Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part VIII: Own/When It Goes Wrong

Lesson 8.4.1

The Workout

Lender workouts, what a personal guarantee actually reaches, the difference between a business bankruptcy and an individual bankruptcy, the settlement, and how to wind a business down the right way.

Lesson 6 of 10 in this part · 13 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

What happens if I can't pay the SBA loan on a business I bought?

You enter a workout: a negotiation with the lender over a loan the business can no longer pay as written. It can end with the loan back on track, the business sold, or the business closed and liquidated. The lender can then pursue your personal guarantee for the deficiency. Call the lender early, with a 13-week cash forecast and specific requests.

Every lesson before this one is about not ending up here. This one is about what to do if you do. A workout is the negotiation between a struggling borrower and its lender over what happens to a loan that the business can no longer pay as written. It can end with the loan back on track, with the business sold, or with the business closed and the lender collecting what it can. Most buyers in trouble make the same two mistakes: they wait too long to tell the lender, and they learn the rules of the endgame only after the endgame has started. Learn them now, while it is still hypothetical.

Principle

Call the lender before the lender calls you. A borrower who arrives early, with real numbers and a plan, has options. A borrower who arrives ninety days late has a collections file.

Four facts shape everything that follows.

1. The personal guarantee is the design, not a formality

A personal guarantee (PG) is your promise to repay the company's loan from your own assets if the company cannot. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, every individual who owns 20 percent or more of the borrower, directly or indirectly, must provide an unlimited full guaranty (Y25; 13 CFR 120.160, Y31). That is the document the lender reads on your worst day.

The guarantee also reaches your house in a specific way. If the business assets do not cover the loan (a "collateral shortfall"), SOP 50 10 8.1 says the lender must take available equity in personal real estate that is solely owned by the 20 percent owners and by guarantors. The lender is not required to take a lien where the equity is less than 25 percent of the property's fair market value, and the lien may be limited to the amount of the shortfall. Property owned jointly with a spouse falls under a softer sentence: when an owner, alone or together with a spouse or minor children, holds 20 percent or more of the business, the lender must consider taking a lien on real estate that person owns individually or jointly with the spouse or minor children. Real estate transferred to a non-owning spouse or minor children within six months of the application is not exempt from consideration. So before you ever reach a workout, you should already know whether there is a lien on your home and for how much.

2. Your lender has its own incentives

An SBA 7(a) lender carries a government guaranty on most of the loan. To keep that guaranty, it has to service and liquidate the loan under SBA's servicing rules (SOP 50 57, which SOP 50 10 8.1 points every lender to once a loan is disbursed) (Y30). That makes the lender procedural, not creative. In the interview corpus of 60+ failed and struggling buyers, the common arc is a short payment deferral, maybe a second one, and then liquidation. Restructuring the buyer imagined was rarely on the menu. Underwrite your own downside as if the middle gear does not exist.

3. A business bankruptcy and an individual bankruptcy are different events

A business bankruptcy is the company's case. The company files, a court process takes over its assets and debts, and the company is liquidated or reorganized. It does not touch your personal guarantee. The guarantee is your contract, separate from the company's, and the lender can pursue you on it while the company's case runs.

An individual bankruptcy is your own case. A Chapter 7 filing liquidates your non-exempt assets and can discharge (legally erase) debts, including a personal guarantee (Y44). A Chapter 13 filing puts you on a court-supervised repayment plan for several years (Y46). A business can go through bankruptcy while its owner never files personally, and the reverse also happens.

Lesson 8.4.3 covers the chapters themselves: Chapter 7, Chapter 11 and Subchapter V, the streamlined Chapter 11 for small businesses. One number to know now: Subchapter V's debt limit is $7.5 million for cases filed on or after November 10, 2026 (Y41, 2026).

4. A federal loan has a federal tail

If the lender liquidates, collects what it can, and SBA honors its guaranty, any unpaid balance on your guarantee becomes a debt owed to the federal government. Federal debt collection law allows those debts to be referred to the Treasury and collected by offset against federal payments owed to you, including tax refunds (31 U.S.C. 3716 and 3720A).

There is a second tail. SOP 50 10 8.1 makes an applicant ineligible for a 7(a) or 504 loan if a business it owned or controlled caused a prior loss to the federal government, and it defines loss to include any amount compromised for less than the full balance or discharged in bankruptcy. Lenders must also tell every applicant that, after a default with a loss, the names of the business and its guarantors are referred for listing in CAIVRS, the federal database lenders check before approving a loan. A settlement can end the collection and still close the door to the next SBA loan.

