This is the exercise the whole underwriting part has been building toward. You get a broker's package for a fictional HVAC company, with red flags planted in it on purpose. Your job is to get from the broker's earnings claim to your own number, from your own number to a fair value range, and from the range to a walk-away price and a verdict. Do it before you read the worked answer. The answer is printed below because this is an open textbook, but the value of the exercise is entirely in the attempt. A buyer who reads the answer first has learned what Coastal Comfort is worth. A buyer who works it first has learned how to find out what any business is worth.
Principle
The grade is the bridge, not the number. Anyone can copy a figure. What this exercise tests is whether you can walk from the seller's claim to your own figure one documented adjustment at a time, and defend every step to a lender, a quality of earnings provider, or the seller.
Three rules govern the attempt:
- Use only the documents. Every adjustment you make has to point at a line in the P&L, the tax return, the balance sheet or the broker's memo. If you cannot point at it, you cannot make it.
- Price the business a new owner will run, not the one the seller ran. The owner's below-market salary, the spouse on payroll, the personal truck, the one year that will not repeat: all of them describe the seller's business. You are buying the one that is left after he leaves.
- Expect the year before the sale to be the year the numbers were dressed. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer the business outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55, 2023). You are the outsider in this deal.
Case
Coastal Comfort HVAC, LLC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Every name and number in it is invented, and every pattern in it comes from the failure record.
The business. A residential and light-commercial HVAC contractor in Palm Bay, Florida, founded in March 2009 and taxed as an S corporation. Thirty-six people: 24 field technicians and installers, 6 office staff, 4 salespeople and estimators, the owner's spouse part-time on the books, and the owner. The owner, Ray Delgado, is 58. He runs sales, dispatch and the largest jobs himself, and there is no second-in-command. He wants to move to Georgia to be near his daughter and grandchildren.
The broker's pitch. Gulfstream Business Advisors presents FY2025 as "the Company's strongest year ever" and as the go-forward earnings base: record revenue of $6.675 million, up 25 percent; a strong relationship with a major local homebuilder; 800-plus recurring maintenance agreements; an owner willing to stay for a short transition. The ask is $6,450,000, which the broker describes as 3.8 times adjusted EBITDA, plus inventory at cost.
Document 1: Profit and loss, FY2023 to FY2025 (internally prepared, unaudited)
| FY2023 | FY2024 | FY2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service, maintenance and repair | $2,640,000 | $2,930,000 | $2,805,000 |
| Residential replacement and install | $1,920,000 | $2,130,000 | $2,670,000 |
| Commercial and new-construction install | $240,000 | $265,000 | $1,200,000 |
| Total revenue | $4,800,000 | $5,325,000 | $6,675,000 |
| Gross margin | 41.5% | 42.0% | 44.0% |
| Owner compensation | $90,000 | $90,000 | $90,000 |
| Family payroll (spouse, bookkeeping) | $68,000 | $72,000 | $78,000 |
| Advertising and marketing | $105,000 | $138,000 | $232,000 |
| Professional fees | $42,000 | $45,000 | $69,000 |
| EBITDA as reported | $714,000 | $857,000 | $1,308,000 |
| EBITDA margin | 14.9% | 16.1% | 19.6% |
Notes to the P&L:
- The owner is the full-time working manager and takes most of his earnings as distributions.
- FY2025 revenue includes one commercial new-construction contract, the 41-unit Harbor Pointe townhome project for Beachline, a local homebuilder, completed in the second and third quarters. The job-cost report shows it billed $930,000 and contributed about $205,000 after materials, subcontractors and field labor (about 22 percent).
- Several residential customers accelerated full-system replacements in 2025 ahead of an announced equipment price increase tied to the refrigerant transition. Management estimates that about $300,000 of FY2025 replacement revenue was pulled forward. Replacement work contributes about 29 percent after equipment, field labor and commissions.
