Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part II: Failure Literacy: The Case Record/The Paper Trap

Lesson 2.1.2

The Controlling Interest

Control-holding preferred stock plus a solo personal guarantee on the credit line. Ownership percentage is not control. Map every power the other side's paper holds before you count on your majority.

Lesson 2 of 14 in this part · 8 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

Can I own the largest share of a company and still not control it?

Yes. Control is written in share classes, voting and board rules, loan covenants and guarantees, not in your percentage. Preferred stock can carry vetoes, a liquidation preference and a drag-along. In the lesson's case, a buyer who started as the largest owner ended with 28 percent of the equity and 100 percent of the personal guarantee. Never guarantee a company you do not control.

Your ownership percentage is a number on a cap table. Control is something else: it is written into share classes, voting rules, board rights and loan documents, and it can sit with people who own far less of the company than you do. This lesson follows a buyer who was the largest owner of his company at closing, ended with 28 percent of the equity and 100 percent of the personal guarantee, and watched every decision that mattered get made by someone else.

Principle

Ownership is a number. Control is written in the documents. Before you count on your majority, or your plurality, map every power the other side's paper holds.

Four kinds of paper decide who controls a small company:

  • Share classes. Preferred stock is equity that gets paid before common stock and usually carries special rights. Those rights can include a liquidation preference (the preferred holder gets its money back first in any sale), protective provisions (a veto over things like new debt, a sale, a budget or hiring the CEO), redemption rights (the right to demand its money back on a date), and a drag-along (the right to force every other owner to join a sale it approves).
  • Voting and board rules. Whether votes are counted per share or per person, who appoints board seats, and which decisions need a supermajority.
  • Loan documents. Covenants are the financial tests in a loan agreement (minimum cash flow coverage, maximum leverage). Break one and you are in default even if you never missed a payment, and the lender gains the right to act.
  • Personal guarantees. A personal guarantee (PG) is your promise that if the company cannot repay a loan, you will, from your savings, your house and your family's future.

In a self-funded SBA deal, the guarantee follows ownership by rule. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026 (Y25), any individual who owns 20 percent or more of the borrower, directly or indirectly, must give an unlimited full guarantee (13 CFR 120.160(a), Y31), and the lender may require others when credit calls for it. Read that from the buyer's chair: investors who hold under 20 percent are not required to sign (spouses are counted together, and each spouse signs when the couple holds 20 percent or more), so the searcher is very often the only guarantor in the room. If you are carrying all of the downside, the documents have to give you the control that matches it. And once the SBA loan is refinanced, even that ownership-based rule is gone. A conventional lender asks for whichever name it likes.

The rule this case was built to carry: never sign a personal guarantee for a company you do not control.

Case

The case comes from Buyer Beware, chapter 3, "The Controlling Interest." Names are the book's pseudonyms.

Greg Fowler, a former strategy consultant and banker with an MBA, ran a self-funded search in northern Michigan and found North Channel Boats, a 52-year-old maker of aluminum fishing boats. He closed in 2017 at four times earnings, financed with 75 percent from a government-backed bank loan, 10 percent in a seller note and 15 percent in equity from a small investor group, with Greg writing the largest check. He earned another 30 percent as promoted equity for finding and running the deal. On day one he held 42 percent: the largest owner, not the majority.

Two early choices set the pattern. He gave his management team equity and set voting at one vote per person, not per share. And the bank loan required a personal guarantee. One person signed it: Greg.

The business boomed through 2020 and 2021. In 2021 the company opened a second plant in Mexico, where most of its raw material came from. In January 2022 a family office, Rockhill Capital, bought 20 percent in preferred stock with, in Greg's words, every bell and whistle a preferred structure can carry. Its money paid off the government loan and the seller note. The company owed nothing except a line of credit.

Then orders fell. Two plants carried two sets of fixed costs. Closing the Michigan plant needed a bigger line of credit. A follow-on round left Greg at 28 percent. The first lender wanted Rockhill's guarantee; Rockhill refused and steered Greg to Granite Peak Bank, owned by the same family. The bank waived the family's guarantee and required Greg's. Rockhill promised a recapitalization (new money to retire the old debt) that would release his guarantee. "It's never going to be an issue," they said. None of it was in writing. Greg later called his yes "a move made out of desperation."

Then, one November, a tariff announcement threatened a 25 percent tax on goods made in Mexico. The next morning the investor asked how profitable the company would be. "We're not. At all," Greg answered. "We want you to sell the company," came the reply. The recap died on that call. Within weeks the company broke its loan covenants and fell into default, held by the bank owned by the family that had just ordered the sale. A buyer offered, in effect, to assume the debts. At the last minute the bank struck a clause that would have released individual guarantors.

The bank was owed $1.9 million on the line and recovered $1.3 million. The roughly $600,000 gap sits on Greg's guarantee. His 28 percent went to zero. No one in the family ever signed a guarantee for anything.