Case

The published book Buyer Beware contains four different endings. Read them as four exits from the same burning building.

The workout that followed the procedure. Paul (chapter 6) told his lender about the fraud he had uncovered before he ever missed a payment. The bank paused payments for three months, then three more. He brought the workout team, the lender's unit for troubled loans, five rescue paths. Then he learned the bank would not consider a discounted sale of the company unless the loan was already in default. A signed buyer eventually offered the bank cash for the assets plus new money and kept roughly 150 jobs. The bank answered through lawyers, slowly, and the deal died. The company was liquidated, and his personal guarantee still hung over his family. The lesson he took: a lender shows you its character only on your worst day.

The sale that left a gap. Greg (chapter 3) sold his company for, in effect, the assumption of its debts. The bank was owed $1.9 million on the line of credit, the sale recovered $1.3 million, and the roughly $600,000 gap sat on his personal guarantee. He made the bank's workout officer an offer instead of filing.

The individual bankruptcy. Eric (chapter 12) and his wife had both signed every guarantee. He paid staff and vendors current to the last day, closed the school in an orderly way, and they filed Chapter 7 together. The discharge came in under ninety days and erased roughly half a million dollars of guaranteed debt. They kept their house and cars under the exemptions. In the book's words, bankruptcy is not death; it is a machine with rules.

The business bankruptcy and the settlement. This school's founder bought two landscaping companies in 2023. The combined business failed about eight months later, missed payroll, and closed on June 3, 2024. It went through a business bankruptcy, leaving $1M+ in personally guaranteed debt, and the settlement that followed cost the family their home. The family itself never filed for bankruptcy.

Four buyers, four routes, one common thread: the guarantee decided the ending, not the company.

Steps

Step 1: Know your cash weekly, not monthly

Build a 13-week cash flow forecast: a week-by-week spreadsheet of cash in, cash out, and the ending bank balance for the next quarter. Update it every Friday. It is the first thing a workout officer, a restructuring attorney or a turnaround adviser will ask for, and it is the only tool that shows a payroll shortfall six weeks before it happens instead of six hours. If the forecast shows you missing a debt payment or a payroll inside the quarter, you are in Step 2 now, not later.

Step 2: Read your own documents before anyone else does

Pull every signed document and build a one-page map:

  • The note and loan agreement: payment terms, financial covenants (ratios you promised to maintain), and what counts as a default.
  • Your guaranty: full or limited, who signed, and whether a spouse signed anything.
  • Security agreements and recorded liens: what business assets are pledged, and whether there is a lien on your home or other real estate.
  • The seller note and its subordination or standby agreement: whether you are allowed to pay the seller at all while the senior loan is stressed.
  • The lease, equipment leases, and any personal guarantees on them. Landlords and equipment lessors often hold guarantees too.

Step 3: Get your own counsel before you sign anything new

Your deal attorney may not be the right person. You want an attorney who does restructuring and bankruptcy work, and a CPA. Do this before you sign a forbearance agreement (a lender's written promise to hold off on enforcement for a period, in exchange for conditions). Forbearance agreements commonly ask you to acknowledge the debt, waive defenses, and release claims you may have against the lender. Paul's bank later asked him to sign away his claims against it. Never sign a release without advice.

Step 4: Go to the lender early, with a plan

Ask for the meeting yourself. Bring the 13-week forecast, the reason for the shortfall, what you have already cut, and two or three specific requests. The tools a lender may have include a short payment deferral, a temporary interest-only period, re-amortizing the balance, consent to sell the business or some assets, or an orderly liquidation. Ask directly what the lender can and cannot do under its own policies and SBA's servicing rules.

Talk to the seller too. If you carry a seller note, the seller is a creditor with a stake in the outcome, and a seller who agrees to defer or reduce payments buys you real room.

Step 5: Decide early: fix, sell or close

Distress does not have to end in court. A study of 6,118 distress-related exits of mature Belgian firms found 41 percent exited through a court procedure, mainly bankruptcy, 44 percent through voluntary liquidation, and 14 percent through an acquisition, merger or split (H16, 2012). A sale or an orderly wind-down is a real route, and it usually requires deciding while there is still something to sell.