- FY2025 advertising includes a rebrand and website relaunch; FY2025 professional fees include legal costs from a landlord lease dispute.
Document 2: FY2025 tax return (Form 1120-S, summary)
Gross receipts $6,675,000, matching the P&L. Officer compensation $90,000. Ordinary business income $1,209,000. Distributions to the shareholder: $810,000.
Document 3: Balance sheet, December 31, 2025 (internally prepared, unaudited)
Accounts receivable $645,000; inventory $248,000; deferred revenue from prepaid maintenance agreements $57,000. Note A: a single commercial customer, Beachline, represents about $245,000, roughly 38 percent, of year-end receivables. Note B: about 810 active residential maintenance plans. Note C: vehicles include the owner's personal-use pickup truck, titled to and expensed through the company.
Document 4: The broker's adjusted EBITDA
| Adjustment | Amount | Broker's note |
|---|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA, FY2025 | $1,308,000 | |
| Owner's W-2 salary | +$90,000 | "New owner can run it" |
| Spouse payroll | +$78,000 | "Role eliminable" |
| Owner's personal vehicle | +$27,000 | "Personal use" |
| One-time rebrand and website | +$90,000 | "Non-recurring marketing" |
| One-time legal (lease dispute) | +$33,000 | "Non-recurring" |
| Owner health insurance and personal items | +$24,000 | "Discretionary owner perk" |
| Projected rent savings | +$60,000 | "Expected savings after closing" |
| Seller's adjusted EBITDA | $1,710,000 |
Steps
The tasks
Work these in order, on paper or in a spreadsheet, before you scroll further. Budget a few focused hours.
- Reconcile. Does revenue on the P&L tie to the tax return? What does the gap between $90,000 of salary and $810,000 of distributions tell you?
- Normalize owner pay. What does it cost to hire someone to do Ray's job? Make the adjustment the broker did not. For this exercise, use $225,000 for a market general manager (salary, bonus and payroll taxes, with no health coverage in the figure) and about $23,000 for a part-time bookkeeper.
- Grade every add-back A, B or C (lesson 6.2.1). Accept, haircut or reject each one, with a one-line reason pointing at a document.
- Find what will not repeat. Isolate the FY2025 items that a new owner should not expect again, and compute their EBITDA contribution from the job-cost and pull-forward figures in the notes to the P&L.
- State your recurring adjusted EBITDA. One number, with the bridge from $1,308,000 shown line by line.
- List the red flags by their RF numbers from lesson 5.2.1, with the evidence for each.
- Value it. Apply a 3.0x to 4.5x multiple range to your recurring number. Compare the range to the ask.
- Model it and set the walk-away. Run the lesson 6.5.1 model and the four ceilings from lesson 6.5.2.
- Write the verdict. One page: walk, or re-trade, and if re-trade, the structure you would offer and why.
How it is graded
- Recurring adjusted EBITDA between $975,000 and $1,050,000, with every line of the bridge tied to a document. A number outside that band can still pass if the reasoning is documented and conservative; a number inside it fails if the bridge is missing.
- Mandatory catches: the owner-pay normalization is a net reduction, not an add-back; the projected rent savings are rejected outright; the FY2025 commercial job and the pulled-forward replacements are removed from recurring earnings; the homebuilder concentration is named as a risk, not a strength.
- The margin check: your recurring margin compared with FY2024's normalized margin, and the unexplained gap carried forward as an open question for the quality of earnings report. A bridge that never tests its own result loses marks even if the number is in the band.
- A fair value range and a walk-away price that both sit far below the ask, with the arithmetic shown.
- A verdict that does not depend on the bull case.
Worked answer (read only after you have attempted the exercise)
Step 1, reconcile. Revenue ties: $6,675,000 on the P&L, $6,675,000 on the return. The $810,000 of distributions against a $90,000 salary is the first real finding. The owner has been paid mostly as an owner, not as the manager he actually is, so the P&L shows a business that does not pay for its own management.
