The seller's financial statements show what the business paid. They do not show what it owes and never paid, what it pledged to a lender, who has sued it, or which "contractors" are really employees. Those are sins of omission, and a quality of earnings report built from the seller's own records will rarely find them, because they never entered those records.
They do leave a trail in public filings. This lesson is the set of searches that finds that trail, and the rule for deciding what each finding does to your deal.
Principle
What the seller did not tell you is in a government record somewhere. A lender who takes collateral files a financing statement. A taxing authority that is owed money files a lien. A plaintiff who sues files a complaint. None of them asks the seller's permission, and all of it is searchable. Your job is to search before you are committed, not after.
Search the exact legal name, in every place it could be filed. In Buyer Beware, Eric bought a swim school and later found that the seller who kept the books had a long court record, judgments and forged checks among it, filed under the formal version of his name, the one he never used day to day. It had been public the whole time, one name away. The interview corpus of 60+ failed and struggling buyers turns this into a rule: pull legal names early and run them in every county the sellers lived or operated.
Structure decides how much of what you find becomes yours. In a stock purchase you buy the company itself, with its whole history: every unpaid tax, every claim, every misclassified worker. In an asset purchase your new company buys selected assets and leaves most liabilities with the seller's entity, but not all of them:
- Liens follow the asset. A lender's security interest or a tax lien attached to equipment does not disappear because the equipment changed hands. It has to be paid off and released at closing.
- Some taxes follow by statute. Many states make the buyer of a business's assets liable for the seller's unpaid sales or withholding taxes unless the buyer gets a clearance from the state tax agency or holds back enough of the price.
- Courts can impose successor liability. When a buyer continues the same business with the same assets, courts in some situations hold it responsible for the seller's obligations. Unpaid wages and overtime are one of those situations: federal courts have applied a broader successor test to federal wage claims and have held an asset buyer that carried on the business, with notice of the claim, responsible for the seller's unpaid overtime. Your own diligence can supply that notice. Another example: after courts adopted a "product line" exception holding acquirers accountable for the acquired business's product liabilities, acquisitions of manufacturing establishments fell and closures rose relative to other businesses (A17, 2024). Buyers price that exposure, and sometimes they stop buying.
Lesson 7.4.2 covers the structure decision itself. This lesson tells you what you are deciding about.
The SBA rules make some findings the seller's problem by force. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, 7(a) loan proceeds may not be used to pay past-due payroll taxes, sales taxes or similar taxes collected and held in trust for a government (13 CFR 120.130(e)) (Y25; Y31). The lender's credit memo must also discuss any liens, judgments, bankruptcy filings and pending litigation. So a trust-fund tax delinquency has to be cured from the seller's money, before or at closing, and your lender will see whatever your searches see. Better that you see it first.
Case
Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Its seller is Coastal Comfort HVAC, LLC, owned by Ray Delgado; his spouse Marta is the part-time bookkeeper. You are buying substantially all of the assets, and your letter of intent excludes the seller's debt. Here are the four searches, run on this deal.
Lien filings. The balance sheet shows vehicle and equipment loans, part current and part long term. You should expect to find financing statements from those lenders against equipment, and liens noted on vehicle titles. Expected filings are not the finding. The finding is any secured party that is not on the balance sheet, or any filing that claims "all assets," which would mean a lender holds a claim on everything you are buying. Either way, every lien gets a payoff letter and a release at closing.
Tax liens and compliance. No lien search can show a tax that has not been assessed yet. So beyond the lien search, you ask for two years of quarterly payroll tax returns with proof of deposits, the annual unemployment tax returns, the W-2 and 1099 forms, and every sales and use tax return, and your CPA reconciles them to the payroll and revenue on the books.
Judgments and dockets. The fiscal 2025 P&L carries a $33,000 legal expense, explained as a lease dispute. The docket search is how you test that story. If a case was filed, you read how it ended. If none was, you ask for the settlement letter. In this case it was a dispute over common-area charges, and it was resolved. You also search Ray and Marta by full legal name, because a judgment against an owner can reach what the owner controls, and because you are about to trust the bookkeeper's numbers.
Misclassification. Coastal Comfort has 24 field technicians and installers. Count the W-2s and the 1099s. Here is a labelled hypothetical to show the arithmetic: suppose three installers are paid on 1099s, work only for Coastal Comfort, drive its trucks and follow its dispatch schedule, at $55,000 each. Converting them to employees adds at least the employer's 7.65 percent share of Social Security and Medicare taxes, about $12,600 a year, before unemployment insurance, workers' compensation and benefits. At the multiple in your letter of intent, about 3.74 times recurring earnings, that is roughly $47,000 of price for a cost the seller never paid. In a stock purchase, the back taxes and penalties for prior years come with the company. An asset purchase leaves most of that history with the seller's company, but not reliably all of it: successor liability can reach an asset buyer in some circumstances, wage claims among them, so have a deal attorney confirm what could follow you in your state and how the purchase agreement should cover it.
Steps
1. Collect the exact names first
Before you search anything, get in writing:
- The entity's exact legal name as registered with its state, every prior name, and every assumed name ("doing business as").