The traditional search fund data points the same way. In one investor's portfolio of 67 search fund companies, Yale researchers looked at 23 early weak performers: the nine that exited early averaged a 19 percent simple IRR, while the 14 that held on averaged negative 9 percent, although seven of those 14 did turn the business around (M8, 2023). That is fund context, not self-funded, and it does not say holding never works. It says waiting is a decision with a price, so make it on purpose. Set your triggers in writing now: for example, two consecutive months below 1.0x debt service coverage, or a forecast that shows a missed payroll.

Step 6: If you close, close it the right way

The order of operations matters, and some of it is personal liability:

  1. Wages and the taxes withheld from them are one payment. A paycheck has two parts: the net pay the employee receives, and the income tax, Social Security and Medicare withheld from it. The withheld part is held in trust for the government. Never run a payroll you cannot fund in full, net pay and the tax deposit together. Paying net wages while the withheld taxes go unpaid is not "payroll first." It is the fact pattern that creates personal liability: a person responsible for collecting and paying over those taxes who willfully fails to do so is personally liable for the full amount (26 U.S.C. 6672), whatever the company's entity type and whatever happens in its bankruptcy. Paying other bills, employees' net wages included, while you know the withheld taxes are unpaid is generally treated as willful. If the cash will not cover both parts of the next payroll, stop and call your attorney and CPA before you run it.
  2. Pay the wages you owe, on the state's clock. State laws set deadlines for final paychecks, and unpaid wages carry penalties. That is one more reason to stop operating while you can still fund a complete final payroll, deposit included.
  3. Stop taking customer deposits and prepayments for work you cannot deliver.
  4. Give the notices the law requires. The federal WARN Act requires advance notice of plant closings and mass layoffs for covered employers, generally those with 100 or more employees, and some states have their own versions with lower thresholds. Ask counsel which apply.
  5. Protect the collateral and collect the receivables. One traditional searcher who closed a home health company in 2024 described on the Still Searching podcast writing the wind-down plan with the bank himself: who stays behind to collect receivables and deal with the assets. A lender that recovers more from the collateral leaves less on your guarantee.
  6. Do not pay favorites. Payments to insiders, or to some creditors over others, shortly before a bankruptcy can be clawed back (11 U.S.C. 547). Do not move assets out of the company or into family names.
  7. Close the paperwork. Final tax returns, payroll filings, licenses, registrations, and the state dissolution filing. Keep the records.

Step 7: Understand the settlement before you negotiate it

After the collateral is sold, what remains is the deficiency: the unpaid balance you owe under the guarantee. A settlement (sometimes called a compromise) is an agreement to pay less than that balance. On an SBA loan, the servicing rules in SOP 50 57 govern how the lender evaluates an offer in compromise and pursues guarantors (Y30). Expect the lender, and later the government, to require full financial disclosure before considering an offer, and to measure the offer against what they believe they could collect from you.

Three things travel with any settlement:

  • The prior-loss rule. As above, a compromise counts as a loss under SOP 50 10 8.1 for future SBA eligibility.
  • Taxes. Forgiven debt can be taxable income to the person or company that borrowed it (26 U.S.C. 61(a)(11)). There are exclusions, including for debt discharged in bankruptcy or while insolvent (26 U.S.C. 108), claimed on IRS Form 982. The loan here was made to the company, and you signed as guarantor. Whether a settlement produces income at the company, whether that income reaches you through an LLC or S corporation, and how a guarantor who settles for less is treated are separate questions with different answers. This lesson does not answer them. Have a CPA work through them, and any Form 1099-C that arrives, before you sign.
  • Confidentiality and releases. Anecdotally, from the failures this school has studied, roughly 8 out of 10 post-close acquisition failures end in some mix of litigation, bankruptcy and a settlement carrying confidentiality or non-disparagement terms. Read what you are agreeing not to say, and to whom.

Where to go for help

  • Your lender's workout or special assets group. Ask for it by name. It is the unit with authority to agree to anything.
  • A restructuring or bankruptcy attorney licensed in your state, plus a CPA. Many will do an initial consultation before you commit.
  • The SBA. Your SBA district office and SBA's resource partners, including Small Business Development Centers and SCORE, can explain the programs and point you to local help. They do not represent you against your lender.
  • The U.S. Trustee Program and your bankruptcy court's website explain how bankruptcy cases work, in plain language (Y43). Lesson 8.4.3 is this school's walk-through.

