Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part VII: The Deal/The Paper That Can Kill You

Lesson 7.6.1

A Purchase Agreement Is Not Protection

A purchase agreement is a platform to sue, and suing is a second catastrophe. What representations and warranties actually get you, and why most failed acquisitions end in settlement rather than recovery.

Lesson 15 of 20 in this part · 10 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

Can I sue the seller if they lied about the business I bought?

A purchase agreement gives you the legal right to sue over a false representation, but not the means to collect. Collecting depends on the seller still having money you can reach, your ability to fund the dispute, and your business staying alive long enough. Plan as if you will never collect through a lawsuit, and build protection into diligence, price and the seller note.

The purchase agreement is the contract that transfers the business to you. It runs to dozens of pages and carries the seller's representations and warranties, the indemnification terms, the covenants and the closing conditions. First-time buyers tend to treat it as a shield: if the seller lied, the contract will make it right.

It will not. A purchase agreement gives you the legal right to sue. Whether you can afford to sue, whether you will win, whether you can collect, and whether your business survives long enough to find out are separate questions, and the contract answers none of them. This lesson covers what the agreement actually does for you, why litigation after a failed acquisition is a second catastrophe rather than a rescue, and where your real protection has to come from.

Principle

A purchase agreement is necessary, but it is not sufficient. You cannot close without one, and a careless one can hurt you badly. But the protection it offers is a claim, and a claim is only worth what you can afford to pursue and actually collect.

What the key terms are

A 2019 Stanford white paper on acquisition documents, written for search fund buyers, lists the documents in a typical deal and what each should cover, with guidance on which parts deserve the closest attention and how to keep legal fees from escalating (K22, 2019). The terms you need to understand, in plain words (your attorney drafts and negotiates them):

  • Representations and warranties (reps): statements of fact by the seller about the business as of signing and closing: the financial statements are accurate, there is no undisclosed litigation, the company has its licenses, taxes have been paid.
  • Disclosure schedules: the seller's written list of exceptions to the reps. "There is no litigation, except as listed on Schedule 3.12."
  • Indemnification: the seller's promise to reimburse you for losses caused by a breach of the reps or by certain listed liabilities.
  • Survival period: how long after closing you have to bring a claim for a breach.
  • Basket and cap: the minimum amount of losses before you can claim anything, and the maximum the seller can owe. Certain core reps, and fraud, are often treated differently. That is negotiated.
  • Covenants: promises about conduct, such as a non-compete or a non-solicitation agreement.

What reps and warranties actually get you

They do three things well, and one thing poorly.

They force disclosure before you close. The most valuable moment for a rep is before signing. A seller asked to state in writing that there is no litigation, no lost customer and no tax problem must either say so or list the exception on a schedule. That is diligence, and it costs you nothing to ask. Read the schedules as closely as any financial statement.

They allocate risk on paper. They decide, in advance, who bears which kind of loss.

They give you standing to sue. If a rep was false, you have a contractual claim.

They do not get you paid. Collecting depends on the seller still having money you can reach, on your ability to fund the dispute, and on your business staying alive for as long as it takes. The contract controls none of those things.

Why suing is a second catastrophe

When an acquisition fails because the seller misrepresented the business, the buyer usually finds out after closing, when cash is shortest and the personal guarantee is fully in force. That is the worst possible moment to begin a lawsuit. Buyer Beware shows what it looks like:

  • The cost arrives up front. In "The $600 Tire," the buyer, Tom, spent about $50,000 just to get his complaint written. The seller, who still owned 20 percent of the company, answered by suing him personally, and he had to hire a second set of lawyers to defend himself. The lawsuit was still running when the book was written.
  • The timeline outruns the business. In "The Numbers Guy," when the buyer, Eric, discovered the earnings had been overstated, the broker described his choices: do nothing, try to unwind the sale (which almost never works), or sue, which would take two years or more and a $30,000 retainer to start, while the business kept losing money every month. Eric spent the money trying to save the business instead.
  • Bankruptcy can take your claims away. In "The Kill Switch," after the company failed, the buyer's fraud and interference claims against the sellers became property of the bankruptcy estate. The trustee and the bank could pursue them. They chose not to, even when the buyer offered to pay the legal fees himself. He had spent more than $200,000 on legal fees by then. The estate is the pool of the failed company's property that a court-appointed trustee controls; lesson 8.4.3 covers Chapter 7 and the trustee's role.

