Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part VII: The Deal/Structure After the Rewrite

Lesson 7.4.2

Asset or Stock: The First Structural Decision

Asset purchase versus stock purchase, forming the new entity, successor liability, purchase price allocation and why the seller fights you on it, sales tax on asset transfers, and what each choice does to the diligence burden.

Lesson 9 of 20 in this part · 10 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

Should I buy a small business as an asset purchase or a stock purchase?

For a first-time self-funded buyer the asset purchase is the default. A new company you form buys the assets and takes on only the liabilities it agrees in writing to assume. Buy stock only for a named reason: a key contract that cannot be assigned, a license that would take months to reissue, or a C corporation seller facing double tax on an asset sale.

Before you can write a price into a letter of intent, you have to decide what the price buys: the company itself, or the things the company owns. That is the choice between a stock purchase and an asset purchase, and it is the most consequential structural decision most first-time buyers never see coming. It decides which liabilities become yours, which contracts and licenses survive, how much tax you and the seller each pay, and how much diligence you have to do.

This lesson explains the two structures, forming the new company that does the buying, what follows the assets even when you think you left it behind, and the purchase price allocation fight that comes with every asset deal.

Principle

Decide what you are buying before you decide what to pay for it. The two structures, in plain terms:

  • Asset purchase. A new company you form (usually called NewCo) buys the business's assets from the seller's company: equipment, vehicles, inventory, customer lists, the trade name, the phone number, the goodwill. NewCo takes on only the liabilities it agrees in writing to assume. The seller's old company keeps everything else, pays its own debts from the proceeds, and is wound down.
  • Stock purchase. You, or your company, buy the seller's shares (or, for an LLC, membership interests). The company does not change. Its contracts, licenses, tax history and every liability, known or not, stay inside it, and it now belongs to you.
Asset purchase Stock purchase
Liabilities Only those you assume, plus what follows the assets anyway (below) All of them, including the unknown
Contracts Each one must be assigned; anti-assignment clauses need consent Stay with the company, but change-of-control clauses can still be triggered
Licenses and permits Often reissued to NewCo Often stay, unless tied to a person or triggered by the change
Your tax basis Stepped up to what you paid, so you can depreciate and amortize the price Carries over from the seller, usually lower
Seller's tax Depends on how each dollar is allocated; double tax for a C corporation Usually capital gain on the shares
Diligence burden Lien, tax and successor-liability focus, plus assignment consents Everything in lesson 7.3.3, for every year the company existed

For a first-time self-funded buyer, the asset purchase is the default, and a stock purchase needs a reason. Good reasons exist: a key contract or government approval that cannot be assigned, a license that would take months to reissue, or a seller whose company is taxed as a C corporation (a corporation that pays its own income tax). An asset sale taxes a C corporation's gain once inside the company and again when the money goes out to the owner, so C corporation sellers often insist on a stock sale or demand a higher price for an asset sale. When you buy stock, you replace the protection of the structure with the protection of diligence, representations, indemnities and escrow, and you pay for all of it.

An asset purchase does not leave everything behind. Some obligations follow the business no matter how the deal is papered:

  • Liens on the assets. A lender's security interest or a tax lien attached to equipment stays with the equipment until it is paid and released.
  • State taxes. Many states make the buyer of a business's assets liable for the seller's unpaid sales or withholding taxes unless the buyer obtains a tax clearance or holds back enough of the price.
  • Successor liability. Courts can hold an asset buyer responsible for the seller's obligations when the buyer expressly or implicitly assumed them, when the deal is really a merger in disguise, when the buyer is a mere continuation of the seller, or when the sale was meant to escape creditors. Some courts go further. After courts adopted a "product line" exception holding acquirers accountable for the acquired business's product liabilities, acquisitions of manufacturing establishments fell and closures rose relative to other businesses (A17, 2024).
  • Obligations you choose to keep. Prepaid customer contracts, warranties on past work, gift cards and deposits are obligations to people who will call you, not the seller's old company.
  • Reputation. Same name, same trucks, same phone number. The customer does not know or care that the legal entity changed.

The allocation is a negotiation, and the seller is on the other side of it. In an asset purchase, buyer and seller each file IRS Form 8594, the Asset Acquisition Statement under Section 1060 of the Internal Revenue Code, with their tax returns for the year of the sale (Y35). The form allocates the price across seven asset classes, from cash (Class I) through receivables (Class III), inventory (Class IV), equipment and other tangible assets (Class V), identifiable intangibles such as customer lists and the seller's agreement not to compete (Class VI), to goodwill and going concern value (Class VII), which takes whatever is left. If buyer and seller agree to the allocation in writing, that agreement generally binds both of them.