Deliverable

A Bad Day Binder, built in your first month of ownership while everything is fine:

Section What goes in it
Guarantee map Every loan and lease, its balance, who guaranteed it, full or limited, and every lien on personal property
Document set The note, loan agreement, guaranty, security agreements, seller note and standby agreement, lease
13-week cash flow The live forecast, updated weekly
Triggers Your written fix, sell or close triggers, agreed with your spouse or a mentor
Contacts Lender relationship manager, restructuring attorney, CPA, SBA district office
Wind-down order The Step 6 list, adapted to your state and industry

For the fictional Coastal Comfort HVAC case, the guarantee map starts with three lines: a $3,030,000 SBA 7(a) loan with the buyer's unlimited personal guaranty; Seller Note A, $500,000, subordinated and on full standby until the SBA loan is paid in full, with interest accruing at about $30,000 a year, then repaid over five years, and due in full if the business is sold (about $650,000 at a year-5 sale); and Seller Note B, $250,000, subordinated and paying about $3,652 a month for 84 months. That is $3,780,000 of debt at closing. The three outside investors each own less than 20 percent and guarantee nothing, so the only personal guaranty on the map is yours. Whether a fourth line exists, a lien on real estate you own, depends on the collateral shortfall rules above. You want to know that answer at closing, not at the workout table. Write the triggers knowing how thin the margin is. The case's bear year (earnings of $583,000 on the quality of earnings basis) covers its debt 1.11 times, clearing the 1.10 floor by a hair; two points on the variable SBA rate take that to about 1.03 times; and the same bear year leaves about $77,000 less cash than the business needs after debt, capital spending and tax, money that comes from you. A deal that close to its floor reaches the first trigger in one bad season, which is why the call to the lender has to be early.

This lesson is education, not legal, tax or lending advice. Bankruptcy, guarantee and collection rules are complex and vary by state. Before you sign a forbearance agreement, settlement or bankruptcy petition, get advice from a licensed attorney and CPA.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

Can the SBA take my house if my business fails?

It can reach it. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, if business assets do not cover the loan, the lender must take available equity in personal real estate solely owned by 20 percent owners and guarantors. It is not required to take a lien where equity is below 25 percent of fair market value. For a home owned jointly with a spouse, the lender must consider taking a lien.

Does a business bankruptcy wipe out my personal guarantee?

No. A business bankruptcy is the company's case and does not touch your personal guarantee, which is your separate contract. The lender can pursue you on it while the company's case runs. An individual Chapter 7 filing can discharge debts including a personal guarantee; Chapter 13 puts you on a court-supervised repayment plan.

Can I get another SBA loan after settling a defaulted one?

Possibly not. SOP 50 10 8.1 makes an applicant ineligible for a 7(a) or 504 loan if a business it owned or controlled caused a prior loss to the federal government, and loss includes any amount compromised for less than the full balance or discharged in bankruptcy. Guarantor names are also referred for listing in CAIVRS.

What should I pay first when closing a failing business?

Wages and the taxes withheld from them, together, as one payment. Withheld income and payroll taxes are held in trust for the government, and a responsible person who willfully fails to pay them over is personally liable under 26 U.S.C. 6672. Paying net wages while the withheld taxes go unpaid is what creates that liability. Never run a payroll you cannot fund in full. Then stop taking customer deposits, give required notices, protect the collateral, and do not pay insiders or favored creditors.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. H16

    Balcaen, S., Manigart, S., Buyze, J., & Ooghe, H (2012). Firm exit after distress: Differentiating between bankruptcy, voluntary liquidation and M&A. Small Business Economics, 39(4), 949-975.

  2. M8

    Matt Littell, David Rosner, A. J. Wasserstein. (2023). When to Give Up on Your Search Fund Dream. Yale Case, no number printed, March 10, 2023.

  3. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.

  4. Y31

    Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (). 13 CFR Part 120, Business Loans.

  5. Y30

    U.S. Small Business Administration (). SOP 50 57, 7(a) Loan Servicing and Liquidation.

  6. Y44

    Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts (). Chapter 7 - Bankruptcy Basics.

  7. Y46

    Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts (). Chapter 13 - Bankruptcy Basics.

  8. Y41

    U.S. Congress (2026). H.R. 7730, Bankruptcy Threshold Adjustment Act of 2026. 119th Congress.

  9. Y43

    U.S. Department of Justice, U.S. Trustee Program (). Subchapter V.