The Still Searching newsletter told a version of the same story about a buyer called Jim. Weeks after closing on a trucking business, he learned the sellers had set up a near-identical company across town and were taking his largest customers and soliciting his staff, in breach of their non-compete. His attorneys sent letters and filed suit for breach of contract within days. The business lost about 40 percent of its revenue in five weeks and was insolvent by the end of its second month. The sellers used the proceeds of the sale to fund their defense. Jim dropped the lawsuit three months in. A strong contract claim does not stop a business from bleeding while it waits for a court.

Anecdotally, from the interview corpus of 60+ failed and struggling buyers, roughly 8 out of 10 post-close failures ended in some mix of litigation, bankruptcy and a settlement carrying confidentiality or non-disparagement terms. That is Jed's own estimate from those conversations, not a measured rate. What it describes is a pattern of settlement, not recovery. Plan as if you will never collect a dollar through a lawsuit.

Where your protection actually comes from

If the lawsuit is the last resort, your protection has to come before closing and from structures that work without a court:

  1. Diligence that does not depend on the seller's word (Part VI and lesson 7.3.1). The reps are a backstop to diligence, never a substitute.
  2. Money you control. A 2020 study of private acquisitions found that seller financing and earnouts become more common as the information gap between buyer and seller grows, and that audited financial statements reduce that effect (C24, 2020). Contingent payment is how buyers share risk with sellers they cannot fully verify. In a 7(a) deal, under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, seller earnouts are prohibited (Y25). The one contingent tool the SOP names is a buyer rebate based on business performance, and any rebate the buyer receives must be applied to pay down the principal of the 7(a) loan (lesson 7.4.1). What is left is deferral: price that stays in a seller note, junior to the SBA loan, is money the seller has not received yet.
  3. A set-off right (also called a right of offset). A right, drafted into the purchase agreement and the seller notes, to deduct indemnification claims from what you still owe the seller. When the remedy is "we pay you less," you do not need to win a judgment and then collect it. Know what it does on each kind of note. Against a paying note, it lowers the payments. A note on full standby has no payments to lower for the life of the SBA loan, so a set-off lowers the balance that comes due afterward. How a claim is established before it can be set off, and what happens to a disputed amount, is your attorney's drafting. The right needs your SBA lender's approval and has to fit the standby agreement, under which a standby creditor takes no action against you or the collateral without the lender's consent (lesson 7.5.2).
  4. Escrow or holdback, where some of the price is held back and released later, if your attorney and lender can structure one that fits your financing.
  5. Paper that does not arm the seller. The clauses that let a seller act against you without a court, such as a confession of judgment, belong in lesson 7.6.2. Removing them is protection too.
  6. The walk. A seller who will not stand behind a rep, or will not accept the structures above, is telling you what their rep is worth. That is an exit under the Walk-Away Doctrine (/walk-away).

Case

Coastal Comfort HVAC is the fictional company that runs through this curriculum. Beyond the earnings, diligence turned up three findings: the largest commercial relationship, with a local homebuilder, rested on one estimator's friendship and job-by-job purchase orders with no master agreement; the lease expired in 14 months with no renewal option; and 8 of 24 field technicians were one extended family, including the senior commercial lead.

A buyer relying on the contract would have asked for a rep that the commercial relationship was stable and stopped there. If the builder walked after closing, that buyer's remedy would be a claim that the seller misrepresented the relationship, filed while revenue fell and the SBA payments continued.

