a real recurring base, prepaid maintenance agreements, and a motivated seller.

Specific mitigant: Price rebuilt from about $1,017,000 of recurring earnings, not the broker's $1,710,000. Both open questions become closing conditions in the letter of intent. First, a quality of earnings report satisfactory to me and acceptable to the lender, which SOP 50 10 8.1 requires in any case at a purchase price of $3 million or more, with the margin question written into its scope. Second, a written qualifying-agent agreement with a licensed employee, approved by the Florida licensing board to take effect at closing. A contractor license belongs to a person and does not transfer with the business, and I cannot qualify one myself in the time the deal allows. No part of the price is contingent on future results (a seller earnout is prohibited inside an SBA 7(a) loan under SOP 50 10 8.1). Seller consulting agreement through the transition.

Expiry: The override lapses if the quality of earnings report does not confirm recurring earnings within 10 percent of $1,017,000, or if no board-approved qualifying agent is in place before closing. Either one ends the deal. Inside that band, the price is rebuilt on the report's number, not mine.

Signed and dated.

Notice what the memo does not say: "I have a good feeling," "the seller likes me," or "I have been searching for eleven months." If those are the real reasons, there is no memo, and there is no deal.

Deliverable

A Scoring Rubric and a Scoring Sheet template:

  • The rubric: your seven gates (plus household red lines), six categories with weights and point bands, action bands, tie-breakers, and the 70-point LOI rule. Dated, and changed only between deals, never during one.
  • The sheet, one per business: identity, gate results with evidence, every sub-criterion score with a note, total, band, top three risks, top three strengths, open questions, and three score columns: first pass, second pass at the ask, and second pass at your price.
  • An override memo template with the four parts: rule overridden, why, specific mitigant, expiry. Every open question the memo names must appear in your letter of intent as a closing condition.

Score Coastal Comfort yourself from the facts above, then compare your sheet with the scores in this lesson and write down every line where you disagree and why.

This lesson is education, not investment, legal or lending advice. A rubric organizes judgment; it does not replace diligence, and no score means a business is safe to buy.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What deal-breakers should rule out a business before I score it?

The textbook's example uses seven gates: SBA eligibility, earnings inside the band your financing supports, a customer concentration cap set in advance, 1.25 to 1 historical debt service coverage, a clean legal record, transferable licenses and contracts, and a seller who will produce tax returns and bank statements. A high score never buys back a failed gate.

What score should a deal reach before I write a letter of intent?

In the textbook's example rubric, a letter of intent requires 70 or more out of 100 on the second pass, the one scored from the seller's documents. Scores of 55 to 69 are conditional: name the one or two disqualifying questions and resolve them first. Under 55 is a pass. These bands are illustrations, not market standards.

When is it okay to override my own acquisition criteria?

Only in writing. An override memo names the rule you are overruling, why, the specific mitigant, and the condition under which the override expires. It is signed, dated and filed with the scoring sheet. If you cannot write the memo, you do not have a reason. You have a feeling.

How should I weight the criteria when evaluating a business to buy?

The textbook's example for a self-funded buyer using an SBA 7(a) loan weights financial quality at 25, revenue and customers at 20, seller and succession at 20, operations and people at 15, fit with you at 10, and location and network at 10. Set your weights before scoring the first business and never change them to rescue a favorite.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. A16

    van Balen, T., de Regt, A., & de Jong, J. P. J. (2026). Survival after takeover entry: Effects of entrepreneurs' domain experience and knowledge acquisition behaviour. International Small Business Journal, online first.

  2. Y31

    Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (). 13 CFR Part 120, Business Loans.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.