Sooner or later someone will send you a teaser for a business with a line like "we are the exclusive representative of the seller" and an NDA to sign before you see anything else. Sometimes that is true. Sometimes the person has an informal understanding with the owner, or has a relationship with someone who has one, or is shopping a business that has not hired anyone at all. And sometimes you will learn about a company late, after other buyers have offers on the table and a deadline is already set. This lesson covers the three skills these situations need: verifying that an intermediary actually holds the mandate they claim, reading the non-circumvention clause in their NDA and negotiating the carve-outs that protect relationships you already had, and entering a competitive process late without panicking or paying more than your own model says the business is worth.
Principle
Only the seller can confirm a mandate. A mandate is the written agreement in which the owner hires an intermediary to sell the company. An intermediary's own statement that they are exclusive is a claim, like the seller's earnings number. You test it before you rely on it, and the only person who can confirm it is the owner, in writing.
Know the three common forms, because "exclusive" means different things in each:
- Exclusive right to sell. One intermediary is hired, and is paid if the company sells during the term, whoever finds the buyer.
- Exclusive agency. One intermediary is hired, but the owner can usually sell to a buyer he finds himself without owing the full fee. Exact terms vary by agreement.
- Open or non-exclusive. The owner has authorised more than one intermediary, or none exclusively. Whoever brings the buyer may be paid.
Agreements often list excluded buyers, set a term, and include a tail: a period after the agreement ends during which the intermediary is still paid if the owner sells to a buyer they introduced. The fee terms are between the owner and his intermediary. Your interest is narrower: that the person you are dealing with is authorised, that the NDA you sign does not trap you, and that you are not later accused of going around someone you never agreed to work through.
Non-circumvention protects the intermediary's introduction, not their claim to the whole market. A reasonable clause says you will not use their introduction to cut them out. An overreaching one says you may never deal with this company, its owner, or sometimes anyone in its industry, except through them. Carve-outs exist to keep the clause inside its fair purpose.
A competing offer changes the timeline, not the value of the business. Other buyers' letters of intent (LOIs, the non-binding offers that usually come with an exclusivity period) tell you about the process. They tell you nothing about what this business earns. Your walk-away price comes from your own model, set before you hear what anyone else offered.
Case
Two cases. The first is from Coastal Comfort HVAC, the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. The second is a hypothetical, built for teaching, with no connection to any real deal.
Coastal Comfort: the buyer who was there first. The buyer first emailed the owner, Ray Delgado, on day 0, weeks before any intermediary was involved (lesson 4.4.1). On day 18 Ray wrote that he had signed with a business broker and named her. The buyer's reply congratulated Ray and said he would call the broker that day. That is the right move, and it carries two disciplines.
First, the buyer went through the broker from that moment on. Ray had hired her. Going around her would have damaged the relationship with both of them, and the broker channel does not forget (lesson 4.5.1).
Second, the broker's NDA arrived with a standard non-circumvention clause. This is where the curriculum's practice comes in: before signing, the buyer asks for one change, a schedule listing his earlier contact with Ray (the day 0 and day 4 emails and Ray's replies, with dates) as a prior relationship the clause does not reach. The point is not to avoid the broker's fee; that is between Ray and his broker. The point is to make sure that if this process died and Ray called him a year later, nobody could claim the broker had introduced them. A reasonable broker agrees to that, because it costs her nothing on the deal in front of her.
Hypothetical: the late entry. A buyer gets a call on a Monday from an established broker about a commercial cleaning company inside her buy box. Two other buyers have submitted LOIs. "Best and final" offers are due Friday.
She does not panic, and she does not skip steps. Monday she signs the NDA (after reading it) and gets the CIM, the broker's marketing document for the business. Monday night she runs the screen from lesson 5.1.1. Tuesday she asks the broker four questions: how many offers, whether either buyer has been granted exclusivity, what the seller cares about besides price, and whether the deadline can move by a week for a financed buyer with a lender already engaged. Wednesday she builds a rough model and sets her walk-away. Thursday she submits an LOI at her number, with a short cover note on what she offers that a higher bid may not: a specific timeline, a lender who has seen her file, and a plan for the seller's two managers.
She does not win. The seller takes a higher offer. Her walk-away held, the broker remembers her as the buyer who did serious work in four days without complaining, and in this version of the story she is the first call when the winning buyer's financing falls through two months later. In a real process that second call may never come. Plan for it anyway.
