A quality of earnings report (QoE) is an accounting firm's independent test of whether the profit a seller reports is the profit the business actually produces. You should buy one before you close. But most of what sinks first-time buyers is visible long before that report exists, in the documents the seller has already sent you. This lesson is the six findings you can catch yourself, at no cost, before you spend a dollar on outside diligence or sign a letter of intent.
Principle
The seller's earnings number is a claim, not a fact. Treat it the way a lender treats your personal financial statement: something to be tested against source documents, line by line, before anyone relies on it.
That is not cynicism about sellers. It is how the incentives work. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer ownership to someone outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55). You are the outsider. The year before a sale is the year the number is most likely to have been shaped, deliberately or not.
Small private companies also have no outside party forcing their statements to mean anything. Most are not audited, and research on private firms shows how much the quality and form of their financial statements varies with who is asking for them (C58). The statements you receive were built for the owner's tax return and the owner's banker. Nobody built them for you.
So the rule is simple. Every dollar of earnings has to trace to a tax return, a bank deposit, or a contract. What does not trace does not get paid for.
One more rule sits under everything in this part of the curriculum, and it is the reason this lesson matters: you pay a multiple of earnings, so every error is multiplied. At four times earnings, every $1 of overstated profit adds $4 to the price. Catching a $100,000 overstatement is not a $100,000 save. It is a $400,000 save, and on a deal financed with a personally guaranteed loan, it is $400,000 you would otherwise have borrowed against your house.
Case
Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Its numbers are invented, but every pattern in it comes from the failure record.
The broker's memo presents $1,710,000 of adjusted EBITDA and an asking price of $6,450,000. The documents in the data room tell a different story, and three of the six findings below are sitting in plain view:
- A hockey stick. Revenue jumped 25 percent in the last year, from $5,325,000 to $6,675,000, after a rise of about 11 percent the year before. Two drivers explain it, and neither repeats: one large commercial new-construction job, and homeowners pulling forward system replacements ahead of an announced equipment price increase.
- A margin spike to match. EBITDA margin rose to 19.6 percent in the final year against roughly 15 to 16 percent in the two years before. The broker presents the peak year as the base year.
- Owner pay that was never normalized. The owner drew a $90,000 salary while running the company as general manager, lead salesperson and job supervisor. Replacing him costs about $225,000 a year in salary, bonus and payroll taxes. The broker's memo adds the whole $90,000 back and subtracts nothing.
Work those three findings, plus the add-backs graded in lesson 6.2.1, and the recurring earnings a new owner can actually expect land near $1,017,000. The spike itself comes off using the seller's own notes: the job-cost report shows the one-time project contributed about $205,000, and about $300,000 of pulled-forward replacement revenue at a 29 percent contribution is another $87,000, $292,000 in all. Lesson 6.6.1 shows the whole bridge. The result is about 60 percent of the headline. At the asking multiple, the gap of $693,000 is worth about $2,600,000 of purchase price, and every bit of it was findable from the P&L, the tax return and the broker's own memo.
One test is left, and it is Finding 2 run on your own number. The recurring $1,017,000 on the roughly $5,445,000 of revenue left after the one-time job and the pull-forward is an EBITDA margin of about 18.7 percent. FY2024, normalized the same way, ran about 14.8 percent. Your bridge took the spike out of revenue, and the margin is still almost four points higher than the year before. The documents do not say why. That is not a reason to change your number before the letter of intent; it is the first question in your override memo and a named item in the QoE scope. Lesson 7.3.1 shows what the QoE found.
The buyers in the failure record who lost everything rarely missed something exotic. They missed this.
Steps
Before you start: get the right documents
Request these before you analyze anything. If the seller cannot or will not produce them, that is your first finding.
- Three years of profit and loss statements, plus the current year to date.
- Three years of business tax returns for the entity you are buying, not the owner's personal return.
- Twelve to twenty-four months of business bank statements.
- The current balance sheet and the two prior year-end balance sheets.
- Accounts receivable and accounts payable aging reports as of the latest month end.
- The seller's or broker's add-back schedule, with a line-item explanation for each add-back.
Then reconcile before you analyze. Revenue on the P&L should tie to revenue on the tax return, and both should be supported by deposits in the bank statements. If the three do not reconcile, stop. Nothing downstream is reliable until they do.
Finding 1: Hockey-stick revenue
What it looks like: a sharp jump in the most recent year that breaks the prior trend.
How to test it:
- Put three years of revenue side by side and calculate the growth rate each year.
- If the last year grew much faster than the years before it, ask the seller in writing: what drove the increase, and will it repeat?
- Ask for revenue by customer and by job for the last two years. Look for one or two large items that explain the jump.
- Check for pulled-forward demand: price increases announced in advance, a regulation change, a one-time contract, a pandemic or storm year.