As the book notes, his investor never lied. Every term that ruined him was written down, with his signature under it.

Steps

These are the checks that would have caught it. Run them at the LOI (letter of intent, the offer that starts exclusive negotiation), at every new equity round, and at every new loan.

1. Build a control map, not a cap table

For each class of equity, write down:

  1. Its ownership percentage.
  2. Its votes, and whether votes are per share or per person.
  3. Its board seats.
  4. Every protective provision: each decision it can veto or must approve.
  5. Its liquidation preference, redemption rights, drag-along and any forced-sale trigger.

Then list the ten decisions that matter most in a bad year: take new debt, sell the company, close a plant, fire the CEO, approve a budget, raise money, change the guarantee. Next to each, write who can make it, who can block it, and who can force it. If your name is not in the "can make it" column for most of them, your percentage is decoration.

2. Keep a guarantee ledger

  1. List every guarantee on every loan: who signed, who did not, the amount, and what it reaches (house, retirement accounts, a spouse).

  2. For every loan, ask: who else could guarantee this, and why are they not?

  3. If you are the only guarantor while others hold control rights, negotiate protection before you sign, and know who can give it:

    • Against an SBA lender, nothing. A 20 percent owner's guarantee on a 7(a) loan is unlimited and full. There is no cap and no release date to negotiate.
    • Among the owners: a contribution agreement (the other owners agree to share any guarantee loss in proportion to ownership), or a guarantee fee paid to you for carrying the risk. Have your attorney and lender confirm that any fee fits the loan's limits on payments to owners.
    • With a conventional lender, as in Greg's later line of credit: a cap on your exposure, or a written release date or release trigger.

    If none is available, the answer is no.

3. Map conflicts of interest across the table

  1. For each investor, list every other role it or its owners hold: lender, landlord, supplier, customer, board member elsewhere.
  2. When your investor and your lender answer to the same people, assume every conflict will resolve in their favor. Not because they are bad actors. Because the paper says so.
  3. Never accept a lender introduced by an investor who refused to guarantee the same loan without asking, in writing, why the lender waived that investor and required you.

4. Put every promise in writing or treat it as absent

"We will recap it." "It will never be an issue." "You will be released." If a promise matters enough to make you sign, it belongs in the documents with a date, an amount and a remedy if it is broken. A verbal promise from the party who holds the veto is worth exactly what the veto holder decides on your worst day.

5. Run the macro stress test against the covenants

Greg's company was run well twice and was undone by a pandemic boom it extrapolated and a tariff it could not control. For any business with cross-border cost, cyclical demand or seasonal swings:

  1. Model the covenants, not just the cash. At what drop in earnings does each covenant break?
  2. Ask who holds the right to act once it breaks, and what that party wants.
  3. Decide in advance what you will do at that point, and write it down while you are rested.

6. Fix the structure on day one

Greg's own grade on one vote per person: too democratic, too generous. Give management economic upside if you like, but keep voting control matched to who carries the risk. A hard decision dodged becomes a harder decision forced. He knew the guarantee was wrong the day he signed it; every quarter he waited for the promised recap shrank his options.

Deliverable

A one-page Control Map for your deal:

Decision Who can make it Who can block it Who can force it Document and clause

Below the table:

  • Guarantee ledger: every guarantee, every signer, every asset reached, and every party who was asked and declined.
  • Conflicts list: every relationship your investors and lenders have with each other.
  • Written promises: each one, with its date and remedy. Anything not on this list is not a promise.

If the map shows you carrying the guarantee without the control, do not sign until it changes.

This lesson is education, not legal or investment advice. Have a licensed attorney review every equity, governance and guarantee document before you sign.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What rights does preferred stock have over common stock?

Preferred stock gets paid before common stock and usually carries special rights. Those can include a liquidation preference, protective provisions that give a veto over new debt, a sale, a budget or hiring the CEO, redemption rights to demand its money back on a date, and a drag-along that forces other owners into a sale.

Do investors have to sign the SBA personal guarantee?

Only at 20 percent or more. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, any individual who owns 20 percent or more of the borrower must give an unlimited full guarantee, and the lender may require others when credit calls for it. Investors under 20 percent are not required to sign, unless a married couple together holds 20 percent or more, so the searcher is often the only guarantor.

What can I ask for if I am the only personal guarantor?

Against an SBA lender, nothing: a 20 percent owner's guarantee is unlimited, with no cap or release date to negotiate. Among the owners, ask for a contribution agreement that shares any guarantee loss in proportion to ownership, or a guarantee fee. With a later conventional lender, ask for a cap or a written release trigger. If none is available, the answer is no.

What happens if a company breaks a loan covenant?

It is in default even if it never missed a payment, and the lender gains the right to act. Covenants are the financial tests in a loan agreement, such as minimum cash flow coverage or maximum leverage. Model at what drop in earnings each covenant breaks, and who holds the right to act once it does.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.

  2. Y31

    Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (). 13 CFR Part 120, Business Loans.