Steps
1. Verify the mandate before you sign anything substantive
When an intermediary claims to represent a seller, ask for these in writing:
- Confirmation of the engagement. "Can you confirm you have a signed engagement with the owner, and whether it is exclusive?" You are not entitled to see the agreement itself, and many intermediaries will not share it. A clear written answer is the minimum.
- The company's legal name and the owner's name, so you can check them against the state business registry.
- The intermediary's own entity, which you check in the state registry too: is it real, active and in the business it claims?
- Who has authorised what. "Has the owner approved the release of this information?"
Then watch for warning signs: a teaser with no company name and no way to confirm one, financial figures with no source documents behind them, pressure to sign an NDA that names the intermediary but not the company, an intermediary who cannot say when the engagement started, or a request for any payment from you. If the claim cannot be confirmed, you are not in a process. You are being shopped.
If it matters (you are about to spend real money on diligence, or two intermediaries claim the same company), confirm with the owner directly, in writing, once you have a legitimate path to him. A short note works: "I've been introduced to your company by [name]. Before I go further, can you confirm they represent you?" Do not use that note to start negotiating around anyone.
2. Read the NDA for six things
An intermediary's NDA usually combines confidentiality with non-circumvention and non-solicitation. Read for:
- Who the parties are. The NDA should name the company being sold and identify the intermediary as acting for the seller.
- Scope. Limited to this company and this transaction, not "any business introduced to you" or a whole industry.
- Term. A fixed, reasonable period, not indefinite.
- Non-solicitation of employees, with an exception for general job advertising not aimed at the company's staff.
- Remedies. Watch for clauses that make you liable for the intermediary's full fee if you are found to have circumvented them. Have an attorney read any clause that puts a fee on you.
- Return or destruction of information when you walk away, which you should actually do.
3. Ask for the carve-outs that fit
Request in writing, before signing:
- Prior relationships. A schedule of anyone at the company you were already in contact with, with dates and evidence (your sent emails, letters, call notes). This is the Coastal Comfort carve-out.
- Information you already had or that is public.
- Ordinary-course contact. If you already buy from, sell to or know the company's suppliers or customers in the normal course of life, that contact is not circumvention.
- Your own advisors and lender, who need the information to do their jobs.
Keep your sourcing records dated and complete (lessons 4.3.2 and 4.4.2). They are your evidence if this is ever disputed.
4. Enter a late process in four moves
- Get the facts about the process. How many offers, whether anyone has been granted exclusivity, the real deadline, and what the seller wants besides price. If the seller has already signed an LOI with exclusivity, stop: you wait until it lapses. Do not encourage a seller to break an exclusivity commitment; it can expose you to legal claims and it marks you as the buyer who would do the same to him.
- Screen first, fast. The screen in lesson 5.1.1 takes an evening. If it fails, pass politely and quickly. A deadline is not a reason to skip the screen.
- Set your walk-away before you hear anyone's number. Use your own model (lessons 6.5.1 and 6.5.2), and the doctrine at /walk-away. Write it down.
- Compete on certainty, not just price. Lender engaged, proof of funds, a specific timeline, a clear transition plan. Ask once whether a short extension is possible for a financed buyer. Then submit at your number or not at all.
Never bid against a number you cannot see. You cannot verify a rival LOI, and you should not try. If the broker says the other offer is higher, the only useful questions are whether your structure solves something theirs does not, and whether your walk-away has room. If it does not, you have your answer.
5. Lose well
If you are not chosen, say thank you, say you remain interested at your number, and ask the broker to keep you informed. Processes fail after LOI for financing, diligence and second thoughts. The buyer who lost gracefully is the one who gets the next call. Lesson 7.1.2 covers how to stay alive in a competing process once you are inside it.
Deliverable
An intermediary verification and NDA kit, with:
- A verification log for every intermediary you deal with: the written confirmation of engagement, the registry checks on the company and the intermediary, any warning signs, and the date the owner confirmed (if he did).
- An NDA review checklist covering the six items in Step 2, and a standard carve-out request you can paste into a reply.
- A dated prior-contact schedule for every company you have reached off-market.
- A one-page late-entry decision sheet: process facts, screen result, walk-away price written before any rival number, and your certainty case.
This lesson is education, not legal advice. NDAs, non-circumvention clauses and intermediary agreements are contracts with real liability; have a deal attorney review any agreement before you sign it.