The fight is about the character of the seller's income and the speed of your deductions:

  • Equipment and vehicles: you want more here, because you can depreciate it faster than goodwill. For the seller, gain above the equipment's tax basis, up to the depreciation already taken, is generally taxed as ordinary income (depreciation recapture), not capital gain.
  • Goodwill: the seller wants more here, because for an individual owner of a pass-through company it is generally capital gain. You amortize it over 15 years under Section 197.
  • The non-compete: you amortize it over 15 years, the same as goodwill, so the tax difference to you is small. To the seller it is ordinary income, so he wants it small. You may want a real number on it anyway, because a non-compete with a visible price is easier to defend (lesson 7.4.3).
  • Consulting payments are not purchase price. They are deductible to the business as paid and ordinary income to the seller, with payroll or self-employment tax.

Sales tax can ride on the allocation too. In many states, transferring tangible business property such as equipment and furniture is subject to sales or use tax unless an occasional-sale exemption applies. Vehicles are usually taxed or charged a fee when they are retitled. Inventory bought for resale is often exempt with a resale certificate. Goodwill and other intangibles generally are not taxed. So moving value into equipment can lower your income tax and raise your sales tax. Your CPA runs both before you agree a number.

The SBA lender works with either structure, with different paperwork. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, a 7(a) loan may fund a stock purchase or an asset purchase, and buying all or substantially all of a business's assets while continuing its operations is a change of ownership (Y25). A 7(a) loan cannot be made solely to an individual. In an asset purchase by your company, NewCo is the borrower. When a person buys 100 percent of the ownership interest, the person and the business are co-borrowers and both sign the note. The lender's independent valuation must state whether the deal is an asset or stock purchase and what debt, if any, is being assumed. Intangibles, including agreements not to compete, can be financed if the valuation and other diligence requirements are met.

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. The seller is Coastal Comfort HVAC, LLC, owned entirely by Ray Delgado and taxed as an S corporation. Your letter of intent offered $3,800,000 for substantially all of its assets, with your NewCo LLC as the buyer; after the quality of earnings report, the price was re-traded to $3,500,000 (lesson 7.3.1). Ray's cash and his personal pickup are excluded, and the company's vehicle and equipment loans stay with the seller, to be paid off at closing.

Why an asset purchase here? The financials carry a fiscal 2025 legal expense, the worker classification history is unverified, and the seller's books are internally prepared and unaudited. An asset purchase leaves the history with Ray's company. Because Ray's company is an S corporation, the gain is taxed once either way, so the seller has no double-tax reason to resist.

What follows the assets anyway, and what you did about it:

  • The roughly 810 prepaid maintenance plans. You are taking on the obligation to perform work Ray was already paid for. That is why the working capital formula in the letter of intent subtracts deferred revenue.
  • The equipment liens. Payoff letters and releases at closing, then a fresh lien search.
  • The license and the lease. The license does not transfer. NewCo contracts through a permanent, paid qualifying agent, the licensed senior install lead, approved by the state board to take effect at closing (lesson 7.3.2); the lease is assigned to NewCo with a renewal.
  • Past installs. Customers whose systems Ray installed will call you about them. Decide your policy on callbacks before day one and price it.

Then the allocation. The table below is a simplified illustration, not part of the spine case's figures and not a complete Form 8594. It spreads the $3,500,000 price across three lines only, and it assumes, for the arithmetic, that the seller's books carry the vehicles, tools and equipment at $520,000. It leaves out the receivables and inventory delivered through the working capital peg and the liabilities NewCo assumes, such as the prepaid maintenance plans. A real allocation has to place all of those, so its goodwill figure will differ from the one shown. Your CPA builds the full schedule.

Seller's proposal Your proposal
Vehicles, tools and equipment (Class V) $520,000 $680,000
Non-compete (Class VI) $15,000 $75,000
Goodwill and other intangibles (Classes VI and VII) $2,965,000 $2,745,000
Total $3,500,000 $3,500,000

Your proposal gives you faster deductions on $160,000 of value and a non-compete with a real price. It gives Ray more ordinary income and, depending on the state, may add sales tax on the equipment. An independent equipment appraisal ends most of this argument, because both of you have to defend the numbers to the IRS. Agree the method in the letter of intent and the final schedule before closing, so it cannot become a last-week hostage.