Steps 2 to 5, the bridge.
| Line | Adjustment | Treatment and reason |
|---|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA, FY2025 | $1,308,000 | Starting point |
| Owner compensation | -$135,000 | Add back the $90,000 salary, then subtract $225,000 for a market general manager (salary, bonus and payroll taxes). Ray does sales, dispatch and job supervision; someone has to be paid to do them. The broker's version adds $90,000 and subtracts nothing. |
| Spouse payroll | +$55,000 | Haircut. Some real bookkeeping work exists; only the $78,000 less about $23,000 for a part-time bookkeeper is an add-back. |
| Owner's vehicle | +$18,000 | Haircut to the personal portion of one truck (balance sheet Note C). The rest of the fleet is operating cost. |
| Lease-dispute legal | +$33,000 | Accept. Documented, specific, and the prior two years show normal professional fees. |
| Rebrand | +$30,000 | Haircut. Advertising rose from $105,000 to $138,000 to $232,000; most of the increase is ongoing lead generation, and only about $30,000 is a true one-time relaunch. |
| Owner health insurance | $0 | Reject. The company will keep paying for a health plan for whoever does Ray's job, so the cost does not go away with him. The $225,000 manager figure does not include health coverage. |
| Projected rent savings | $0 | Reject outright. It is a forecast of a cost that has not changed, not a historical expense. Never an add-back. |
| Normalized adjusted EBITDA, including FY2025's spike | about $1,309,000 | |
| The one-time commercial job and replacement pull-forward | -$292,000 | Both figures come from the notes to the P&L. Harbor Pointe contributed about $205,000 (job-cost report). About $300,000 of pulled-forward replacement revenue at a 29 percent contribution is $87,000. $205,000 plus $87,000 is $292,000. Neither repeats. |
| Recurring adjusted EBITDA | about $1,017,000 |
Notice that the broker's add-backs and your adjustments nearly cancel out: normalized EBITDA including the spike lands almost exactly on the reported $1,308,000. The broker's $402,000 of extra earnings is almost entirely invented. The real reduction comes from the spike, which no add-back schedule mentions. The broker's number overstates recurring earnings by $693,000; recurring earnings are about 60 percent of the headline.
The three-year cross-check. Normalize each year the same way (the manager, the bookkeeper, the truck) and you get about $642,000 for FY2023, $789,000 for FY2024 and $1,017,000 for FY2025, a three-year average of about $816,000. That is not the same neighborhood. It is lower, because the business grew. Use the average to confirm the direction, not as the number. It matters for a second reason: under SOP 50 10 8.1 the lender tests coverage on the last fiscal year or on the average of the last two, and that two-year average is about $903,000. The SOP lets the lender use either one. Build a structure that clears on both.
The margin check. One more test before you trust the bridge. Take Harbor Pointe's $930,000 and the $300,000 of pulled-forward replacements out of FY2025 revenue and about $5,445,000 is left, earning the recurring $1,017,000: an EBITDA margin of about 18.7 percent. FY2024, normalized the same way, earned about $789,000 on $5,325,000, about 14.8 percent. Taking out low-margin project work should not lift the margin of what is left by almost four points on almost the same revenue, and FY2025 gross margin rose to 44.0 percent in the very year low-margin project work was added. Every line of your bridge is supported; the documents underneath it do not explain the margin. You do not change your number before the letter of intent, because you have nothing yet to change it to. You name it as the first open question in your override memo ("what are the real recurring earnings"), write it into the QoE scope, and keep the QoE condition in the letter. Lesson 7.3.1 shows what the QoE found.
Step 6, the red flags.
- RF-04, owner dependency. Ray holds sales, dispatch and the largest jobs, and there is no second-in-command. Price the job you are buying.
- RF-09, revenue and margin erosion, run in reverse. A margin spike to 19.6 percent against 14.9 and 16.1 percent, presented as the base year. This is the hockey stick from lesson 6.3.1.
