Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part II: Failure Literacy: The Case Record/Bought a Lie

Lesson 2.2.2

The Warehouse That Lied

A manufacturer's profitability is faked through inventory manipulation, and the lender refuses the rescue when it surfaces. How inventory games work, where they show in the statements, and why the bank will not be your backstop.

Lesson 5 of 14 in this part · 7 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How do I verify inventory when buying a manufacturing business?

Count it, or watch it counted, before you close. Compare three years of inventory, days inventory, gross margin and net income against cash from operations. Roll inventory forward each year and question any unexplained adjustment. Then attend a physical count or have your quality of earnings provider test-count a sample in both directions, and test the ten largest work-in-progress jobs.

Inventory is where a manufacturer's profit is easiest to invent and hardest to see. A number written next to a pile of half-finished goods moves straight into earnings, and no cash ever has to change hands. This lesson follows an industry veteran who bought a furniture manufacturer, found after closing that most of its reported profit had lived in an inventory figure nobody had counted, and then learned that his lender would not be the backstop he assumed.

Principle

If the profit lives in the inventory line, the inventory has to be counted, by you or someone you hired, before you close. Expertise in the industry does not replace a count. Familiarity is not verification.

Here is the mechanism in plain words. A manufacturer spends money on materials and labor. That spending only becomes cost of goods sold (the expense on the P&L) when finished product ships. Everything still on the floor sits on the balance sheet as inventory, an asset. Work in progress (WIP) is the part of inventory that is partly built.

So the ending inventory number does double duty: the higher it is, the lower cost of goods sold is, and the higher profit is. Write a bigger number next to the same pile and profit rises on paper while cash stays exactly where it was.

Illustrative arithmetic: a shop starts the year with $2,000,000 of inventory, spends $5,000,000 on materials and labor, and reports $2,500,000 of ending inventory. Cost of goods sold is $2,000,000 + $5,000,000 − $2,500,000 = $4,500,000. If the true ending inventory is $1,500,000, cost of goods sold is really $5,500,000. That $1,000,000 overstatement is $1,000,000 of profit that never existed, and at four times earnings it is $4,000,000 of purchase price.

Sellers have a reason to shape earnings before a sale to an outsider. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer ownership outside the family managed earnings more than those planning a family succession (C55). The pattern has bitten searchers before: a Stanford case describes a search fund that acquired a home health supply company whose sales growth, inventories and receivables had been grossly overstated, discovered only after closing (K29, 2003). And professional valuers of private firms have been found to rely heavily on reported earnings despite the possibility of manipulation (C23, 2010).

The second rule of this case is about money, not accounting: your lender is not your rescue plan. A bank's first duty is to its loan. On an SBA loan, it is also protecting the government guarantee it holds. Plan your survival so it does not depend on the bank's willingness to exercise judgment on your worst day.

Case

The case comes from Buyer Beware, chapter 6, "The Warehouse That Lied." Names are the book's pseudonyms.

Paul Kessler had spent twenty-five years in commercial furniture. When his employer wound down its hospitality business, he ran a self-funded search with a list of five companies he knew. At the top was Lakeland Manufacturing, a sixty-year-old family furniture and millwork maker outside Chicago whose owner had twice tried to hire him. Two earlier sales of the company had fallen apart.

The price was $6 million: a $4.6 million government-backed loan from a high-volume lender, a $300,000 credit line, a $1 million seller note, and equity from ten investors plus Paul. He bought a full quality of earnings study and hired strong lawyers. The study firm remarked that it was rare to get this much financial data this fast. The seller refused any access to employees. Paul skipped customer calls because he already knew the customers. In the book's words, familiarity was doing the job that verification was supposed to do.

The cracks came quickly. The purchase list showed 145 employees; the insurance census showed 125, after quiet cuts sixty days before closing. Every order shipped six to eight weeks late. Paul rehired to about 160, raised output per worker 37 percent, and set two production records, yet cash stayed thin. Then the controller mentioned that the old owner used to adjust the inventory numbers to make the company look profitable.

Paul counted the floor by hand over a weekend. Millions of dollars of value on the inventory report were not there. About $3 million of half-built custom work had been valued by the seller, year after year, at numbers that were fiction. The last truly profitable year was 2019; the company had been losing millions since, and stale labor rates in the costing system meant new jobs were priced to lose about five cents on the dollar. A turnaround needed about $2.5 million.

Paul went to his lender before missing a single payment and brought five rescue paths. He learned the bank could not consider a discounted sale unless the loan was in default, so he asked to be declared in default. A buyer signed a letter of intent offering $600,000 for the assets, about $3 million of new money, rebuilding to about 180 jobs, and taking over the fraud claim. The bank replied through lawyers, weekly, with "not commercially reasonable" and no counteroffer. After a required public layoff notice reached the local paper, the bank agreed, but by then deposits and orders had stopped and the buyer walked. About 140 people lost their jobs.

Equipment appraised at $1.1 million at purchase was expected to bring $200,000 to $300,000 at auction. About $4.5 million remained owed to the bank, about $3.5 million in client deposits, and about $800,000 to vendors. Paul's personal guarantee still hangs over his family.

Steps

These are the checks that would have caught it.

