Every seller has a number. Almost no seller has only a number. Behind the asking price sits a person who built something, often over decades, and who is about to hand it to a stranger. What that person wants besides money decides more deals than buyers expect, and reading it correctly is a skill you can learn.
This lesson covers what sellers want besides cash, why their psychology favors structure over the headline price more often than buyers believe, and the two failure reads that cost buyers the most: a seller anchored to a number no arithmetic supports, and a seller who uses your offer to go shopping for a better one.
Principle
The seller's price has an emotional component, and it can run in either direction. Research on owner psychology is consistent on this point. A study of 1,354 Swiss small-business owners, checked against 455 actual ownership transfers, found that owners' willingness to sell at a discount was driven by reluctance to lose access to information about the firm and influence over it, and by aversion to putting the firm's future at risk; a long tenure, a familiar relationship with the successor and weak recent performance all increased that willingness (C4, 2016). The same emotions can push the other way. A study across two countries found that owners who had intended to pass the firm to the next generation set a higher acceptable selling price for outside buyers (B26, 2012). And a 2024 study of how owners set their first asking price found that it is often driven by personal experience and emotion rather than earnings, and that when the first price departs from the firm's earnings value, transactions are likely to fail (C15, 2024).
Put those together and you get the working rule: find out what the seller is protecting, and you will know which way his emotions push his price.
What sellers want besides money
Listen for these. Most sellers want two or three of them, and few will list them unprompted.
- Succession. Someone who will keep the doors open. The owner with no successor and no number two is often the most motivated seller you will meet, and the most anxious.
- Legacy. The name on the trucks, the reputation in town, the customers he has served for twenty years.
- The people. Long-serving employees, often including family. On episode 2 of the Still Searching podcast, Drew Williams described the seller's family members who expected to keep working, and keep a paycheck, under the new owner.
- A role for the next generation. A son or daughter who works in the business and expected to own part of it one day.
- His own transition. How long he stays, in what role, and whether he still has somewhere to go on Monday morning.
- Certainty and timing. A clean close, before a lease renewal, a health event, a retirement date or a slow season.
Some of these you can give at little cost. Some you cannot give at all inside an SBA deal. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, in an initial acquisition the seller may not remain an owner, officer, director or employee after closing; he may serve as a consultant for no more than 24 months in total (Y25). A seller who wants to keep a stake in the company is asking for something a 100 percent purchase cannot deliver. It is not impossible with SBA money. In a partial change of ownership the seller keeps part of the company and may stay as an owner and employee; under the Technical Policy Updates, when an outside buyer takes 50 percent or more, the deal is processed under the Initial Acquisition credit standards, and "sellers retain their ability to remain as an owner and employee of the business as allowed under an Owner Buyout." The conditions are heavy: every new owner is a co-borrower, the seller who stays must guarantee the loan, and a structure that puts buyer and seller into a new holding company is not eligible. Lesson 7.4.1 covers the rule; ask your lender before you raise it with a seller. Any ownership or employment for a seller's family member raises eligibility and guarantee questions; your lender and attorney must answer them before the idea appears in a letter.
"I don't need the cash"
When a seller says this, take it seriously, and test it. It can mean he is comfortable with a seller note, a longer transition, and a structure that pays him over time. That is good news: seller paper is one of the strongest tools a self-funded buyer has, and a 2020 study of private acquisitions found that seller-financed deals close faster and at higher prices (C24, 2020). It can also mean he is not really selling, and will hold out for a number nobody will pay. The test is simple: propose a structure with meaningful deferred payment and see whether he engages with the terms or only with the headline.
Seller psychology favors structure over the headline more often than buyers believe. Buyers assume every seller wants the most cash at closing. Many care at least as much about who you are, what happens to their people, and whether the price they tell their friends sounds right. Structure lets you give a seller a number he can be proud of while you pay part of it later, out of what the business earns, in paper that waits behind your lender.
The two failure reads
The irrational anchor. The seller's number is several times anything his earnings support, and he built it to look reasonable. You do not argue with it. You convert it into arithmetic and let the arithmetic do the negotiating.
The seller who shops your number. You send a careful offer, and the seller (or his broker) uses it to solicit a higher bid from someone else. Signs: the broker asks you to "firm up" your number before granting exclusivity; signing drags with no new information; the seller wants your detailed analysis before he commits to anything. Your defenses are structural: no detailed model before exclusivity is signed (a one-page earnings bridge attached to the letter of intent itself is the exception, lesson 7.1.1), an expiry date on your offer, and confidentiality covering the terms of your letter.