Steps

1. Choose the structure before the LOI

Start from the asset purchase. Switch to stock only for a named reason (an unassignable contract, a license that cannot be reissued in time, a C corporation seller), and write that reason down. If you buy stock, budget for the full liability diligence in lesson 7.3.3 and for stronger protection in the purchase agreement.

2. Confirm how the seller's company is taxed

Ask for the seller's entity type and tax election, and check the tax return. An LLC can be taxed as a sole proprietorship, a partnership, an S corporation or a C corporation, and buying its membership interests can be treated as a stock purchase or an asset purchase for tax, depending on which. Your CPA confirms what you are actually buying.

3. Form NewCo early

With your attorney and CPA:

  1. Form the entity (usually an LLC) in the right state and choose its tax classification.
  2. Get its federal employer identification number, write its operating agreement, and open its bank account.
  3. Register it to do business in every state where the business operates.
  4. Line up its licenses, permits, payroll tax accounts (federal, state withholding and unemployment) and insurance, so they are live at closing. Some states carry the seller's unemployment tax rate over to a successor; ask.
  5. Buy the trade name as an asset, and require the seller's company to change its name after closing.

Your lender will want NewCo's documents during underwriting, so do not leave this for the last month.

4. List the liabilities you will assume, and only those

Your purchase agreement should name each assumed liability (for example, the obligation to perform prepaid service plans) and state that all others stay with the seller. Pair that with the tax clearances, lien releases and escrow or holdback from lesson 7.3.3 for what follows the assets anyway.

5. Negotiate the allocation on purpose

Get an equipment appraisal. Ask your CPA for the tax and sales tax effect of the seller's allocation and yours. Put the allocation method in the letter of intent and the final schedule in the purchase agreement, and make sure both sides' Form 8594 will match it.

6. Tell the lender what you are buying

Give your lender the structure, the borrower entity and any assumed debt before it orders the valuation, because the valuation's scope must say whether this is an asset or stock purchase.

Deliverable

A one-page structure memo for the deal:

  • Asset or stock, and the reason in one sentence.
  • The seller's entity type and tax election, and what that means for your tax treatment.
  • NewCo: entity, state, tax classification, and its licensing, payroll and banking checklist.
  • Assumed liabilities, listed; everything else excluded.
  • What follows the assets anyway, and the protection for each (release, clearance, escrow, holdback).
  • The proposed Form 8594 allocation, the appraisal behind it, and the sales tax effect.
  • Who owns each decision: your attorney (structure, assumed liabilities, NewCo), your CPA (tax classification, allocation, sales tax), your lender (borrower structure, valuation scope).

This lesson is education, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Successor liability and sales tax rules vary by state; a deal attorney and a CPA should decide the structure, the allocation and the entity before you sign a letter of intent.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What liabilities follow the buyer in an asset purchase?

Liens stay with the equipment until they are paid and released. Many states make the buyer liable for the seller's unpaid sales or withholding taxes without a tax clearance or holdback. Courts can impose successor liability. And prepaid customer contracts, warranties on past work, gift cards and deposits are obligations to people who will call you.

What is IRS Form 8594?

Form 8594 is the Asset Acquisition Statement under Section 1060 of the Internal Revenue Code. In an asset purchase, buyer and seller each file it with their tax returns for the year of the sale. It allocates the price across seven asset classes, from cash through equipment and identifiable intangibles to goodwill, which takes whatever is left.

How should the purchase price be allocated in an asset sale?

It is a negotiation. The buyer wants more in equipment, which depreciates faster than goodwill. The seller wants more in goodwill, which is generally capital gain for an individual owner of a pass-through company, while equipment gain up to depreciation taken is generally ordinary income. An independent equipment appraisal ends most of the argument. Your CPA should also run the sales tax effect.

Can an SBA 7(a) loan finance a stock purchase?

Yes. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, a 7(a) loan may fund a stock purchase or an asset purchase. The loan cannot be made solely to an individual. In an asset purchase the new company is the borrower. When a person buys 100 percent of the ownership interest, the person and the business are co-borrowers.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. A17

    Balasubramanian, N., Sivadasan, J., & Xu, W. (2024). Caveat emptor as an obstacle to business transfers: Effect of product line liability exceptions on acquisitions, entry, and exit. Strategic Management Journal, 45(7), 1300-1325.

  2. Y35

    Internal Revenue Service (). About Form 8594, Asset Acquisition Statement Under Section 1060.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.