What to do with it: value the business on its recurring revenue, not the spike. Remove the profit contribution of anything that will not repeat: ask for the job-cost report on a one-time job, and for pulled-forward sales multiply the revenue by what that kind of work contributes after its direct costs. A three-year average of normalized earnings is a cross-check, not a substitute: in a growing business the average sits below the current recurring level.
Finding 2: The pre-sale margin spike
What it looks like: profit margin jumps in the final year while revenue is flat or growing modestly. Costs were cut to fatten the number.
How to test it:
- Calculate gross margin and EBITDA margin for each of the three years.
- If the final year jumped, compare each expense line year over year. Look for maintenance, marketing, payroll and equipment spending that fell.
- Ask the seller: which costs changed in the last year, and why?
- After you normalize, run it again on your recurring number: recurring EBITDA over the revenue left after one-time items, against the prior year normalized the same way. If your recurring margin is still well above the prior year and the documents do not explain it, look at what sits inside cost of goods (supplier rebates, year-end invoice timing) and send the question to the QoE.
What to do with it: cuts in maintenance, advertising or staffing are almost always deferred, not saved. You will reverse them after closing. Add the deferred cost back into your expense base and price the business on the normalized margin. This is the territory of red flags RF-08 (deferred capex) and RF-09 (revenue and margin erosion).
Finding 3: Owner pay that was never normalized
What it looks like: the earnings number assumes nobody has to be paid to do the owner's job.
How to test it:
- List every role the owner performs: general manager, salesperson, estimator, lead technician, bookkeeper.
- Price what it costs to hire someone to do those jobs at market wages in that region.
- Compare it to what the owner was actually paid on the W-2.
What to do with it: add back the owner's actual pay, then subtract the market cost of replacing them. In the Coastal Comfort case that is +$90,000 and then -$225,000: a net reduction of $135,000, not the $90,000 increase in the broker's memo. This is RF-04 (owner dependency) and Tier A of the add-back tiers in lesson 6.2.1.
Finding 4: Aggressive add-backs
What it looks like: a long list of "one-time" expenses that recur every year, or savings that have not happened yet.
How to test it:
- For each add-back, ask for the invoice or the payroll record behind it.
- Check whether the same "one-time" item appears in the prior two years.
- Reject outright anything that is a forecast rather than a historical expense. "Projected rent savings" is not an add-back. It is a hope.
What to do with it: accept only what you can document and defend to a lender. Lesson 6.2.1 grades every add-back A, B or C. This is RF-11.
Finding 5: Working-capital drain
What it looks like: reported profit that never turns into cash, because receivables and inventory keep growing faster than sales.
How to test it:
- Compare net income to the actual increase in cash over the same period, using the bank statements.
- Calculate days sales outstanding (receivables divided by revenue, times 365) for each year. Rising days means customers are paying slower, or the receivables are not real.
- Read the receivables aging. Balances past 90 days are often uncollectible.
What to do with it: if the business consumes cash to grow, you will fund that cash out of your own pocket after closing, on top of the price. Account for it in your model and negotiate a working capital target in the purchase agreement. This is RF-05.
Finding 6: Related-party deals
What it looks like: below-market rent on a building the owner owns, a vendor the owner's family controls, relatives on payroll at wages that do not match the work.
How to test it:
- Ask the seller in writing to list every transaction with a person or company related to the owner.
- Compare the rent to market rent for similar space. Compare related-party vendor pricing to a third-party quote.
- Match every name on payroll to a real role.
What to do with it: those terms end the day you take over. Replace them with market costs in your earnings number. If the owner's building is below market today, assume the new lease will not be. This is RF-10.
When to stop
If you find two or more of the six, the seller's number is not the number. Rebuild your own earnings figure before you discuss price. If you find a finding the seller cannot or will not explain, that is not a negotiating point. Under the Walk-Away Doctrine it is a reason to stop.
Deliverable
A one-page DIY QoE worksheet for the deal, with:
- The three-year revenue and margin table, with growth rates.
- A row for each of the six findings: found / not found, the evidence, and the dollar adjustment.
- The seller's adjusted EBITDA, your adjustments line by line, and your own recurring earnings number.
- A list of open questions for the seller, sent in writing.
Bring that worksheet to the quality of earnings provider when you engage one. It tells them where to look first and makes their report faster and cheaper. Lesson 6.3.2 covers when to engage one and what it should cost: Yale's 2022 primer on diligence in search fund acquisitions gives an illustrative budget of $30,000 to $40,000 for a QoE on a traditional search fund deal (M19), and the right scope for a smaller self-funded deal is part of that conversation.
This lesson is education, not accounting, tax or legal advice. A licensed CPA should review the financials of any business you intend to buy.