Case
Project Ridgeline is an anonymized case from this school's files, with deliberately rounded figures. It is much larger than a typical self-funded deal and was never a candidate for SBA financing, but its seller behavior is the clearest example of an irrational anchor on record, and the method transfers to any size.
Ridgeline was a niche defense-software company whose real asset was a federal cryptographic validation competitors did not have. Revenue ran roughly $12 to $15 million, with about $3.5 million of trailing EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) on paper. Only about $2 million of revenue was genuinely recurring annual license fees. The rest arrived in lumps whenever a customer refreshed hardware.
The founder ran his own process, unrepresented, after a bank passed on the mandate. His anchor was several times any defensible value, and he built it carefully:
- He anchored on a multiple of revenue, not earnings. Revenue multiples run higher and hide a lumpy cost structure. He never volunteered an earnings figure at all.
- He narrowed his revenue projection to make the anchor look conservative. "I'm only assuming modest growth" is a framing move, not a concession, when the multiple applied to that revenue is doing all the work.
- He wanted growth-investor pricing with a buyout's liquidity. Full cash at closing, at a price that assumed the growth a buyer's capital and effort would create. He was asking to be paid for a future he was not staying to build.
The buyers did not call the number crazy. They converted it into implied multiples of trailing EBITDA, of recurring revenue and of total revenue, and asked which of those numbers a lender or investor would underwrite. The arithmetic embarrassed the ask on its own.
Two more moves from Ridgeline transfer directly to self-funded deals.
Find the clock, and ask whom it pressures. The company's core validation was scheduled to lapse on a hard federal date with no successor in the queue, and a competitor was reportedly in the market. For the seller, certainty and speed were worth more than the last turn of multiple. The general rule: look for the date-certain external event in every deal (a lease expiry, a contract recompete, a license renewal, a retirement) and work out which side it squeezes.
Let structure do the diagnosing. The buyers' honest structure capped value at what recurring revenue alone supported and tied the rest to the recertification and the pipeline, with the founder keeping a large equity stake so the growth story kept its author. That rollover structure belonged to a growth purchase with no SBA loan. Inside a 7(a) deal, earnouts are prohibited and seller rollover is unavailable in a 100 percent purchase; the one contingent tool the SOP names is a buyer rebate, and the tool you will use most is deferred seller paper. The diagnostic still works: a seller who refuses to wait for any part of his price is telling you what he believes about the business's future.
No letter of intent was signed. The buyers stayed close, held their price discipline and let the clock argue for them.
Steps
1. Ask before you offer
In the first two conversations, ask open questions and listen more than you talk: Why now? What happens to you after the sale? Who here matters most to you? What would make this a good outcome for your family? Record the answers word for word the same day.
2. Map his wants against what you can give
Make three columns: wants you can give at little cost (keeping the name, offering employment to named staff, a consulting transition), wants you can give at a price (a longer transition, a higher headline with more of it deferred into seller notes), and wants you cannot give in a 100 percent purchase with an SBA loan (an ownership stake, a seller job) or in any SBA deal (an earnout). Be honest with the seller early about the third column, and if he will not sell without a stake, ask your lender whether a partial change of ownership fits before you say no.
3. Test "I don't need the cash"
Float a structure with a meaningful seller note in conversation before the letter of intent. Watch whether he negotiates the terms or only the headline.
4. If the anchor is irrational, translate it
Convert his number into multiples of trailing earnings, of recurring revenue and of total revenue. Put them in a short table. Ask him to help you understand which one a lender would accept. Then wait.
5. Find the clock
List every date-certain event in the deal: lease, licenses, major contracts, the seller's own plans. Note whom each one pressures. Never reveal your own.
6. Guard against shopping
Do not send your model or a detailed offer until exclusivity is in sight. The one-page earnings bridge goes out with the letter of intent itself (lesson 7.1.1), not before it. Put an expiry date on every offer. If the broker asks you to raise your number before exclusivity with no new facts, decline.
Deliverable
A one-page seller read for your top deal:
- The seller's stated reasons for selling, in his words, with dates.
- His wants besides money, sorted into the three columns from Step 2.
- His anchor, translated into implied multiples.
- Every date-certain event and whom it pressures.
- Your read: structure-friendly, anchored, or shopping, with the evidence for each.
Reread it before every negotiation call. The seller will tell you what he wants. Most buyers are too busy talking to hear it.
This lesson is education, not legal, lending or investment advice. Your SBA lender and deal attorney must confirm any role, ownership or contingent payment for a seller or a seller's family before you propose it.