Skip to content
CurriculumToolsLibraryCommunitySign in
Join the community

Curriculum/Part II: Failure Literacy: The Case Record/Bought a Lie

Lesson 2.2.4

The Numbers Guy

A swim school where every figure the seller handed over was true and the picture was false: unpaid owner labor, promises never written down, costs that never reached the books. Reconciling to bank statements and tax returns is where diligence starts, and the costs that never touched the account are what it has to find.

Lesson 7 of 14 in this part · 7 minute read · Draft, under review

Short answer

How do I verify a seller's discretionary earnings before buying a small business?

Trace every dollar of earnings to evidence: bank deposits, signed tax returns, paid bills and vendors confirming prices. Reconcile twelve to twenty-four months of revenue and expenses to the bank, then hunt for costs that never touched the account: unpaid owner labor, promised raises, unpaid commissions, bills paid from another account, prepaid service still owed and marketing cut before closing.

Some sellers do not lie in any single number. Every figure they hand you is true, and the picture the figures build is false: costs that never reached the books, promises that were never written down, spending switched off while you were reading. This lesson follows a buyer with finance degrees and a job reading industry numbers who bought a small swim school whose earnings were almost entirely phantom. When the books themselves are the thing being sold, only evidence counts.

Principle

A P&L is testimony. Evidence is cash in a bank account, a tax return signed under penalty, a bill paid on schedule, a vendor confirming a price out loud. Every dollar of earnings has to trace to evidence, and every cost the business needs has to be on the page.

The number most small deals are priced on is SDE (seller's discretionary earnings): profit before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, plus the owner's own pay and personal expenses run through the business. It answers one question: how much cash would one full-time owner-operator take home? That makes it easy to inflate in a way that is technically true. If the owner works thirty hours a week and pays himself nothing, the work is real, the cost is real, and neither appears anywhere.

Sellers have reason to shape the year before a sale. A 2023 study of 331 Belgian private family firms found that owners planning to transfer ownership to outsiders managed earnings more than those planning a family succession (C55). And small private companies have no outside party forcing their statements to mean anything; research on privately held small businesses shows how much the production and sophistication of their financial statements varies with who demands them (C58, 2009).

On a small deal, you are the quality of earnings provider. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026 (Y25), a formal QoE is required only when the purchase price of an Initial Acquisition or a Business Expansion is $3 million or more. Below that, the lender must still verify the seller's tax information with IRS tax transcripts (through IRS Form 4506-C or Form 8821). That confirms the return you were shown is the return that was filed. It does not confirm that the return is complete or the earnings are real. Make your offer contingent on reviewing the tax returns and walk away if the seller refuses, as a broker quoted in a 2007 newspaper advice column recommended (JD10). Then go further than the returns.

Case

The case comes from Buyer Beware, chapter 12, "The Numbers Guy." Names are the book's pseudonyms.

Eric Sandoval had a finance degree and a master's in business, and worked at the head office of a national children's swim school chain building dashboards for its school owners. Those dashboards showed revenue, never expenses. He studied the field for years, spoke with about twenty owners, and read the books on 62 swim schools before choosing the 63rd: an independent school across town with sixteen instructors and card-on-file billing.

Most schools that size, he believed, earned their owner maybe $60,000 a year. This one claimed about $180,000. The price was about $550,000: about $55,000 down, about $55,000 as a seller note, and about $450,000 from a government-backed bank loan. Eric and his wife both personally guaranteed it, and he took on a ten-year lease, guaranteed again. Payroll, rent and debt service ran $25,000 to $30,000 a month.

There were two sellers. One was the head coach, on the deck nearly thirty hours a week, the person families came for. The other kept the books and was a working CPA, which made Eric trust the numbers more.

His diligence was serious. He rebuilt profit from raw bank statements instead of the sellers' spreadsheets. He enrolled his toddler and spent three months inside the school as a paying parent. He searched both sellers in county court records under the names on the listing. He skipped two things: an outside accountant, and calls to any vendor.

Day one cost $20,000: the general manager had been promised a raise out loud, and Eric raised her from $45,000 to $65,000 to keep her. The first month brought four new families instead of the twenty to thirty he modeled, and a $7,000 loss instead of a $6,000 profit. After a second loss, he rebuilt the business at his kitchen table and found the books cooked three ways:

  • Phantom earnings. The coach's thirty hours a week were never paid. Commissions owed never appeared as a cost. Staff were paid below market. About $170,000 of the claimed $180,000 disappeared.
  • A pre-closing fire sale. The sellers sold discounted prepaid lesson packages, about $1,800 for a year, in the final weeks. The cash landed before closing and stayed with them. The lessons were owed after closing, by Eric.
  • Ads switched off. Marketing of $2,000 to $3,000 a month was cut to zero three months before closing, flattering profit while starving the pipeline.

A small tell sealed it: a software tool cost $100 a month, and the bank statements showed $10. A seller had paid the rest from an account Eric never saw. "They gave me numbers that were factually correct," he said, "and they lied with every one of them." Then he searched the CPA's full legal name in county records and found years of money cases, judgments and forged checks.

