Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part II: Failure Literacy: The Case Record/The Patterns and the First Checklist

Lesson 2.5.2

The Liar Across the Table

Base-rating seller misrepresentation so that the default posture is proof, not trust and not fear. What to verify as a matter of routine, and how to ask for it without poisoning the relationship.

Lesson 13 of 14 in this part · 7 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How do I verify what a seller tells me when buying a business?

Treat every number as testimony and ask the seller to turn it into evidence. Tie tax returns to bank deposits, trace one sale from the call to the deposit, count physical assets, call every material vendor, search court and lien records under the seller's full legal name, re-cost open jobs, and get read-only access to operating accounts before closing. An honest seller can do all of it.

Most of the buyers in Part II were not beaten by markets. They were beaten by a person across the table who sold them a story. This lesson does two things with that fact. It sets a base rate, so you walk into every deal with the right default posture. Then it turns that posture into routine: what to verify on every deal, and how to ask for it so that an honest seller is not insulted and a dishonest one has nowhere to hide.

Principle

The default posture is proof. Not trust, and not fear. Treat every number a seller gives you as testimony, and ask them to turn it into evidence. An honest seller can. That is the whole test, and it never insults the honest ones.

Start with the base rate. Of the failures in the founder's interview corpus of 60+ failed and struggling buyers, about 65 percent involved material seller fraud or misrepresentation, by his own tally. That is not an industry statistic; nobody keeps one. It is enough to set your default. If roughly two of every three failures in a practitioner's own notebooks involved a seller misrepresenting the business, then checking is not paranoia. It is arithmetic.

The research supports the posture, if not the number. Graebner's 2009 study of acquisitions of entrepreneurial firms found that buyers and sellers hold asymmetric views of each other's trustworthiness, that those beliefs are often wrong, and that the asymmetries shape both deceptive behavior and efforts to guard against it (C6). A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer to someone outside the family managed reported earnings more than owners planning a family succession (C55). You are the outsider.

Two more rules follow.

A lie is a verdict, not a coupon. When diligence catches a seller misrepresenting the business, you have learned something about the person, and the person comes with the deal through the transition, the seller note and any dispute. Re-price a fixable problem. Walk away from a dishonest counterparty.

Verification is the price of your signature, not an accusation. You are about to sign a personal guarantee. Asking for proof is what that signature costs.

Case

The published record shows the forms misrepresentation takes. None of these buyers was careless.

  • Tom Brennan's target billed a large customer around $600 for tires that cost about $230. The margin was the fraud. When a diligence study cut the seller's earnings nearly in half, Tom cut the price from $2.25 million to $951,000 and kept the seller as a partner. The discount changed what he paid. It did not change who he was in business with.
  • Paul Kessler spent twenty-five years in his industry. His seller wrote fiction into the inventory line for years, in a factory too large to count casually. Paul had a full quality of earnings review, and the seller produced every document instantly. The manipulation sat in work-in-process inventory the review never physically tested. Books that arrive too fast and too clean are not a gift.
  • Victor Lang toured the factory and helped build machines with his own hands, but never visited the sites, checked title, or audited the operator's own financials, where the scheme lived. The checks arrived on time, because in that fraud the on-time check was the product.
  • Eric Sandoval read industry numbers for a living and rebuilt the books from bank statements. Every number was true. What was missing was the lie: a seller quietly paying part of the expenses from an account Eric never saw, an owner who drew no wage, advertising shut off before the sale. A later court search under the seller's full legal name, rather than the name he used day to day, turned up records a first search had missed.
  • Dan Cole's seller loaded and repainted the job backlog before the sale, in a contractor whose real financial statement is the work-in-progress schedule.

Notice what the honest-seller cases look like. Alan Brewer's sellers and Devin Price's sellers produced true numbers, and verification confirmed them. Proof cost those sellers nothing. It is the dishonest seller who finds verification expensive.

Steps

Step 1: Announce the policy before you need it

On the first serious call, before any document request, tell the seller how you work: "I verify everything on every deal. It's not about you; my lender and my family require it, because I'm personally guaranteeing the loan. Anything you tell me I'll ask to see in a document, and I'll do the same with every number I give you." A policy stated at the start is a process. A request that arrives after a doubt is an accusation.