- The state where it is organized and every state where it operates.
- The full legal name of every owner, and of anyone who controls money (bookkeeper, controller, office manager), with the counties where each has lived or done business.
Ask the seller to sign a consent for background and record searches. A seller who refuses is giving you a finding.
2. Run the lien search
Financing statements under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code are generally filed with the secretary of state where the debtor entity is organized. Search there, under the exact legal name, and in any other state where the business holds significant assets. Also check:
- County records for fixture filings and real property liens.
- Vehicle titles for lienholders, since vehicle liens usually sit on the title, not in the lien index.
For every filing, read who the secured party is and what collateral it claims. A blanket claim on "all assets," a filing by a merchant cash advance company (a lender that buys a share of future receipts), or a lender the seller never mentioned is a finding. Ask the seller to explain each one in writing.
3. Run the tax searches, then test compliance
Search for federal tax lien notices, state tax liens or warrants, and local property tax liens, in the state and county offices where they are filed for that kind of debtor. Then test the filings that come before a lien:
- Payroll: the quarterly federal payroll tax returns (Form 941) and proof of each deposit, the annual federal unemployment return (Form 940), and the state withholding and unemployment filings.
- Sales and use tax: every return for the period you are reviewing, reconciled to revenue.
- IRS records: ask the seller to sign IRS Form 8821, which authorizes the IRS to release the business's tax information to a person the seller names, usually your CPA. Your lender will also verify the seller's financials against IRS tax transcripts, as SOP 50 10 8.1 requires.
- Clearance: ask your attorney whether the states involved issue tax clearance certificates for a business sale, and make obtaining them a closing condition.
Unpaid withheld payroll tax is the one to fear most. It is money taken from employees' paychecks and not handed over, and owners who do it are usually short of cash. It is also a liability the IRS can pursue against the people responsible for paying it.
4. Run the judgment and docket searches
Search the entity, every prior name and every owner, in:
- State and county court records in each county where they lived or operated.
- PACER, the federal courts' public records system, for federal civil cases and bankruptcy filings.
- Judgment lien indexes, wherever the state records them.
- Agency records that are public: workplace safety inspections, wage and hour enforcement, and complaints with the licensing board for the trade.
Read the dockets; do not just count them. A collection suit by a supplier, a wage claim by a former employee, or a pattern of customer suits tells you something different from a single dispute that settled. Anything active or recurring goes to RF-02 (active litigation) or RF-03 (regulatory and environmental exposure).
5. Test worker classification
Whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor turns on the facts, not on the form the seller files. The IRS looks at behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties; some states apply a stricter test that presumes a worker is an employee. Overtime is a second version of the same problem: a salaried technician treated as exempt from overtime may not qualify.
- Get every Form W-2 and Form 1099-NEC for the last two years. List each 1099 recipient with what they do.
- Flag anyone who works only or mostly for this company, on its schedule, with its tools, vehicles or uniform, doing the core work of the business.
- List salaried employees treated as exempt from overtime and what they actually do.
- Have your CPA, and if needed an employment attorney, estimate the cost to fix it going forward and the exposure for prior years.
The forward cost belongs in your earnings number as a negative adjustment, the same way lesson 6.3.1 treats an underpaid owner. The back exposure belongs in the structure.
6. Decide what each finding does
Every finding gets one of these outcomes, decided with your attorney:
- Cured before closing: liens paid off and released, delinquent taxes paid from the seller's money, workers reclassified.
- Priced: the forward cost comes out of earnings, and the price follows.
- Secured: a specific indemnity in the purchase agreement, backed by something you control, such as an escrow or holdback from the seller's proceeds, or a right to offset against the seller note (which your lender must approve). An indemnity backed only by the seller's promise is a lawsuit you would have to fund.
- Structured around: the finding moves you from a stock purchase to an asset purchase. That narrows what you inherit; it does not remove it, so pair it with an indemnity and security for the exposure your attorney says could still follow the assets.
- Fatal: a pattern of unpaid trust-fund taxes or a court record of financial dishonesty by someone who controls the books is a reason to walk under the Walk-Away Doctrine.
7. Search again before you wire
Filings keep arriving during exclusivity. Re-run the lien, tax lien and docket searches in the final days before closing, and make a clean bring-down a closing condition.
Deliverable
An undisclosed-liabilities log for the deal:
- The exact names searched, where, and on what date.
- Every filing found: lien, tax lien, judgment or case, with the claimant, amount, status and the seller's written explanation.
- The payroll and sales tax compliance check, with any gaps your CPA found.
- The classification review: workers flagged, forward cost, prior-year exposure.
- For each finding: cure, price, secure, restructure or walk, and who owns it (you, your attorney, your CPA, the seller).
Hand the log to your attorney before the purchase agreement is drafted. It becomes the list of representations, indemnities and closing conditions you need.
This lesson is education, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Search requirements and successor liability rules vary by state; a deal attorney should direct the searches and the response, and a CPA should review tax compliance and worker classification.