Families quit at twice the normal rate once the coach was gone. Losses settled near $8,000 a month, and the school closed almost a year after it was bought. Eric and his wife filed Chapter 7 and received a discharge in under ninety days. They lost about $55,000 of down payment and about $100,000 more in losses covered and pay forgone.

Steps

These are the checks that would have caught it. Most cost nothing but time.

1. Do a proof of cash, then hunt for what is missing

Reconcile twelve to twenty-four months of revenue to bank deposits and expenses to disbursements (lesson 6.1.1). Eric did this, and it was not enough, because a bank-statement rebuild cannot show a cost that never touched the account. So run the missing-cost hunt next.

2. Map every hour of labor

List every role the business needs and every person who fills it, with weekly hours and actual pay:

Role Who does it now Hours per week Paid now Market cost to replace

SDE already assumes one full-time owner-operator, so do not subtract the one full-time job you will personally do. Subtract the market cost of everything beyond it: every other role filled by an owner, a relative or a volunteer at below-market pay, and any owner role you cannot fill yourself. Eric kept his day job and planned three hours a week on a deck where the head coach had spent nearly thirty, so that coaching was a wage he would have to pay. A seller working thirty hours a week for nothing, in a job you will not do, is not an add-back. It is a hole (RF-04, RF-11).

3. Ask about promises that are not on paper

  1. Interview key employees before closing, with the seller's agreement, and ask directly whether they have been promised raises, bonuses, commissions or titles.
  2. Ask for a list of all commissions earned but unpaid.
  3. Put a representation in the purchase agreement that no undisclosed compensation promises exist, with an indemnity if one surfaces.

4. Call the vendors

For the ten largest recurring expenses, compare the invoice, the bank debit and the vendor's own statement of the price. Call each vendor and confirm the rate and the account holder. A $10 line that should read $100 is a $90 lie, and one phone call finds it.

5. Count the prepaid money

Get a schedule of every prepaid package, gift card, deposit or membership paid in advance: who paid, how much, how much service is still owed. That is deferred revenue, a liability: the customer has paid and you still owe the work. Require a credit against the price at closing for every dollar of it, and compare pre-closing sales of prepaid packages against the same months in prior years.

6. Freeze the business between signing and closing

Ask your attorney for operating covenants: from LOI to closing, the business runs as it normally does. Marketing stays at its historical level, no discounting or special promotions, no prepaid sales outside the normal pattern, no changes to pay. Then check marketing spend by month for the last twelve months. A drop in the final quarter is a flag on its own.

Search county, state and federal court records (PACER for federal cases) under each seller's full legal name, every prior name, and every entity they own. Not the friendly name on the listing. Add state professional licensing boards for anyone with a license. It costs little or nothing, and it is the step that would have stopped this deal.

8. Price the seller's personal pull on customers

If customers come for a person who is leaving, test it: how many accounts started after that person joined, how many cite them in reviews, and what attrition looked like when they took time away. Then model churn after closing at a level that assumes they are gone.

Deliverable

An Evidence Ledger for every line of the seller's earnings:

P&L line Seller's figure Evidence type (bank, tax return, invoice, vendor call, payroll) Evidence amount Gap Status

Attach:

  • The labor map from step 2, with your adjusted SDE.
  • The prepaid liability schedule and the closing credit it requires.
  • Monthly marketing spend for twelve months.
  • Court and licensing search results under each seller's full legal name, dated.

Any line without evidence is removed from earnings until it has some. Price the business on what is left.

This lesson is education, not accounting or legal advice. A licensed CPA should review the financials of any business you intend to buy, whatever its size.

Common questions

Asked about this lesson

What is SDE (seller's discretionary earnings)?

SDE is profit before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, plus the owner's own pay and personal expenses run through the business. It answers one question: how much cash would one full-time owner-operator take home? It is easy to inflate in a way that is technically true, for example when an owner works thirty hours a week and pays himself nothing.

Is a quality of earnings report required for an SBA loan under $3 million?

No. Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, a formal quality of earnings report is required only when the purchase price of an Initial Acquisition or a Business Expansion is $3 million or more. Below that, the lender must still verify the seller's tax information with IRS tax transcripts, which confirms the return shown is the return filed, not that the earnings are real.

What is deferred revenue when buying a business?

Deferred revenue is money customers paid in advance for service still owed: prepaid packages, gift cards, deposits, memberships. It is a liability, because you will owe the work after closing. Get a schedule of who paid, how much and what is still owed, and require a credit against the price at closing for every dollar of it.

How do I run a background check on a business seller?

Search county, state and federal court records, including PACER for federal cases, under each seller's full legal name, every prior name and every entity they own, not the friendly name on the listing. Add state professional licensing boards for anyone with a license. The search costs little or nothing.

More answers on the buyer FAQ.

Sources

From the Library

  1. C55

    Umans, I., & Corten, M (2023). Ownership succession intentions affecting earnings management in private family firms. Small Business Economics, 61(2), 827-842.

  2. C58

    Allee, K. D., & Yohn, T. L (2009). The demand for financial statements in an unregulated environment: An examination of the production and use of financial statements by privately held small businesses. The Accounting Review, 84(1), 1-25.

  3. JD10

    Klein, Karen E (2007). Viewing tax filings in buying a business. Los Angeles Times.

  4. Y25

    U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, with Technical Policy Updates. Effective October 1, 2026.