1. Find out where the profit lives

Put three years of balance sheets beside three years of P&Ls and compute, for each year:

  1. Inventory and WIP as a percentage of revenue.
  2. Days inventory: inventory divided by cost of goods sold, times 365.
  3. Gross margin.
  4. Net income versus cash from operations (from the bank statements, not the seller's cash flow statement).

The warning pattern is inventory and margin rising together while cash does not. If net income keeps beating the cash the business actually produced, the gap is sitting in a balance sheet line, and most often it is inventory or receivables (RF-05).

2. Roll the inventory forward

For each year, rebuild: beginning inventory, plus purchases, plus labor and overhead absorbed, minus cost of goods sold, equals ending inventory. Tie purchases to supplier invoices and payroll to payroll records. If the roll-forward only balances with an unexplained "adjustment," ask who made it and why. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1 (Y25), a required QoE must include a cash proof reconciling bank statements to the income statement and tax return. In a manufacturer, one of the biggest reconciling items between cash spent and costs recorded is the inventory change. Make sure your provider tests it rather than accepting it.

3. Count it, or watch it counted

  1. Before closing, attend a physical count, or have your QoE provider observe one and test-count a sample against the inventory report, in both directions: from the report to the floor, and from the floor to the report.
  2. For WIP, pick the ten largest jobs. For each, get the contract price, cost to date, estimated cost to complete and amount billed. Ask how the percentage complete is set, and by whom.
  3. Check the costing system's labor and overhead rates against current payroll. Stale rates hide jobs that lose money.

4. Make employee access a condition

Zero access to employees is not a condition of the deal. It is a price you pay in missing information. At minimum, before closing, speak with the controller, the production manager and someone who runs the shipping schedule. Ask about on-time delivery, how inventory is counted, and what changed in the last six months. Request the payroll register at signing and again at closing, and compare headcount. Every fact that sank Paul was known on the shop floor.

5. Read the polish as a signal

Books that arrive complete, clean and fast are not evidence of honesty. Neither is a long industry relationship. Ask why each earlier sale failed, and try to speak with those buyers. A company that has been inspected and rejected twice has been telling people something.

6. Protect yourself in the purchase agreement

Ask your attorney for specific representations on inventory valuation and WIP methodology, an indemnity for breach, and a right to offset proven claims against the seller note. None of these replaces a count, but they give you a remedy that is not a two-year lawsuit.

7. Diligence the lender as a partner

Before you sign loan documents, ask the prospective lender:

  1. Who handles a loan that gets into trouble, and how early will they engage?
  2. Have they ever approved a sale or restructuring of a troubled borrower rather than liquidating? What did it take?
  3. What would need to be true for them to consider a discounted payoff?

Then build a liquidity reserve and a plan that does not assume the answers will be kind. The lender's character shows only on your worst day.

Deliverable

An Inventory Test Workpaper with:

  • The three-year ratio table from step 1, with the net income versus operating cash gap highlighted.
  • The inventory roll-forward for each year, with every adjustment explained or flagged.
  • Physical count results: sample size, variances in both directions, and WIP job-level tests.
  • A list of employee conversations held, with dates and what you learned.
  • The lender's answers to the three questions in step 7.

If the count does not support the inventory number, rebuild earnings on the counted figure before you discuss price, or walk.

This lesson is education, not accounting, legal or lending advice. A licensed CPA should observe inventory and review the financials of any manufacturer you intend to buy.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

How does overstated inventory inflate profit?

Spending on materials and labor becomes cost of goods sold only when finished product ships. Everything still on the floor sits on the balance sheet as inventory. So the higher the ending inventory number, the lower cost of goods sold and the higher profit. A bigger number next to the same pile raises profit on paper while cash stays where it was.

What is work in progress (WIP) inventory and how do I test it?

Work in progress is the part of inventory that is partly built. Pick the ten largest jobs and, for each, get the contract price, cost to date, estimated cost to complete and amount billed. Ask how the percentage complete is set and by whom, and check the costing system's labor and overhead rates against current payroll.

What are the warning signs of inflated inventory in a business for sale?

The warning pattern is inventory and gross margin rising together while cash does not. If net income keeps beating the cash the business actually produced, the gap is sitting in a balance sheet line, most often inventory or receivables. Books that arrive complete, clean and fast are not evidence of honesty, and zero access to employees costs you information.

Will my SBA lender help if the business gets into trouble after closing?

Do not plan on it. A bank's first duty is to its loan, and on an SBA loan it is also protecting the government guarantee it holds. Before signing, ask who handles troubled loans, whether the lender has ever approved a sale or restructuring instead of liquidating, and what a discounted payoff would take. Then build a liquidity reserve.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C55

    Umans, I., & Corten, M (2023). Ownership succession intentions affecting earnings management in private family firms. Small Business Economics, 61(2), 827-842.

  2. K29

    James Lattin, Mark Leslie, Erin Yurday. (2003). Med-Mart, Transitioning The Business Model (A). Stanford GSB Case E163A.

  3. C23

    Elnathan, D., Gavious, I., & Hauser, S (2010). An analysis of private versus public firm valuations and the contribution of financial experts. International Journal of Accounting, 45(4), 387-412.

  4. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.