Step 2: Verify these on every deal, as routine

Claim The evidence Who it caught in the record
Revenue and profit Business tax returns, tied to bank deposits. These are the seller's returns, so the seller signs the IRS authorization (Form 4506-C or Form 8821) and your lender obtains the transcripts and verifies the seller's figures against them. Make that signature a condition of your LOI. Eric
How money arrives Trace one sale from the call to the bank deposit, in documents Tom
Physical assets and inventory Count them yourself, or pay for a physical observation Paul, Victor
Costs Call every material vendor, confirm the price, and ask which account pays them Eric
The seller's history Court and lien records under the full legal name, in every county they have lived or operated Eric
Backlog or work in progress Re-cost open jobs with independent eyes Dan
Cash control Read-only access to every operating account before closing, and sole control after Victor, Dan
Why it is for sale Ask why every earlier buyer walked away Dan

Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026 (Y25), a quality of earnings report with a cash proof (an independent rebuild of cash receipts and disbursements, reconciling bank statements to the income statement and tax return) is required for an initial acquisition with a purchase price of $3 million or more, and the lender must use its findings in the coverage calculation. Below that threshold, buy one anyway. Yale's 2022 primer on diligence in search fund acquisitions budgets for a quality of earnings review as a normal part of confirmatory diligence (M19); that is traditional-search guidance, and the logic applies to you with more force, because your house is behind the loan.

Step 3: Ask your QoE provider what it will not test

Before you sign the engagement letter, ask in writing for the list of things the review will not physically observe or re-perform. Inventory counts, work in progress, and related-party payments are common gaps. That list is where you do your own work.

Step 4: Read the speed and the friction

Two signals deserve a note in your file:

  • Resistance to routine requests. A seller who fights a bank statement request for weeks is giving you information. Do not reclassify it as a personality.
  • Unusual frictionlessness. A data room that is perfect on day one, in a business whose books are usually messy, is a reason to sample harder, not relax.

Step 5: Let structure share the risk you cannot remove

Research on private acquisitions found that seller financing and earnouts become more common as the information gap between buyer and target grows, and that audited financials reduce that effect (C24, 2020). Use the tools available inside an SBA deal: a seller note with a right of offset if representations prove false (attorney-drafted and lender-approved), and a buyer rebate from the seller based on business performance, which under SOP 50 10 8.1 must be applied to pay down the principal of the 7(a) loan. Seller earnouts are prohibited in 7(a) acquisitions under the same SOP. Structure is a backstop for honest uncertainty. It is not a substitute for verification, and it does not fix a liar.

Step 6: When you catch a misrepresentation, decide what kind it is

What you found What it usually means The response
An error the seller corrects when shown Messy books Re-price, keep verifying
An aggressive add-back the seller defends Negotiation Reject the add-back, re-price
A number the seller cannot or will not document Unknown Treat it as false until proven
A deliberate concealment or fabrication Dishonesty Walk. No discount fixes the counterparty

Deliverable

A Proof Log for each deal: every material seller claim in one column, the independent document that verifies it in the next, the date verified, and a status of verified, unverified or contradicted. Add the QoE provider's written list of what it will not test, and your own work on each item. Any claim still unverified the week before closing is a reason to delay or walk, and any contradicted claim goes through the table in Step 6 before you sign anything.

This lesson is education, not legal, accounting or investment advice. Have a licensed CPA and a deal attorney review any acquisition before you sign.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

How do I ask a seller for proof without insulting them?

Announce the policy on the first serious call, before any document request: you verify everything on every deal because you are personally guaranteeing the loan, and you will do the same with every number you give. A policy stated at the start is a process. A request that arrives after a doubt is an accusation.

What does a quality of earnings report not cover?

It depends on the engagement, so ask in writing, before you sign the engagement letter, for the list of things the review will not physically observe or re-perform. Inventory counts, work in progress and related-party payments are common gaps. That list is where you do your own work.

What should I do if I catch a seller in a misrepresentation?

Decide what kind it is. An error the seller corrects when shown means messy books: re-price and keep verifying. An aggressive add-back is negotiation: reject it and re-price. A number the seller cannot document is false until proven. A deliberate concealment or fabrication is dishonesty: walk, because no discount fixes the counterparty.

Are earnouts allowed in an SBA 7(a) acquisition?

No. Seller earnouts are prohibited in 7(a) acquisitions under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026. Inside an SBA deal, the tools are a seller note with a right of offset if representations prove false, and a buyer rebate based on business performance, which must be applied to pay down the 7(a) loan. Structure is a backstop, not a substitute for verification.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C6

    Graebner, M. E. (2009). Caveat venditor: Trust asymmetries in acquisitions of entrepreneurial firms. Academy of Management Journal, 52(3), 435-472.

  2. C55

    Umans, I., & Corten, M (2023). Ownership succession intentions affecting earnings management in private family firms. Small Business Economics, 61(2), 827-842.

  3. C24

    Jansen, M (2020). Resolving information asymmetry through contractual risk sharing: The case of private firm acquisitions. Journal of Accounting Research, 58(5), 1203-1248.

  4. M19

    Andrew Seth Jacobs, A. J. Wasserstein. (2022). On the Nature of Due Diligence in a Search Fund Acquisition. Yale Case, no number printed, May 6, 2022.

  5. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.