The buyer here put each finding into structure instead:

Finding Contract-only response What the buyer did
Builder relationship with no master agreement A rep that the relationship is stable A price built on recurring earnings that leave out the builder's one-time project; $50,000 moved from cash at closing into Seller Note A, which is on full standby (after the later re-trade, cash at closing was $2,750,000 and Note A $500,000, with this $50,000 inside it); introductions to the builder's construction manager before closing; a right to set off indemnity claims against both seller notes
A recurring margin the seller's documents could not explain A rep that the financial statements are accurate A quality of earnings condition in the letter of intent; when the report set recurring earnings at about $920,000, a re-trade to $3,500,000 by amendment, before the financing commitment (lesson 7.3.1)
Lease ending in 14 months A rep that the lease is valid A five-year renewal, signed by the landlord as part of the assignment, as a condition of closing
Family cluster of technicians A rep that there are no known departures A $60,000 seller-funded retention escrow for two named leads, paid at 6 and 12 months

There is no contingent price in this deal: no earnout, which the SOP prohibits, and no rebate. The reps were still in the agreement, and the buyer's attorney still negotiated them. But every finding was priced or fixed before the money moved. If the builder goes quiet, the buyer has already paid for a business valued without that project, $750,000 of the price is still unpaid in two notes that sit behind the SBA loan, and an indemnity claim can be set off against what the seller is owed. A lawsuit remains possible, and is no longer the plan.

Steps

1. Hire your own deal attorney early

Engage an attorney who represents only you and who regularly handles small business acquisitions financed with SBA loans. Bring them in before the letter of intent is final (lesson 7.1.1), because the protections that matter are agreed in principle there.

2. Map every diligence finding to a structure

List each material finding. Next to it, write the structural response: price, deferral into a seller note, set-off, escrow, closing condition, or walk. A finding whose only response is "the seller reps it" is unresolved.

3. Read the disclosure schedules as diligence

Ask for the schedules early. Compare every exception against what you learned in diligence. Anything new on a schedule late in the process is a finding, not a formality.

4. Ask your attorney the collection questions

For each rep that matters to you, ask in writing: how long does it survive, what are the basket and cap, how is fraud treated, and how would we actually collect if it is breached? If the honest answer is "sue a seller who has spent the money," move that risk into the note or the price.

5. Confirm the offset and the SBA fit

Have your attorney confirm that the set-off right and any escrow are consistent with the lender's standby agreement (SBA Form 155 or the lender's equivalent), any subordination agreement, and SOP 50 10 8.1. Get the lender's sign-off in writing.

6. Write down your litigation threshold

Before closing, write down the situation in which you would actually sue: the size of the loss, the cash you could commit without endangering payroll or your household, and the person who would make the call with you. Deciding that on a calm day protects you from deciding it in a panic.

Deliverable

A Protection Map for your deal: each material diligence finding, the rep that covers it, the structural protection that backs it up (price, deferral, set-off, escrow, closing condition), the attorney's answer on how it would be collected, and your written litigation threshold. Review it with your attorney before you sign the purchase agreement.

This lesson is education, not legal advice. Purchase agreement terms vary by deal and by state; a licensed attorney who represents you should draft, negotiate and review every document before you sign.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What are representations and warranties in a purchase agreement?

They are the seller's statements of fact about the business as of signing and closing: the financial statements are accurate, there is no undisclosed litigation, the company has its licenses, taxes have been paid. Exceptions go on disclosure schedules. Their most valuable moment is before signing, because they force the seller to disclose in writing.

What is a right of offset in a seller note?

A right, also called set-off, drafted into the purchase agreement and the seller notes, to deduct indemnification claims from what you still owe the seller. Against a paying note it lowers the payments; against a note on full standby it lowers the balance due later. The remedy is paying the seller less, so you do not need to win a judgment and then collect it. Your attorney drafts it and your SBA lender must approve it.

What do basket and cap mean in indemnification?

The basket is the minimum amount of losses before you can claim anything from the seller. The cap is the maximum the seller can owe. Certain core representations, and fraud, are often treated differently, and all of it is negotiated. The survival period sets how long after closing you have to bring a claim.

How much does it cost to sue a business seller?

The lesson gives no market range, only cases from the book Buyer Beware. One buyer spent about $50,000 just to get his complaint written. Another was told a suit would take two years or more and a $30,000 retainer to start. A third had spent more than $200,000 on legal fees.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. K22

    David Dodson. (2019). Acquisition Documents and Strategies. Stanford GSB Case E677, 12 pp.

  2. C24

    Jansen, M (2020). Resolving information asymmetry through contractual risk sharing: The case of private firm acquisitions. Journal of Accounting Research, 58(5), 1203-1248.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.