- RF-01 and RF-12, concentration and channel dependency. Beachline is 38 percent of receivables and the source of the spike. The broker presents it as a strength. It is a single relationship that may not transfer.
- RF-11, aggressive add-backs. Seven add-backs: two rejected outright, three haircut, one accepted, and the owner-salary line reversed into a net reduction.
- RF-06, lease and cost cliff, as an open question. A landlord dispute in FY2025 means the lease file is a diligence priority, and the "projected rent savings" suggest the seller expects the location to change.
Diligence later adds two that no document in this package shows: RF-07, key technicians, and RF-03, the contractor license qualifier.
Step 7, the value. 3.0x to 4.5x of $1,017,000 is about $3,051,000 to $4,577,000, with a midpoint near $3,814,000. The $6,450,000 ask is about $1,873,000 above the top of that range and about 6.3 times recurring earnings, not the 3.8 times the broker advertises. The seller is asking you to pay a market multiple on earnings that mostly do not exist for a new owner.
Step 8, the walk-away. From lessons 6.5.1 and 6.5.2: value ceiling about $3,814,000; lender ceiling about $4,850,000, where the $5,000,000 maximum for a standard 7(a) loan binds before 1.25x coverage does; 25 percent IRR ceiling about $4,750,000; survival ceiling at 1.10x in the bear case about $3,630,000 (the buyer's stress test, not the lender's). Walk-away price: $3,600,000, in cash at closing.
Step 9, the verdict. Two answers are defensible, and both get full marks if the reasoning is sound.
- Walk. The ask is $2,850,000 above your walk-away, the seller's own memo presents a peak year as the base, and the add-back schedule includes a forecast dressed as history. Under Gate 3 of the Walk-Away Doctrine, "the financials don't survive QoE scrutiny" is a kill condition, and the broker's number plainly does not.
- Re-trade with structure. Offer a price built on your recurring number and let structure carry the two ugliest findings. The case's offer is $3,800,000, about 3.74 times recurring EBITDA and $2,650,000 under the ask. Cash at closing stays under the walk-away. The rest sits in two seller notes behind the SBA loan: one on full standby (no payments of principal or interest for the term of the SBA loan) and one paying over seven years. The spike is priced by building the price on recurring earnings that exclude it. The concentration is priced by how much of the price waits in the standby note, and by a right, drafted by your attorney and approved by your lender, to set off indemnity claims against the seller notes. Nothing in the price is contingent. Under SOP 50 10 8.1 (effective October 1, 2026), seller earnouts are prohibited in an SBA 7(a) acquisition, and the only contingent tool the SOP names is a buyer rebate, which must be applied to pay down the loan. A seller who believes his own story can accept paper that waits behind the bank. Research on private-firm acquisitions finds exactly this pattern: seller financing becomes more common as the buyer's information gap grows (C24, 2020). Watch which term he negotiates first. It tells you what he actually believes.
One more rule check for the record: under SOP 50 10 8.1 (Y25), a quality of earnings report with a cash proof is mandatory for initial acquisitions at a business purchase price of $3 million or more. That covers the ask and the $3,800,000 offer alike. The report must not be prepared by or for the seller; one the buyer commissions may be used once the lender's approved vendor has reviewed it, and the lender must use its earnings figure in the coverage test. This bridge is your best estimate of what it will find, and the margin check tells you where it is most likely to be wrong. That is why the letter carries a QoE condition: if the report comes in lower, the price can move without anyone breaching anything.
Where the case goes next
The curriculum follows the re-trade branch so that later lessons can teach the deal from letter of intent to closing on the same company. In brief:
- Sourcing (Part IV). Coastal Comfort surfaced in the buyer's own target list from public data, before any broker was involved: 17 years in business, a founder in his late 50s, no second licensed qualifier, and a 41-unit townhome project with a local homebuilder in the 2025 permit records. The buyer's first note on the file was "verify whether 2025's jump is a trend or an event." That note turned out to be the whole deal. Outreach produced a suspicious first reply, then a relationship, then a call-back on day 18: the owner had signed with a broker and brought the buyer's name to the process.
- The letter of intent (Part VII, lesson 7.1.1), sent Day 47. $3,800,000 for substantially all assets: $3,150,000 in cash at closing, a $350,000 Seller Note A on full standby for the life of the SBA loan, and a $300,000 Seller Note B at 6 percent, amortizing over 7 years from closing. Working capital delivered at a normalized peg, estimated at $470,000. Closing conditions on a written qualifying-agent agreement with a licensed employee, approved by the state licensing board to take effect at closing (a contractor license belongs to a person and does not transfer with a business), the lease, a quality of earnings report satisfactory to the buyer and acceptable to the lender, at least 750 active maintenance plans, and an SBA financing commitment. Accepted on Day 52. Lesson 6.5.2 explains why a $3,800,000 price does not break a $3,600,000 walk-away: the cash never crossed it.
- Diligence (lesson 7.3.1), memo dated Day 123. The planted flags were confirmed. The quality of earnings report tied the revenue to the bank but not the margin: it moved recurring adjusted EBITDA to about $920,000, and the buyer re-traded the price to $3,500,000 by amendment to the letter of intent on Day 104. Diligence also added what no screen can see: there is no master agreement with Beachline at all, 8 of the 24 field technicians are one extended family, and the lease expires in 14 months with no renewal option. The buyer moved $50,000 of the price into Seller Note A, set up a $60,000 seller-funded retention escrow for two key technicians, and got a 5-year lease renewal. On the license (Florida law; other states differ): Ray is the company's only qualifying agent and cannot stay after closing, and the buyer cannot qualify a certified license in 12 months, so the company keeps a permanent, paid qualifier, the senior install lead, who already holds a certified license, on a $24,000-a-year stipend with 90 days' notice, while the buyer is approved as the company's financially responsible officer. Verdict: pursue with modified structure.
- Close (lesson 7.7.1), Day 142. An SBA loan of $3,030,000, Seller Note A of $500,000 on full standby, Seller Note B of $250,000 paying, $210,000 of the buyer's own cash and $210,000 from outside investors, for a total project of $4,200,000: the $3,500,000 price, $250,000 of closing costs and SBA fees, and $450,000 of working capital. That $450,000 is cash the loan and the equity put into the company; it is separate from the working-capital peg, which is what the seller must leave in the business. Equity is exactly 10 percent of the project, half from the buyer and half from minority investors. The lender's independent valuation is $3,550,000. Coverage on the quality of earnings figure of about $920,000 is about 1.75x on FY2025 and about 1.61x on the two-year average, above the 1.25x SBA floor, and the bear case, about $583,000 of EBITDA, holds at about 1.11x, just above the 1.10x floor. Total debt is $3,780,000, exactly 90 percent of the project: at the red line lesson 7.5.1 warns about, not over it. The final walk-away gate ran on Day 139, the week of the wire, on purpose, when leaving felt impossible.
Deliverable
Your graded deal package for Coastal Comfort:
- The reconciliation note: what ties, what does not, and what the distributions tell you.
- The earnings bridge from $1,308,000 to your recurring number, every line graded A, B or C and tied to a document.
- The red flag list with RF numbers and evidence.
- The fair value range against the ask, with the implied multiple of the ask on your recurring earnings.
- The one-page LBO summary from lesson 6.5.1 and the walk-away card from lesson 6.5.2.
- A one-page verdict memo: walk, or re-trade with the structure spelled out.
Grade it against the worked answer. Where your number differs, find the line where the bridges diverge and decide, in writing, which one you would defend to a lender.
This exercise is education, not investment, accounting, lending, tax or legal advice. Coastal Comfort HVAC and everyone in it are fictional. A licensed CPA should review the financials, and a deal attorney the structure, of any business you intend to buy.